Approved for high-90s/low 100s bounty

Hospitality (ositzxz369) [7.5/10] -FR-

PERMS OK
SYNC OK

12.304: This is pretty spiky relative to the rest of the song for what it goes to. Consider repatterning it without the minitrill.

49.247: Moving this to col 3 would be ok PR wise and really make this a lot less awkward on the left hand.

1:01.076: Could afford a triplet (13) jack here to contrast with 1:02.276.

2:07.247: This is rough on the left hand for a fade in.

2:41.361-2:44.961 [FR]: Damn, the left hand bias here is intense for no apparent reason. The PR is understandable, but there's no reason to make this so biased towards one hand.

3:22.504 [FR]: Yeah no, the vocals aren't 8ths here (they're faster), they're only 8ths starting from 3:26.961. Either sync them properly or simply chart the white notes starting at 3:26.961. The same problem, although less apparent, happens at 2:53.704 (where the "hello" is also not charted the same way).

This is a fun chart and it really does not feel like it's as lengthy as it is. The jacks are fine and actually quite welcome given that they make the 16ths less generic and they also represent the song well enough. Fix the vocals white notes and the left hand biased section and this should be good to go. The 32nds in the first quarter are a bit rough given that the rest is mostly 16ths, but it's not unjustified either so that's fine as is.

Judge Score: 7.50 - Fixes Required

Permission good (🆚)
Sync: -0.215 works best for me, but I realized it after writing most of the notes, so the notes below are given under the original sync (-0.219).
Metadata good

Those white notes are hard to sync, but here are my best guesses (I timed them in my -0.215 offset and shifted them back to -0.219):
- 40.497 -> 40.583 (and then step 40.504 again)
- 46.493 -> 46.579 (and then step 46.500 again)
- 1:40.754 -> 1:40.797
- 1:41.611 -> 1:41.626
- 1:41.868 -> 1:41.840
- 1:42.383 -> 1:42.397
- 1:42.983-1:43.761 -> 1:42.954(jump) 1:43.068 1:43.176 1:43.297 1:43.404 1:43.511 1:43.626
- 2:53.697, 2:53.869 -> 2:53.754, 2:53.840
- 3:40.240 -> 3:40.297 (some "hello"es are slower than others)
- 3:41.183 -> 3:41.226
- 3:41.697 -> 3:41.740
- 3:42.640 -> 3:42.697
- 3:43.154-3:46.157 -> 3:43.197 3:43.411 3:44.226 3:44.690 3:44.869 3:45.083 3:45.683 3:45.897 3:46.040

The rest of the chart:
- 3.647, 3.990, 6.047, 6.390, etc.: could be jumps
- 4.419, 14.018: ghosts (there is a sound at 4.461, but that's hard to hear at 100% speed either)
- 6.819, 16.419, 17.961: not minijacks

* 32.447-32.619 and 33.647-33.819 both have the repeating "he" sound. I'd go with removing the jack in the second one (like 12[13]) since it's a bit nasty to hit
- 33.476: could be a jump
- 49.076: jump?
* 49.590-49.761: this makes a bit spiky transition out of the jack. I tried a few alternative approaches, but I think removing the roll in 49.633-49.719 works best (1) because the density gives little room to work with, and (2) for the consistency with 49.761-50.961 which also has the 32nd sounds.
- 54.219, 57.819: jumps?
- 56.790: not minijacks

- 1:06.476: single
- 1:07.161: 4 to distinguish with 1:06.990
- 1:46.847: jump? (if added, may need to tweak 1:46.847-1:47.190 for the right hand balance)
- 1:57.647: jumpminijack? stronger than others
- 1:59.876, 1:59.961, 2:00.047: jumps

- 2:10.590: single
- 2:13.333, 2:15.733, 2:16.933: move to 2:13.354, 2:15.754, 2:16.954
- 2:16.161: [13] to differentiate with 2:16.418
- 2:21.819: strong enough to be a jump
- [2:23.961, 2:24.133], [2:25.161, 2:25.333], [2:26.361, 2:26.533], [2:27.561, 2:27.733], [2:35.961, 2:36.133], [2:37.161, 2:37.333]: seems inconsistent in jump/single
* 2:44.104, 2:48.904: [34] for easier transitions out of the jacks, though it's musically the most intense section so I guess it works either way
- 2:46.504, 2:49.418: jumps

- 2:59.961: jump (and make 3:00.047 single?)
- 3:08.704: not minijack

* 3:27.990-3:29.190: ow, that left hand's rough. Suggest reducing minijacks; I think even something as simple as 1212[12] 121212[12] is fine.
- 3:32.611: white 2 here; also tweak nearby notes so that 3:32.790 doesn't use a 2
- 3:36.219, 3:37.418: jumps
- 3:37.847: single

Taking such a chaotic song as my first judge file... was something. It's a spicy fun file though. A bit spiky in some moments marked with *s, but shouldn't be too hard to take care of them.

Judge Score: 7.50 - Change Recommended

My *s and Op's FRs seem good, and I checked the rest of the notes as well.

As discussed in DM, 3:22.504- is now technically accurate, but I feel like it's susceptible to a handful of Goods, especially around the left hand's 3-jack at 3:23.876. I did find a somewhat working strategy after a bit of practice, though *I recommend nerfing the 3-jack so that players can focus on the polyrhythm.

It was decided to keep the jack.