Opinions on my stepfiles

[Rebirth0]

Re: Opinions on my stepfiles

Sounds like that's what you think I've been doing. I just look at all of the comments on my sims in the SOTW threads that people make.

And if my or Kilga's V1 sims weren't good to you, I don't know. The might be a little too hard for what the song gives out. But V1 needs a stepchart that's a bit harder than SB's

[Shashakiro]

Re: Opinions on my stepfiles

Sounds like that's what you think I've been doing. I just look at all of the comments on my sims in the SOTW threads that people make.

Where'd you get that idea? I wasn't responding to your post at all or referencing you in any way with that comment. Actually, you're one of the better file authors when it comes to accepting criticism from what I've seen.

And if my or Kilga's V1 sims weren't good to you, I don't know. The might be a little too hard for what the song gives out. But V1 needs a stepchart that's a bit harder than SB's

Kilga's is fun, yours is eh, SB's is near perfect (IMO). I don't really think it does need a chart harder than SB's, personally--it could use one, but it's not necessary.

[Silver_Brian]

Re: Opinions on my stepfiles

Thanks for all the comments guys. They really help.

ps 3000 get.

[Evascythe]

Re: Opinions on my stepfiles

I can see the light - good
tribal revival - awesome
cia rave v2 - meh
spontaneous hydroxide v2 - ?
incognito - meh
seven - meh
solitude sun - awesome
v1 - huh

and such

[HeZe]

Re: Opinions on my stepfiles

FC'd Seven today for the first time. Awesome songs btw

[DigitalS3r4ph]

Re: Opinions on my stepfiles

I can see the light - haven't played
tribal revival - bad
cia rave v2 - neh
spontaneous hydroxide v2 - no
incognito - mehish
seven - decent, I liked it overall I guess.
solitude sun - Decent
v1 - Haven't unlocked yet

You can only get better with every file you make. Just keep at it- Despite the general 'off-syncness' I experience with your files, you seem to be geniunely trying to get better. That's good.

EDIT: okay, played v1


Yes, it's probably your best work I've tried by far; Though, to even compare it to kilga's v1 is an absolute joke since he and his file are at a totally different league... The latter half of the file I thought was pretty cool with the way you handled the jumpstream, however, the last final tidbit was kinda stupid. If you had wanted to change it or build it up for a climax, you still shouldn't have forced the same-note jacks. (I don't really know what they're referred to as, but they're annoying when they don't belong in files such as this or klungklung)

[Sir_Thomas]

Re: Opinions on my stepfiles

V1 is GAY because I blackflagged it. ;_;

If you speak the FFR V1... me too

[moches]

Re: Opinions on my stepfiles

I can see the light- Too easy but pretty fun.

tribal revival- Great.

cia rave v2- Way understepped.

spontaneous hydroxide v2- Haven't unlocked.

incognito- nothing good. too many jumps.

seven- like someone else said, jumps seemed forced. other than that, good file.

solitude sun- just played. very good.

v1- AWESOME! Going for AAA.

[Shashakiro]

Re: Opinions on my stepfiles

for the record: I AAAA'd V1 both times I played it in SM. XD

[sjoecool1991]

Re: Opinions on my stepfiles

I think Seven is very clever because there are exactly 777 arrows in the song.

[t3hch34tz0r]

Re: Opinions on my stepfiles

I think youve made a lot of improvement. Im looking forward to seeing your next file in the game.

[Silver_Brian]

Re: Opinions on my stepfiles

My opinions/reasonings on my own files:

I Can See The Light - Yes, very easy, but easy on purpose. It also was the best way to fit the music, I thought.

Tribal Revival - Overjumped beginning, should've used more pattern variation in the ending. I don't know what the hell I was thinking, trying to get a 999 combo. =/

CIA Rave v2 - Again, easy on purpose for new players. I thought the notes fit the music well.

Spontaneous Hydroxide v2 - Meant to be a harder and better SH. Still felt kinda meh. =/

Incognito - Too many jumps, although many still fit fine. I like it better now, since I finally AAA'ed it =p

Seven - Admittedly, 777 combo was forced. It's tricky to get any way, since if I stepped all the 16ths there'd be way too many notes, and if I had just stuck to basic patterns, there'd be way to little notes. Felt kinda odd, personally.

Solitude Sun - I tried to go with the music as much as possible while trying to keep the steps somewhat on the easier side. Guess I should've stuck to 1 difficulty. =/

V1 - Meant to be a medium difficulty song. I think this is probably my best file in the game so far.

[moches]

Re: Opinions on my stepfiles

My opinions/reasonings on my own files:

V1 - Meant to be a medium difficulty song. I think this is probably my best file in the game so far.

Agreed.