TWG XC Host Signups

[Syhto]

Re: TWG XC Host Signups

ill host a normal psychic/seer just like the one before.

[Temote]

Re: TWG XC Host Signups

BDN's game sounds really interesting and I'd love to see it played out.

[Gun92]

Re: TWG XC Host Signups

Clair. All for the simplicity right now and hopefully it will make everyone a better player.

[u84]

Re: TWG XC Host Signups

Please choose Clarinet, guys. If TWC has any power, please veto all votes aside from Clarinet's game. We need to get this active TWG population back up to par and unless we play more original ****, no one will learn how to play the game we'll have ****tier and ****tier games. Please vote Clarinet, for your own sake people.

That counts as 3 votes because it is for Clarinet's game. Now it's 4 votes.

[FictionJunction]

Re: TWG XC Host Signups

there are 4 votes on a normal PSYCHIC/SEER/MASTERWOLF game to be hosted by either clarinet or syhto.
Gun, Makilaz, FictionJunction, u84

Mystery games are far out of this group's league since it has proven that it can't even analyze players properly in a game where the roles are public, much less analyze a game they know nothing about.

psychic/seer/MW game (hosted by syhto or clarinet) - 4 - FictionJunction, Makilaz, Gun, u84
BDN's game - 3 - tupac, Spyke, temote
mystery game - 0 - tupac

[FictionJunction]

Re: TWG XC Host Signups

I call for EXECUTIVE ORDER: Parental Supervision - TIME OUT.

The kids don't get to play with their toys until they've done their homework.

No 'cool games' with special roles until everyone has shown some sort of legitimate improvement playing games where they have no one but themselves to rely on.

This may sound cheesy but I really care about the sub-group. So, I propose that once the next game ends we have some sort of peer evaluation. Not something like Manti telling us how we performed as he has in other games. Everyone has someone to evaluate and we talk about our player in the post-game.

[Makilaz]

Re: TWG XC Host Signups

Seconded. This means we play only games with stock roles for a while. seer, guard, wolfsbane, psychic, master wolf. That's it.

And mystery games... just no. There have been far too many, far too complex, and it's making everyone worse and worse at the game.

[Ruritsu]

Re: TWG XC Host Signups

there are 4 votes on a normal PSYCHIC/SEER/MASTERWOLF game to be hosted by either clarinet or syhto.
Gun, Makilaz, FictionJunction, u84

Mystery games are far out of this group's league since it has proven that it can't even analyze players properly in a game where the roles are public, much less analyze a game they know nothing about.

psychic/seer/MW game (hosted by syhto or clarinet) - 5 - FictionJunction, Makilaz, Gun, u84, Ruritsu
BDN's game - 3 - tupac, Spyke, temote
mystery game - 0 - tupac

Fix'd.

[Gun92]

Re: TWG XC Host Signups

Seconded. This means we play only games with stock roles for a while. seer, guard, wolfsbane, psychic, master wolf. That's it.

And mystery games... just no. There have been far too many, far too complex, and it's making everyone worse and worse at the game.

+1 support

[Brilliant Dynamite Neon]

Re: TWG XC Host Signups

I call for EXECUTIVE ORDER: Parental Supervision - TIME OUT.

The kids don't get to play with their toys until they've done their homework.

No 'cool games' with special roles until everyone has shown some sort of legitimate improvement playing games where they have no one but themselves to rely on.

This may sound cheesy but I really care about the sub-group. So, I propose that once the next game ends we have some sort of peer evaluation. Not something like Manti telling us how we performed as he has in other games. Everyone has someone to evaluate and we talk about our player in the post-game.

I do support something like this, but does it mean a game like mine is out of the question? It may have nonstandard roles, but they are really simple, and I firmly believe that my game will be a good learning experience as well. I would like your thoughts on the matter.

I will take this to the TWC, and if people bother to show up and have a serious discussion, we will have an official vote on it.

[Makilaz]

Re: TWG XC Host Signups

I do support something like this, but does it mean a game like mine is out of the question? It may have nonstandard roles, but they are really simple, and I firmly believe that my game will be a good learning experience as well. I would like your thoughts on the matter.

I will take this to the TWC, and if people bother to show up and have a serious discussion, we will have an official vote on it.

Yes. I'm willing to discuss it with the rest of TWC, but all these nonstandard roles are also not helping. We need to play a lot of games with roles ONLY from the TWG beginner's guide. Guard. Psychic. Wolfsbane. Seer. Master Wolf. Once everyone can learn how to play again, then we can progress to more advanced stuff,

[tupacodaman]

Re: TWG XC Host Signups

omg ..... I explained why I voted for a mystery game and I took it off for BDN's anyway, why do you still feel like you have to single me out fic...

again, I don't mind playing these standard games, but everyone is so freaking inactive. I got subbed in and was pretty active, though I will admit I wasn't UBER SUPER active. too bad everyone else who was active had a mighty bad temper and thought I should die for simply offering an idea. there's nothing wrong with the games we've been playing, it's the general inactivity. and the fact that the active ones are way too aggressive and need to chill just a bit. anyway, it's not going to get better if we have 12+ player games where a third or so of the players are generally inactive throughout the game. again, to prove my point: last game where I was a wolf, only two people who were not wolves talked to me (and we ended up making roundbox our wolf bitch , so really only one). say all you want, but it's very rare for any one player to talk to EVERY one. I did that during the sonic game and ended up getting lynched after getting almost everyone's role. and of course, fic yelled at me for taking the mystery out of the game. hello? hypocrisy? I was being active and socially engineering to figure out who was bs'ing based on what they told me and what I knew from past games with each player...

just my two cents though. do what you guys want

[Gun92]

Re: TWG XC Host Signups

I'm not quite so sure why people are taking this regression of games so hard. It should be common knowledge that almost all of us can not play games as a green and rely too heavily on having a lot of special roles so we can feel more "involved" in the game. It has been said before, but the games are only as good as we make them and its up to you to make yourself involved in the game regardless of role.

I'm sure that no one has anything against your game BDN considering all of us know that you make and host great games, but as bad as it is, I really do think we need to go back to basics for awhile. There's only a select few who play TWG that are really good enough to play in the more complicated games and the rest of us need to learn how to be good so the games we play in that are more complicated can be even more interesting and challenging. Perhaps I'm just rambling here, but thats my opinion on the matter.

[FictionJunction]

Re: TWG XC Host Signups

**** the TWC. The problem is obvious. The solution is obvious. You wouldn't be the only one taking a hit from this decision, BDN. There are games that I'd like to host too, but I'm willing to put that aside for now because I think this is far more important than showing off our abilities as hosts and game makers.

[FictionJunction]

Re: TWG XC Host Signups

stop crying, tupac. I'm not singling you out. We all are.

you screwed up last game. Big deal. go play the next one.