35
28
21
14
7
shule ya samaki :: FFR Batch Submission
ositzxz369 -
shule ya samaki -
cybermiso [7.25 / 10]
16th Official Tournament (see thread)
PublicPurchasedSecretEvents
Released
BOF perms - https://manbow.nothing.sh/event/event.cgi?action=More_def&num=486&event=140 - https://soundcloud.com/cybermiso/shule-ya-samaki
✔️ The stepauthor has acknowledged the judges notes.
Simfile Folder Name
shule ya samaki (ositzxz369)Note Count
1894Chart Length
1:55Average NPS
16.8206Estimated Difficulty
94.06
First Note
0:03Ending Note Delay
0:01Hand Bias
No BiasFramers
0 - 0 1 - 0 2 - 1 3 - 71 4 - 612Jumps
x 530
Hands
x 36
Quads
x 2
Color Jumps
x 4
Color Hands
x 0
Color Quads
x 0
Most notes in:
1/3 of a Second11 - 33.00 nps 0.5 Seconds
14 - 28.00 nps 1 Second
25 - 25.00 nps 2 Seconds
47 - 23.50 nps 5 Seconds
110 - 22.00 nps 10 Seconds
207 - 20.70 nps 30 Seconds
556 - 18.53 nps 1 Minute
1094 - 18.23 nps
Color Count
x 738 (38.97%)
x 598 (31.57%)
x 11 (0.58%)
x 501 (26.45%)
x 0 (0%)
x 5 (0.26%)
x 5 (0.26%)
x 0 (0%)
x 36 (1.9%)
Posted at 11:31am on November 3rd, 2023
shule ya samaki (ositzxz369)
- Offset's fine.
Regarding the jumpstreams - they felt fine to play, though at some points it felt a bit too aggressive in how it's structured, but not at fault at times. However, the long anchoring (more of the OH-trill bias) in some of them contributed towards the rigidity that makes the chart quite uninteresting to me. The 12ths on the column 1 is a bit much to transition into the meatier jumpstream felt a touch rude, but ultimately fine.
**The thing about this chart is that some of the transitions are rude and would require smoothening, e.g. 32.514, where you could make one of the cyan note a 192nd close to 32.492 and delete the 32.557 since it focuses more on the off-vocal. It occurs on 1:23.622 and 1:31.970 as well.
I'm not sure if I agree with not charting 1:01.122 for this section - I get what you're trying to do for charting for the bass kicks only, but it kinda does feel like it's empty after playing it through couple of times.
I feel like this chart doesn't really have much to offer beyond the stop-and-go jumpstreams, but somehow I feel conflicted on what to make of it, since the layering is pretty basic, but I find it would be something that players will dread playing or grinding it since it delights with gross transitioning in between the anchors and the jumpstreams. I'll give this an appeal rating if you think I judged your file unfairly, but if this gets in, I just hope people enjoy this more than I do. [6.5/10]
Posted at 11:36am on November 3rd, 2023
shule ya samaki (ositzxz369) [8/10] [Fixes Required]
- Perms, metadata, sync are good
0:32.296, 0:41.668 - Ghost note
0:33.927-0:34.709 - Why are the 16ths here specifically ignored?
0:36.470 - Based on your structure, this note is missing.
**1:07.057-1:11.231 - This part is aggravating. The continous mix of the 12ths with the 16th JS makes it very difficult to consecutively control and makes it the hardest part of the file, please look for an alternative that tones that transition down.
1:27.079 - Ghost note
1:31.992 - This particular placement for the 48th feels exceptionally trippy. [13][34] or [24][12] are more tough to execute since you have to switch between fingers while maintaining a hit on the middle column. You could honestly just get away with taking 1:23.231-1:23.664 and just mirror/swap positions at 1:31.579-1:31.992
1:43.938 - Why 32nd there?
Weird song, but the chart matches with that vibe. Some parts a bit additive, but it mostly works. FR on the ** note.
Posted at 1:22pm on November 4th, 2023
For Mipha:
-the 48th jumps will be nerfed to singles
For Deam:
32.296/41.668 - Removed ghost note and tweaked some of the incoming patterns. Recheck 32.361-33.796/41.753-42.014
33.927-34.709 - Are 34.122/34.514 the missing 16ths? If so, then it's b/c I didn't hear them initially
36.470 - Added
1:07.057-1:11.231 - Attempted to nerf by just removing the 16ths during the 12ths. Recheck section
1:27.079 - There's a noise here
1:31.992 - I'll just nerf the 48th jumps to singles and tweak the surrounding patterns accordingly. Recheck 1:23.622-1:24.014/1:31.970-1:32.427/1:40.318-1:40.709
1:43.938 - There's a noise here. Also recheck 1:43.840-1:44.622
A new chart file was uploaded with the following changes:
----------
Note Count changed: 1913 => 1896
AVG NPS changed: 16.98934 => 16.83837
Hand Bias changed: 31 => -14
Posted at 2:35pm on November 18th, 2023
For posterity: The current change is a bit better, but the OHTs are tricky and exhausting. Look into mitigating the length of it. Could probably do mirrored sides on the same segment.
Posted at 5:35pm on December 1st, 2023
Don't mind me, popping in here to see if it's 'good enough' to move to DC Engine and ready it for release. Will wait a bit longer since the 'Fixes Required' tag is still appended on this submission.
Posted at 9:51pm on December 1st, 2023
no, it's not good enough yet, will do changes soon
Posted at 1:58pm on December 2nd, 2023
more fixes
A new chart file was uploaded with the following changes:
----------
Note Count changed: 1896 => 1894
AVG NPS changed: 16.83837 => 16.8206
Hand Bias changed: -14 => 0
Posted at 1:39pm on December 20th, 2023
Fixes have been made. This can go out of Fixes Required.