Single Song Pack 1 Released (Review Phase Open)

[leonid]

Re: Single Song Pack 1 Released (Review Phase Open)

By the way, if you have submitted a simfile to this pack, you won't be able to remain anonymous when sending a review, because your rating on your own file will not be counted towards the total score.

[who_cares973]

Re: Single Song Pack 1 Released (Review Phase Open)

****

[I like it]

Re: Single Song Pack 1 Released (Review Phase Open)

Score? Where did that come from? Now my file is gonna get a 0/10.

[leonid]

Re: Single Song Pack 1 Released (Review Phase Open)

Score? Where did that come from? Now my file is gonna get a 0/10.

What do you mean by that? Of course it's the mean value of the ratings given by the reviewers.

[FFR4EVA_00]

Re: Single Song Pack 1 Released (Review Phase Open)

note: if you are taking song choice into account for your ratings you are truly a ****ing idiot
a 10 should be the best possible file for this song, not the best possible file period
therefore, if you didn't rate any file a 10, no one made the best possible file for this song

edit: finished my reviews
highest score: 7.5
lowest: 1 (3 of em, though now i regret one of them a bit)
median (counting 12 heavy and 12 beginner as separate): 3

[JackDrinksJack]

Re: Single Song Pack 1 Released (Review Phase Open)

Any song can be stepped, whether it be a deathcore techno song, or a mellow country song, they can both be stepped with the same amount of difficulty, except you'll have to layer the country song alot more.

[BeatofIke]

Re: Single Song Pack 1 Released (Review Phase Open)

I thought #10 was the best as well. Whoever stepped #5 is high.

EDIT: or probably did it on purpose.

[FFR4EVA_00]

Re: Single Song Pack 1 Released (Review Phase Open)

I thought #10 was the best as well.

gg i wasn't referring to a file

[I like it]

Re: Single Song Pack 1 Released (Review Phase Open)

What do you mean by that? Of course it's the mean value of the ratings given by the reviewers.

Oh, I thought there was some sort of contest lol.

[leonid]

Re: Single Song Pack 1 Released (Review Phase Open)

14 reviews so far. That's a lot more than I expected (o:
Reviews and the stepauthors will be revealed within the next three days (tomorrow if I'm not being lazy), so hurry up and finish your reviews!

[Bluearrowll]

Re: Single Song Pack 1 Released (Review Phase Open)

Should send an email before I sleep tonight. Cool idea Leonid!

edit: the way my reviews are going to work is 10/10 is the file I liked the best, 1/10 the file I liked the least, and stuff in between.

[FFR4EVA_00]

Re: Single Song Pack 1 Released (Review Phase Open)

that sort of system ****s up the overall ratings unless you have everyone do it

[JackDrinksJack]

Re: Single Song Pack 1 Released (Review Phase Open)

i was thinking that.

scoring should be done like

"a 10 should be the best possible file for this song, not the best possible file"

so a 1 would a bad chart for that song, a 10 would be the best chart possible for that song, the other songs in the pack shouldn't be relevant a file's score.

[leonid]

Re: Single Song Pack 1 Released (Review Phase Open)

there are no such things as 'other songs' in this pack...

[Bluearrowll]

Re: Single Song Pack 1 Released (Review Phase Open)

that sort of system ****s up the overall ratings unless you have everyone do it

If this is directed at me, this isn't talking about the difficulty ratings on Stepmania, it's simply my preference of each.

Or if you're talking about an overall, I think for the most part some of these should be within 1-2 of what everyone else will probably say. It may bring an average up or down, but again it's my preference.