TWG 150: Undertale

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • TWG Tsunderplane
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    so i think i missed this somewhere and i do not have anywhere near the patience required to read through the thread again right now but why are you so certain that sans is charu again

    this is a legitimate question, i'm not even trying to imply anything here

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Alphys
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    I guess a plan is possible, but we would've had to talk about the plan.

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Mad Dummy
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Alphys
    you were generally townread at the time and sans was scummy which is why it came to the point that he actually had to put a list out there to look good.
    yes, but we would've had to have planned it out the night before in wolfchat, and the previous day neither of us had any heat at all.

    I have to admit that if I were a partner with Charu I would

    a) be really happy
    b) swear that I would never stop pushing him if he tried to bus me

    so I guess its more plausible than I at first figured, but we still would've had to plan it out the night before.

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Mad Dummy
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Honestly, looking back, the possibility of it being only one is like... slightly reinforced by Sans read on Undyne. The only time that Charu doesn't bus is when he feels like a partner is posting literally perfectly. I have only seen this happen once, which was during the smash game. I'll do a comparison of the read on Undyne there and a read on his partner during that game.

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Alphys
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    So I fail to see what's so weird about it

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Alphys
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Mad Dummy
    You think its a play set up days in advance? Its also reliant on the fact that Charu dies while I am alive, which would be weird. It would defeat most of the purpose of the reads post, no?

    I mean I guess I see where you're coming from, but that's some shiny tinfoil you're wearing.
    you were generally townread at the time and sans was scummy which is why it came to the point that he actually had to put a list out there to look good.

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Tsunderplane
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Mad Dummy
    it seems very very very very much that he is not switching his play up because of the fact that his townreads are 100% accurate. I so desperately wish that both you and Napsta are town because it would be the least Charu has bused before and like... its never good play to do what he does. He wins games off of it despite me trying to convince people to kill him. It took a modkill for him to die in the Supermarket game, not me trying to talk people into killing him. He won in the Smash game super super late. He probably wouldn't have died this game without Alphys's check. But in doing so he kills his entire team. I am illustrating this because the fact that he keeps winning games as a wolf in spite of the fact that he does this makes it somewhat clear that it gives him reason to continue busing.

    I really, really would love it if both you and Napsta are town, but I highly doubt this. My citation is years of playing with him and several Skype conversations where I try to convince him that townreading partners, while you inherently don't believe what you are saying, is good wolf strategy, especially if you have a strong meta attached to you. He never agrees.
    and this is exactly what a clever player would exploit when he feels people would least expect it

    perhaps i'm giving charu too much credit; i'll readily admit that possibility. but if i was in his situation, and had gained notoriety for routinely bussing my entire team, i don't see how i could possibly pass up the opportunity to mindfuck everyone by not doing it

    that you so firmly believe that this could not ever possibly change is what makes me believe this is actually happening

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Mad Dummy
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Alphys
    Because of your entire current argument
    You think its a play set up days in advance? Its also reliant on the fact that Charu dies while I am alive, which would be weird. It would defeat most of the purpose of the reads post, no?

    I mean I guess I see where you're coming from, but that's some shiny tinfoil you're wearing.

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Papyrus
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Temmie
    what is the possibility of Sans being Charu?
    welp i can't use this for scumreading anymore

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Mad Dummy
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Tsunderplane
    i honestly don't think it's that outlandish that a player would choose to switch up their play precisely when everyone thinks they have it figured out.

    pretending to bus a partner that turns out to be town would be so easy to pull off if people are expecting you to turn in your entire team. from what i've seen of charu's play (admittedly not as much as you) i have more faith that they would eventually cotton onto this as a valid path
    it seems very very very very much that he is not switching his play up because of the fact that his townreads are 100% accurate. I so desperately wish that both you and Napsta are town because it would be the least Charu has bused before and like... its never good play to do what he does. He wins games off of it despite me trying to convince people to kill him. It took a modkill for him to die in the Supermarket game, not me trying to talk people into killing him. He won in the Smash game super super late. He probably wouldn't have died this game without Alphys's check. But in doing so he kills his entire team. I am illustrating this because the fact that he keeps winning games as a wolf in spite of the fact that he does this makes it somewhat clear that it gives him reason to continue busing.

    I really, really would love it if both you and Napsta are town, but I highly doubt this. My citation is years of playing with him and several Skype conversations where I try to convince him that townreading partners, while you inherently don't believe what you are saying, is good wolf strategy, especially if you have a strong meta attached to you. He never agrees.

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Alphys
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Mad Dummy
    You need to propose a reason why Charu would not be busing me here.
    Because of your entire current argument

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Tsunderplane
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    god damn i have such a headache right now

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Alphys
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Mad Dummy
    The second posts addresses the fact that Alphys did not give any reasoning as to why they believe Sans would not be busing their entire team. I ask them about their reasoning as to why, which I find especially confusing considering they were on Charu's team the game that I am quoting from, so they should know firsthard that Charu will bus in such a manner.
    This game was a while ago, so I forgot exactly who all was on our team. I believe 2 of our team were barely posting anything so bussing them was great since it made us look better and didn't hinder our progress from what we were doing already. I fucked up as Chicken and was getting flack, so Charu was also in the right here to let me go to give our team the best chance at winning.

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Tsunderplane
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Mad Dummy
    The first is just establishing that he has bused his entire team before. It does not ever say that this \is\ the scenario, just that it is possible.

    The second posts addresses the fact that Alphys did not give any reasoning as to why they believe Sans would not be busing their entire team. I ask them about their reasoning as to why, which I find especially confusing considering they were on Charu's team the game that I am quoting from, so they should know firsthard that Charu will bus in such a manner.

    The third comments on the fact that Charu has bused hard before. He doesn't feel like its a strategy that will likely backfire. The one partner he put in his scumreads would be So Sorry, the Godfather. It doesn't make sense for him to put him in his scumreads, since his town list was 100% accurate, and not put at least, not both, but at least one partner in his scumreads, at least from my point of view.

    Please reread over my posts. I am not advocating for your death. I am stating the possibility that you and Napsta is the team. I am doing so with a vote on neither of you. Please try to keep all of this in mind.
    i understand that now, so let me try to make a calmer post about this

    in my mind, these posts very much sound like you firmly believe this scenario and are not very much willing to entertain the possibility that you are wrong. perhaps i'm not reading you well and that's just how you put forth ideas, but that was the vibe i was getting off of it

    what helps solidify this view is when questioned about it, you double down and insist that the onus is on them to disprove your scenario instead of accepting alternate possibilities

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Mad Dummy
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Tsunderplane
    just for starters

    these are not the posts of someone who thinks this is a mere possibility
    The first is just establishing that he has bused his entire team before. It does not ever say that this \is\ the scenario, just that it is possible.

    The second posts addresses the fact that Alphys did not give any reasoning as to why they believe Sans would not be busing their entire team. I ask them about their reasoning as to why, which I find especially confusing considering they were on Charu's team the game that I am quoting from, so they should know firsthard that Charu will bus in such a manner.

    The third comments on the fact that Charu has bused hard before. He doesn't feel like its a strategy that will likely backfire. The one partner he put in his scumreads would be So Sorry, the Godfather. It doesn't make sense for him to put him in his scumreads, since his town list was 100% accurate, and not put at least, not both, but at least one partner in his scumreads, at least from my point of view.

    Please reread over my posts. I am not advocating for your death. I am stating the possibility that you and Napsta is the team. I am doing so with a vote on neither of you. Please try to keep all of this in mind.

    Leave a comment:

Working...