Camellia VS S3RL debate thread

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #1
    Banned
    QueenAshy
    • Sep 2017
    • 606

    Camellia VS S3RL debate thread

    I think camellia is definitely better, very few of his songs sound the same, his samples are all of good quality, and he knows how to make interesting songs even without variable BPM.

    S3RL on the other hand, while he has some good songs, he sucks at variety. Yeah, he has a few good songs like Candy, R4V3 BOY, and Hentai; but for every one of those, there’s like 5 more songs that are lackluster at best. A lot of S3RL tracks are like TheFatRat, they all sound similar, and I often have trouble telling them apart.

    None of these artists are bad, just one is amazing, and one is good.

    I want to hear some more varying opinions on the subject
  • #2
    FFR Simfile Author
    FFR Simfile Author
    -Tim-
    • Dec 2014
    • 425

    Re: Camellia VS S3RL debate thread

    I don't know what kind of comparison this is given that Camellia works in a variety of genres while S3RL is a UK hardcore/happy hardcore artist

    It doesn't make any sense


    Comment

    • #3
      FFR Player
      FFR Simfile Author
      riktoi
      • Oct 2016
      • 131

      Re: Camellia VS S3RL debate thread

      generic anime girl google image search vs generic anime pixiv background

      Comment

      • #4
        ✘ Forever OP✘
        FFR Simfile Author
        xXOpkillerXx
        • Dec 2008
        • 4219

        Re: Camellia VS S3RL debate thread

        yes

        Comment

        • #5
          Banned
          QueenAshy
          • Sep 2017
          • 606

          Re: Camellia VS S3RL debate thread

          Originally posted by riktoi
          generic anime girl google image search vs generic anime pixiv background
          Yep

          Comment

          • #6
            Banned
            FFR Simfile Author
            choof
            • Nov 2013
            • 8596

            Re: Camellia VS S3RL debate thread

            I could make massive wall posts about electronic music and how it differs from culture to culture but a tl;dr version is that with most genres of electronic music, unless you're comparing very early releases in said genres, japanese vs non japanese is going to be extremely different.

            edit: I just realized that this is in critical thinking lmao we're not talking about artsy fartsy electronic music like ryoji ikeda vs alva noto or music culture in general
            remake the thread in cc
            Last edited by choof; 09-12-2018, 03:36 PM.

            Comment

            • #7
              Banned
              QueenAshy
              • Sep 2017
              • 606

              Re: Camellia VS S3RL debate thread

              Originally posted by choof
              I could make massive wall posts about electronic music and how it differs from culture to culture but a tl;dr version is that with most genres of electronic music, unless you're comparing very early releases in said genres, japanese vs non japanese is going to be extremely different.

              edit: I just realized that this is in critical thinking lmao we're not talking about artsy fartsy electronic music like ryoji ikeda vs alva noto or music culture in general
              remake the thread in cc
              Debate threads can go in critical thinking. Any sort of debate can have worth.

              Comment

              • #8
                Signature Extraordinare~~
                Event Staff
                Game Manager
                FFR Simfile Author
                FFR Music Producer
                Global Moderator
                gold stinger
                • Jan 2007
                • 6478

                Re: Camellia VS S3RL debate thread

                Originally posted by riktoi
                generic anime girl google image search vs generic anime pixiv background
                Originally posted by xXOpkillerXx
                yes
                Originally posted by QueenAshy
                Yep
                C R I T I C A L

                T H O N K A N G S
                Last edited by gold stinger; 09-12-2018, 03:50 PM.
                Originally posted by YoshL
                butts.


                - Tosh 2014






                Comment

                • #9
                  FFR Player
                  ddr_f4n
                  • Sep 2005
                  • 3807

                  Re: Camellia VS S3RL debate thread

                  I don't understand why you want to compare these two specifically.
                  Out Now!


