TWG 150: Undertale

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • TWG Tsunderplane
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Mad Dummy
    was he being scumread the day before? I mean his vote at EOD was weird, but he wasn't being scumread that I can remember.
    if it wasn't already past the time i needed to be in bed i'd go back and look, but i distinctly remember he was getting pressured even the day before he got lynched

    maybe not as aggressively as the day he died, but he certainly wasn't getting townread

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Mad Dummy
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Alphys
    You're missing some stuff in here.
    can you fill in the blanks then?

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Tsunderplane
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Mad Dummy
    Ok. The way that we began interacting, the way he made fun of me for being "paranoid" of him when I posted the thing you and Alphys yelled at me for, I felt like I knew Sans was Charu right away. He always mocks (playfully, of course) me regardless of his alignment, he finds it fun. The post he made about Alphys being Gradiant is something I believe only Charu and myself would make, Gradiant doesn't play all that often and when he does, it is in anonymous games, and I feel like very few people would be able to pick him out of an anon game. The way he appealed to me, like bringing my reputation or whatever Undyne talked about when he was checked, was very distinctly in his language.

    I will say, as I've said before, that Sans not being Charu would be legitimately mindblowing to me.

    I cannot explain why Toriel ever dies the first night without Charu being on a scumteam.
    that makes sense, thank you for the explanation

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Mad Dummy
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Tsunderplane
    this loops us back to you being pretty clear in terms of town read and he was looking very scummy so this is not very far-fetched
    was he being scumread the day before? I mean his vote at EOD was weird, but he wasn't being scumread that I can remember.

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Temmie
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Papyrus
    welp i can't use this for scumreading anymore
    uh, can you provide further detail on what you mean?

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Mad Dummy
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Tsunderplane
    so i think i missed this somewhere and i do not have anywhere near the patience required to read through the thread again right now but why are you so certain that sans is charu again

    this is a legitimate question, i'm not even trying to imply anything here
    Ok. The way that we began interacting, the way he made fun of me for being "paranoid" of him when I posted the thing you and Alphys yelled at me for, I felt like I knew Sans was Charu right away. He always mocks (playfully, of course) me regardless of his alignment, he finds it fun. The post he made about Alphys being Gradiant is something I believe only Charu and myself would make, Gradiant doesn't play all that often and when he does, it is in anonymous games, and I feel like very few people would be able to pick him out of an anon game. The way he appealed to me, like bringing my reputation or whatever Undyne talked about when he was checked, was very distinctly in his language.

    I will say, as I've said before, that Sans not being Charu would be legitimately mindblowing to me.

    I cannot explain why Toriel ever dies the first night without Charu being on a scumteam.

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Alphys
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Tsunderplane
    i don't know everyone's playstyle well enough to decipher these things so i was curious
    The first is a kinda inside joke sorta thing. The other stuff is us 2 actually calling eachother out.

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Alphys
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Mad Dummy
    Random nightkills happen.
    I identify a player as Charu
    I call Charu out for said nightkills
    People laugh at my posts and don't understand or listen
    I attempt to get Charu killed while he kills most of his team
    I never succeed
    You're missing some stuff in here.

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Tsunderplane
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    i don't know everyone's playstyle well enough to decipher these things so i was curious

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Alphys
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    @tsunderplane or anybody questioning why charu is sans.

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Tsunderplane
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Mad Dummy
    its still reliant on the fact that he dies while I live, which is weird.
    this loops us back to you being pretty clear in terms of town read and he was looking very scummy so this is not very far-fetched

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Alphys
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Sans
    im toriel
    Originally posted by TWG Alphys
    There's the Charu I know
    Originally posted by TWG Sans
    there's the Gradiant I know
    these along with general attitude of posts after I claimed.

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Tsunderplane
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Mad Dummy
    I do hope you can understand why I feel like this situation is very, very unlikely to be different from before, especially when I feel like evidence has been presented (the fact that his townreads are perfect).
    no i do see where you're coming from if it's actually been that long but i can't shake the feeling that this is exactly what a good player would do in this situation. his townreads being perfect doesn't persuade me much because it's real easy to have perfect townreads when you're a wolf

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Mad Dummy
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Alphys
    I guess a plan is possible, but we would've had to talk about the plan.
    its still reliant on the fact that he dies while I live, which is weird.

    Leave a comment:


  • TWG Mad Dummy
    replied
    Re: TWG 150: Undertale

    Originally posted by TWG Tsunderplane
    and this is exactly what a clever player would exploit when he feels people would least expect it

    perhaps i'm giving charu too much credit; i'll readily admit that possibility. but if i was in his situation, and had gained notoriety for routinely bussing my entire team, i don't see how i could possibly pass up the opportunity to mindfuck everyone by not doing it

    that you so firmly believe that this could not ever possibly change is what makes me believe this is actually happening
    I've been trying to change it for 3 years and he hasn't budged. So that's why I think the alternative is very, very unlikely.

    Literally every recent anon game has gone like this (We've never been the same alignment in an anon game):

    Random nightkills happen.
    I identify a player as Charu
    I call Charu out for said nightkills
    People laugh at my posts and don't understand or listen
    I attempt to get Charu killed while he kills most of his team
    I never succeed

    I do hope you can understand why I feel like this situation is very, very unlikely to be different from before, especially when I feel like evidence has been presented (the fact that his townreads are perfect).

    Leave a comment:

Working...