Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows (Spoilerific)

[ShastaTwist]

Originally Posted by mrb1019

In book 7 they say that you can't transfigure anything into food, you can only make more of it once you have it.
but in previous books, Mcgonagal transfigures her desk into a pig
why couldn't hermoine just do that when theyre in the woods, then kill the pig

A little morbid for the trio, don't you think? This isn't Lord of the Flies.

[burningeyes88]

Originally Posted by mrb1019

In book 7 they say that you can't transfigure anything into food, you can only make more of it once you have it.
but in previous books, Mcgonagal transfigures her desk into a pig
why couldn't hermoine just do that when theyre in the woods, then kill the pig

slight bump and hermoine is against house elfs being used as slaves. i dont think she is gonna aprrove of killing a pig.

[Afrobean]

Originally Posted by burningeyes88

slight bump and hermoine is against house elfs being used as slaves. i dont think she is gonna aprrove of killing a pig.

Pigs aren't intelligent...

I mean, house elves might not be the smartest things ever, but would you ever consider cannibalizing a retarded person just because they're not that smart?