FFR Community Pack Autumn 2011 (Submissions Open)

[bmah]

Re: FFR Community Pack Autumn 2011 (Submissions Open)

So the pack might be released after the 21st?

[Gundam-Dude]

Re: FFR Community Pack Autumn 2011 (Submissions Open)

possibly since I was initially planning to do the last judging round this weekend

but yeah we'll see. this also gives a bit more time for last minute stuff I suppose, lol

[Ziergdsx18]

Re: FFR Community Pack Autumn 2011 (Submissions Open)

That's just a sample, but yes.

I'm sure you'll get a laugh once you get to play it.

o bby, cant wait for it xD

[Gundam-Dude]

Re: FFR Community Pack Autumn 2011 (Submissions Open)

Prayer Song (Sado)
Heavy
- Good as an easier chart
Yes
Oni
- Handjacks at M42+ (Beat 164+) are tough.
- M49+ (Beat 192+) is the toughest part in the whole file. Hard to combo with all the jacks.
- Good layering and enjoyable to play, despite the difficulty spikes.
Yes


My Half V2 (Torrent)
Heavy
- Simplified enough.
Yes
Oni
- All the jacks and bursts make this file pretty much.
- Good for scoring, albeit long.
Yes


Rinbu Revolution (Sargon)
Standard
- Good
Yes
Heavy
- Good
Yes
Oni
- Jacks are the only thing this file has to offer. Without them would make this unbearably boring and lackluster.
Yes


SHOOT! (Saki)
Heavy
- Way too simplified in contrast to the Oni chart.
- Good otherwise.
Yes
Oni
- Jacks were nice.
- Well layered and enjoyable to some extent.
Yes


VANESSA (rparty89)
Heavy
- There's honestly not much of a difference between this and Oni.
No
Oni
- Jumpjack patterns are VERY uncomfortable to hit. A lot of the jacks are left hand focused.
- 48th rolls, absolutely NOT. Simplify.
- A lot of opportunity to layer in hand placements that you ignored.
- Picked up on some missing bass jumps. Probably not intentional either.
- Not bad but not up to par with file standards here.
No


Futari no Manifest (Circle of the afternoon MIX) (bmah)
This file takes so long to load on the SM editor ahaha
Easier Difficulties
Good
Yes
Heavy
- What did I just play
Yes


Kaze no yo ni honoo no yo ni (Lynn)
- Beat 49.5, you should probably change this to something two hand oriented. This is way too difficult to hit properly.
- Great grace note usage
- Mines were nice too
- My only issue is whether ANYONE will sit through and play this. I don't see much replayability factor to this, with all honesty.
Yes


Magia (Yamigenbu)
Oni
- Those 12ths in the beginning aren't needed
- Holds can be trimmed much shorter in length
- Hand usages a lot of the time don't really emphasize anything significant in the song
- The huge downside to this file is that there is barely any layering shifts or changes. It's the exact same thing pretty much through the entire file which gets extremely boring to playthrough. I hate turning down files of this length but I have no choice. If you're going to step something this long, make it interesting and not boring.
No


Savage (Yamigenbu)
Oni
- Holds can be trimmed much shorter in length
- M38+ (Beat 146+) all those one handed oriented minijacks and patterns are really awkward.
- A lot of the 16th percussive elements are completely ignored which really irks me. They're prominent but you chose not to layer it.
- M66+ (Beat 261+) long [2] jack, absolutely not
- Same deal as Magia. There's absolutely no layring variation in this which makes this extremely dry and boring to playthrough, despite the difficulty factor of this.
No


Venari Strigas (Yamigenbu)
Oni
- Holds can be trimmed much shorter in length. Hold density makes reading very difficult and awkward.
- The jacks get very awkward and difficult to hit, especially in the later half when you start using 3-4 note long ones.
- Same deal as your other submissions. There's absolutely no layering variation to this; Same stuff being rinsed and repeated, which gets extremely dry and boring to playthrough, despite the difficulty factor of this.
No


Pure Ruby (Einar)
Oni
- The overall difficulty of this file is really inconsistent. The beginning measures are extremely underlayered in contrast to when the 24th streams kick which are extremely difficult to hit.
- It's one or the other. You either make an easy file or hard file. You're mixing two underlayered and overlayered elements which makes this file really unenjoyable to playthrough.
No


