The first was Chardish's scenario that Kilga and Kefit are close and so to kill the other keeps decption a little easier from being found out.
The problem is that as wolf, you wouldnt want to kill one of those that you can use to inflitrate the alliance system. A close friend is an easy catch that way, and so I am not sure he would want to kill him. (Unless Kilga thinks he doesn't have the skills to pull if off.) That would mean Kilga wouldnt be a wolf, because he would want kefit to live.
or
This is from my experience as a wolf. I killed LD last game as a preventive measure. People always want to go back to those that they talked to last game. LD was good at bringing things together in Game 2, and after the end I learned that he was a role. To kill some one who was a role in last game is somewhat helpful, in that their role experince can be passed down. LD also has the smarts about him.
The kefit of game 3 could have been chosen like the LD of game 2 was.
If kilga could have analyzed my above logic, (which I doubt) then he would have known that putting it on me worked well.
Of course, that would mean that it wouldnt be a random choice.
Shows that he didnt have the analysis of me, and he just throws out whoever put his name out in post game.
Why post game? Why not look at last game? Post game says nothing about a person, because nobody had this games roles. You have no idea how roles will change things from then, to follow last games logic, I would have hit The_Q.
By the way, is anyone else going to talk? I dont want this to be as inactive as last game.
Edit: Tass/chardish thing was fixed. Sorry.
The problem is that as wolf, you wouldnt want to kill one of those that you can use to inflitrate the alliance system. A close friend is an easy catch that way, and so I am not sure he would want to kill him. (Unless Kilga thinks he doesn't have the skills to pull if off.) That would mean Kilga wouldnt be a wolf, because he would want kefit to live.
or
This is from my experience as a wolf. I killed LD last game as a preventive measure. People always want to go back to those that they talked to last game. LD was good at bringing things together in Game 2, and after the end I learned that he was a role. To kill some one who was a role in last game is somewhat helpful, in that their role experince can be passed down. LD also has the smarts about him.
The kefit of game 3 could have been chosen like the LD of game 2 was.
Kefit seems a rather random choice for a Day 1 kill to me since he didn't do too much last game vocally. The only person I can think of that might have reason to kill him is Cenright...
Of course, that would mean that it wouldnt be a random choice.
...given the postgame comments from Game 3
Why post game? Why not look at last game? Post game says nothing about a person, because nobody had this games roles. You have no idea how roles will change things from then, to follow last games logic, I would have hit The_Q.
By the way, is anyone else going to talk? I dont want this to be as inactive as last game.
Edit: Tass/chardish thing was fixed. Sorry.
Comment