35
28
21
14
7
Kagi Kickflip~ :: FFR Batch Submission
Tru -
Kagi Kickflip~ -
Helious [6.5 / 10]
Autumn 2024 Seasonal Batch
PublicTokenPurchasedSecretEvents
Rejected
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1goVL1D37TyZKlYBfER-ZIZlssHdWdq9-gLSdX6A2sII/edit#gid=0
This chart was also submitted to the community pack.
1:29.591 - 1:44.360 - Fully expecting some layering complaints but this is deliberate, to keep it somewhat close to the structure of the similar section starting 30.511 without being obnoxiously glutty (read spiky) here
1:29.591 - 1:44.360 - Fully expecting some layering complaints but this is deliberate, to keep it somewhat close to the structure of the similar section starting 30.511 without being obnoxiously glutty (read spiky) here
Simfile Folder Name
Kagi Kickflip~ (Tru)Note Count
1359Chart Length
2:20Average NPS
9.9755Estimated Difficulty
75.76
First Note
0:03Ending Note Delay
0:01Hand Bias
x 39
Framers
0 - 0 1 - 0 2 - 0 3 - 48 4 - 48Jumps
x 339
Hands
x 28
Quads
x 0
Color Jumps
x 4
Color Hands
x 0
Color Quads
x 0
Most notes in:
1/3 of a Second7 - 21.00 nps 0.5 Seconds
10 - 20.00 nps 1 Second
17 - 17.00 nps 2 Seconds
31 - 15.50 nps 5 Seconds
66 - 13.20 nps 10 Seconds
127 - 12.70 nps 30 Seconds
345 - 11.50 nps 1 Minute
654 - 10.90 nps
Color Count
x 411 (30.24%)
x 325 (23.91%)
x 1 (0.07%)
x 474 (34.88%)
x 27 (1.99%)
x 8 (0.59%)
x 69 (5.08%)
x 0 (0%)
x 44 (3.24%)
Posted at 11:15pm on September 30th, 2024
h
A new chart file was uploaded with the following changes:
----------
Note Count changed: 1352 => 1359
AVG NPS changed: 9.92415 => 9.97553
Hand Bias changed: 46 => 39
Posted at 3:31am on January 7th, 2025
Kagi Kickflip~ (Tru) [7/10]
>Perms, metadata, sync good
4.320 - Should be on 2
13.435 - This is higher pitched than 13.319
17.742 - Ghost note (even when slowed down to 10%)
31.896 - Should put this on 4 to avoid being misinterpreted as part of the minijack motif in 32.011-32.704. You even did this on 39.281
35.588/37.088 - Missing note? Compare 33.396
45.511 - Shouldn't this be a jump pattern that's derived from 45.281? Previous repetitions followed that rule
48.973 - Why is it here that you start putting hands on this repetition of this noise, but not on 30.511/34.204/37.896/41.588?
1:00.051-1:00.744/1:03.744-1:04.436/etc - Why no more Hand-Jump-Hand-Jump-Jump-Jump? I guess the song's quieter to the point where layering is reduced?
1:00.513 - Should be hand. Compare the spots previous to this
1:02.013-1:02.475 - Technically these 3 notes are descending
1:08.706 - Should be a jump, specifically [14]. Compare 1:05.013
1:26.706 - Ghost note. Not Melody
>>Kinda straightforward & consistent
Judge Score: 7.00 - Change Recommended
Posted at 8:40am on May 14th, 2025
Permission: good
Metadata: good
Sync: good
- 8.358: No jump, or 4th single? See 19.435.
- 20.127: PR is backwards on these jumps.
- 19.089: Pitch is more like A - B - A here, so something like [1][2-3][1] would be more accurate. Could put 19.486 on [4] to not make it too [1] heavy. Actually I conjured something up that makes the PR work for this section: https://imgur.com/a/0AancZI
- 22.550: Probably shouldn't jack, different pitch. I would make 22.666 a [14] jump.
- 31.897: Why the artificial jack? There's no repetition here.
- 32.820: I can get behind the two previous jacks, but this shouldn't jack. I think making this [1][24][1] would follow the pitch better and be much more satisfying to hit.
- 36.050,36.512,: Shouldn't jack.
- 37.204: Why jumps and why are they jacking?
- 37.608: Could include this 32nd to the vibrato in the lead.
- 37.897: This should be different from 38.127, different pitch. PR is wrong in the same way at 30.743, I think something like [24] [34] [123] [34] [13] [24] would work so much better PR wise. This is a continuous problem throughout the entire song and you kinda stepped it this way every time.
- 38.820: Same here, different from 39.166.
- 39.397: PR is backwards.
- 39.281: No grace like 19.435?
- 40.204: Shouldn't jack.
- 43.897: Shouldn't jack.
- 52.089: If anything, this should jack with the 8th before it.
- 52.551: Why jack?
- 57.167: Sorry for hammering on this so much, but again I don't get these jacks.
- 59.244: Why does this jack with the [4]?
- 66.398: Missing note?
- 73.322: Why jack?
- 81.860/81.976: Are you following the melody? Jacks again make no sense here.
- 91.091: PR here is backwards and the 16ths should be on different columns.
- 94.783: If you're following the melody again it makes no sense that the notes jack here.
- 96.053: I'm fine with some of the jacks here, but this one shouldn't be there.
I'm gonna stop here, I think this file has a fundamental problem with jacks. Some of the jacks are justified and are going to the repeating chords, but they are kind of interwoven with other jacks that shouldn't be there creating a very confusing file. I'm conflicted because I actually really like the majority of the file, I like the grace notes and I like the way you structured this layering wise, I just really can't get behind the jacks and I think the PR could use alot of work as well. I'm going to give this a 6 to give you the opportunity to appeal, because the file is fun and the file does have alot of potential and the file is definitely better than alot of files currently in game, but I see too many problems to give it an FR or an accept.
Judge Score: 6.00 - Rejected