Try And Follow Me (moches)
Easier Difficulties
Good
Yes
Heavy
- Great as an easy xmod practice file. Boring file otherwise if played on cmod.
Yes


PINK DREAM (BEAT CASTLE REMIX) (Condoct & Z18)
Standard
- Personally, I would use 64th gallops as opposed to 24th. They're easier to time and don't disrupt flow as much when thrown into 16th stream.
- Layering transitions in this are iffy and detract from the file's flow
- Good otherwise
Yes
Heavy
- Personally, I would use 64th gallops as opposed to 24th. They're easier to time and don't disrupt flow as much when thrown into 16th stream.
- More emphasis on the piano chords would've made this file a lot more interesting, I find.
- M78+ (Beat 308+) jumps to layer the cymbal crashes would make a good addition to the layering.
- Good layering and jacks made this a little more enjoyable. Only downside is that this gets really long and lackluster to playthrough with each repeat in layering.
Yes


Scattered Rose (Cloe)
Standard
- Good
Yes
Heavy
- Layering is great and file's both enjoyable and fairly difficult for scoring.
Yes


InfinitY Happy END (Einar)
- I have nothing to all the difficulties to this other than...
No


Introduction (LongGone)
Standard
- Cool
Yes
Heavy
- Cool
Yes


Calamity Trigger (Loli Empress)
Heavy
- Good
Yes
Oni
- Holds can be trimmed shorter in length
- Climactic and cool
Yes


Sparrow Head Saki (Kommisar)
Heavy
- Cool
Yes
Oni
- The layering in this is so ****ing clever
Yes


Queue is at 52 files. Submissions are now closed to the public, with exception to a few that I have spots reserved for last minute.

I'll have a fresh GFX list up soon.

[i love you]

Re: FFR Community Pack Autumn 2011 (Submissions Open)

Sweet 8)

[Gundam-Dude]

Re: FFR Community Pack Autumn 2011 (Submissions Open)

GFX list posted. Check first post or below:

Files That Need GFX
PINK DREAM (BEAT CASTLE REMIX) (Condoct & Z18)
by O-SE with MASUO

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zacHfKRi9Ec

SHOOT! (Saki)
by Kana Hanazawa, Rina Hidaka, Youko Hikasa, Yuka Higuchi, Yui Oguri

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M2Oi-IDrDaE

Sparrow Head Saki (Kommisar)
by Nico Nico Douga

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ObhBeEOvWlI

Try And Follow Me (moches)
by 2NE1
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MAJ6Xk9bnew

[Coolboyrulez0]

Re: FFR Community Pack Autumn 2011 (Submissions Open)




typography :3

[Gundam-Dude]

Re: FFR Community Pack Autumn 2011 (Submissions Open)

ventian snares. fix dat

I also recommend moving ventian snares to sit on top of half as opposed to what you have. this way you can line up the text with H and F

[Coolboyrulez0]

Re: FFR Community Pack Autumn 2011 (Submissions Open)

fuuuuuuuuuuuuuu-

didnt save psd thats why i shouldnt make gfx rofl

PS: remaking it.

[Shikari]

Re: FFR Community Pack Autumn 2011 (Submissions Open)

Why the **** would you restep My Half, Torrent?

[Shikari]

Re: FFR Community Pack Autumn 2011 (Submissions Open)

Seriously, why the ****

[Coolboyrulez0]

Re: FFR Community Pack Autumn 2011 (Submissions Open)

hope that's better mr. du

[NeoMasterPie]

Re: FFR Community Pack Autumn 2011 (Submissions Open)

you forgot to put venetian snares on top of my half xd

i think it looks alright though

[Coolboyrulez0]

Re: FFR Community Pack Autumn 2011 (Submissions Open)

you forgot to put venetian snares on top of my half xd

i think it looks alright though

yeah because it looks like dicks if i did that

[who_cares973]

Re: FFR Community Pack Autumn 2011 (Submissions Open)

probably wont have time for the submission i was planning on doing oh well