                  Older Releases:
                  Vocaloid: Project Pad Pack 3rd
                  Gpop's Pack of Original Pad Simfiles
                  東方幻想踊 (Touhou Gensouyou) ~ Illusionary Dance Fantasy & Vocaloid: Project Pad Pack 2nd

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    Banned
                    FFR Simfile Author
                    choof
                    • Nov 2013
                    • 8596

                    Re: Camellia VS S3RL debate thread

                    Originally posted by QueenAshy
                    Debate threads can go in critical thinking. Any sort of debate can have worth.
                    this isn't a debate thread, all you said was "camellia good bcuz interdastign s3rl not so good bcuz borign tell me what U think" so there's nothing really to debate. you're just posting an opinion.

                    if you wanted to make a critical thinking thread about these two artists in the grand scheme of japanese vs non-japanese electronic music then by all means set up a topic for debate. but this is not a critical thinking thread. read the rules and check rule 2, and then read "what makes a good ct thread." this thread specifically breaks rule 2 and then sits firmly in the "poor thread" category

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      FFR Player
                      FFR Simfile Author
                      riktoi
                      • Oct 2016
                      • 131

                      Re: Camellia VS S3RL debate thread

                      Originally posted by gold stinger
                      C R I T I C A L

                      T H O N K A N G S
                      sorry i was baited by shitposts

                      anyway what choof said is correct. to have a fitting debate for x artist vs y artist you'd have to at least have two artists that do the same thing, not two artists that have completely different goals and genre choices in general.
                      with that said, if you really wanna get into like ultra generalisation of said artists yes, there are similarities.
                      both produce electronic music.
                      both have similar sounding songs to their other production (note: this applies to basically every single artist ever). camellia has more complex song structure and is nicer to listen to if you want something for stepping LMAO. s3rl again has very similar sounding songs with very comfortable structure so if you like that all power to you. both are nice for listening for different reasons (as long as you don't actually have massive bias towards their genres).
                      Last edited by riktoi; 09-12-2018, 04:13 PM.

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        Snivy! Dohoho!
                        FFR Simfile Author
                        Charu
                        • Mar 2006
                        • 6263

                        Re: Camellia VS S3RL debate thread

                        I don't see a reason for a need for this subforum anyways since plenty of debates have been done in good ol' chit chat.

                        But I suppose this is the place to go if you don't want one liner posts as a response...
                        Last edited by Charu; 09-12-2018, 04:29 PM.


                        Originally posted by JohnRedWolf87
                        Charu the red-nosed Snivy
                        Had a very shiny nose
                        And if you ever saw it
                        You could even say it glows

                        All of the other Snivies
                        Used to laugh and call him names
                        They never let poor Charu
                        Join in any Snivy games

                        (Click the arrow to see the rest)


                        Originally posted by Vendetta21
                        All in all I would say that Charu not only won this game, his play made me reconsider how I play it.

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          Banned
                          QueenAshy
                          • Sep 2017
                          • 606

                          Re: Camellia VS S3RL debate thread

                          Originally posted by choof
                          this isn't a debate thread, all you said was "camellia good bcuz interdastign s3rl not so good bcuz borign tell me what U think" so there's nothing really to debate. you're just posting an opinion.
                          You always have to begin a persuasive essay in debate/English classes by introducing both sides. I’m providing my opinion so others can build off it.

                          Also, what the heck is that even supposed to mean in the quotes? I literally have no idea what you’re trying to say

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            魔法少女
                            Mahou
                            • Jan 2006
                            • 2166

                            Re: Camellia VS S3RL debate thread

                            This thread/topic is not debateable because your argument is not built on factual information. You’re just appealing to your own personal preference.

                            I can’t wait till you’re banned. You have not changed.
                            Last edited by Mahou; 09-12-2018, 05:42 PM.
                            Originally posted by lofty rhino
                            one does not simply hate everyone that plays stepmania
                            AND watch anime.

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              Banned
                              QueenAshy
                              • Sep 2017
                              • 606

                              Re: Camellia VS S3RL debate thread

                              Originally posted by Mahou
                              I can’t wait till you’re banned. You have not changed.
                              Did you not get the memo that I've been on really low estrogen for the past few days cause my patches aren't working correctly?

                              Well, maybe people would know if they cared. But since they didn't, they always act like I'm the bad guy.

                              WELL MAYBE IT'S CAUSE MY MEDICATION DOESN'T WORK CORRECTLY, OR ISN'T WORKING CORRECTLY.

                              IF YOU DON'T LIKE THE THREAD, DON'T VIEW IT! I DON'T NEED MORE SHIT GOING ON RIGHT NOW!

                              I'm distressed enough as it is....

                              Comment

                              Working...