Yolomania Vol. 3 Submissions Open!

[Wafles]

Lol

FFR forums, the place where veteran simfile makers are always right because they've been around longer. I'm done with this argument, if you don't like it go make your own pack. I put a lot of time and effort into doing these packs and if you can't be civil then I want nothing to do with you or your files.

[RainFalleN]

Originally Posted by Wafles

[RainFalleN] - SHOOL KILLERZ - Rejected
We don't really think anyone is going to have a lot of fun with this one. Those 32nd bursts in the middle of dense handstream stamina stuff is really kind of a niche idea, don't see it getting played a lot.

Oh, those 32nds are there because the music does have a note there......
But OK, respect your idea

[Wafles]

Yeah they made sense, it's just not a real fun pattern for a stamina file

[Yulanik]

Originally Posted by Wafles

[Yulanik] Fairy Dance - Conditional
First major problem, you need to define an interesting part to play during the preview music, because no one will pick this otherwise as it just sounds like a dull piano file for the sample you have right now.

LOL very major, stepmania world problems, but thanks for the reminder. I just simply forgot to.

Second major problem is just general consistency and layering things. Like, its hard to tell why at 6.643s you don't have a short 32nd run here, and you step these little things elsewhere.

Because there is no 32nd run there, listen to what I'm putting 32nd runs to in the later portions with clear prominence, I don't get your inconsistency claim here.

Third sort of problem - your minijacks seem a little inconsistent, just take another peak at what you're doing with these please

Took another peek and noticed minor minijack notes missing, but that's it. Fixed those.

25.393 - not sure about the 1h trill here, its probably okay though

It begged to be stepped like that, it's either trill or ignore it altogether. I chose trill. It's 150 bpm, anyone playing this pack aren't little wimps, they can handle it. ^^

46.443 - consider changing to something like a [14][23] jumptrill for this beat to better fit your layering. same thing happens 4 beats later.

Not a bad idea, actually.

54.734 - not a fan of this color theory

I accented the high velocity notes in comparison to the other notes around it. I like to take full attention to these things, I did the same later in the file so it's kinda funny you pointed this one out lol.

& I'm actually noticing ghost notes too, so I'll prob be sending in fixes for this. It might get stuck in conditional limbo, who knows XD

[Fission]

Originally Posted by Wafles

Lol

FFR forums, the place where veteran simfile makers are always right because they've been around longer. I'm done with this argument, if you don't like it go make your own pack. I put a lot of time and effort into doing these packs and if you can't be civil then I want nothing to do with you or your files.

you're the one who can't be civil. you're really bad at taking criticism and you massively over react to people telling you like it is, even if it is rude (which it really wasn't). ask any high level player and they will all say that mines after notes are harder to deal with. play cetaka's dream to nightmare file, for example, and tell me that the file would be harder with the mines before the notes because i'm pretty sure it wouldn't be.

[choof]

Originally Posted by Wafles

Lol

FFR forums, the place where veteran simfile makers are always right because they've been around longer. I'm done with this argument, if you don't like it go make your own pack. I put a lot of time and effort into doing these packs and if you can't be civil then I want nothing to do with you or your files.

stepmania, the place where veteran simfiles artists generally have more insight into what makes a file "good"

[SKG_Scintill]

I make shitty files

[Gradiant]

Originally Posted by Gradiant

Might have a file for this soon

Done, sent some Blitz Lunar in
Also, Wafles check your PMs on here please.

[t-rogdor]

Originally Posted by choof

stepmania, the place where veteran simfiles artists generally have more insight into what makes a file "good"

dude i'm on your side with regards to the whole mine placement thing, but you gotta remember that packs and their respective quality are entirely up to the people running them.

no one really gave a shit when glove made people tune their files to his tastes for odi3. i mean yeah, glove's insight is definitely more refined and based around years of making files, no questioning that, but ultimately what goes into a pack and what's "allowed" and "not allowed" is up to the whims of the pack's creator

i didn't throw a fit when a file of mine got cut out because the xmod gimmicks would fuck with a lot of peoples' stepmania builds. chill.

[choof]

mines don't fuck up sm builds, just sm scores

people didn't get mad at glove tweaking files because the people who sent files to odi3 and got them even close to accepted were experienced simfile artists

[t-rogdor]

i acknowledge that in my post yes

[t-rogdor]

my point is dude, the person who controls the quality of the pack is the person running it. even if said person's definition of "quality" doesn't match up with the standard. you can't really fight that

if you wanna control it let's make our own pack

[choof]

I thought we were just going to do the "morgan and mike casually make files that no one should ever play" thing

[t-rogdor]

that's the plan yeah

[choof]

booty swag

[rCaliberGX]

placing 192nd colour notes to bleep bloops

[SKG_Scintill]

the alchemist

[Wafles]

Originally Posted by Fission

ask any high level player and they will all say that mines after notes are harder to deal with.

You realize this is really obvious and I didn't ever disagree with this right? I'm not retarded, I know how stepmania works, I know how mines work.
Either contribute something or leave. All you're doing is being annoying.





And to put all this stuff to an end, we have our own quality control standards, I'm not going to accept file just because someone with a lot of experience made it. Now seriously, its done. If anyone has any beef with me here anymore take it up over PM or Skype, its clogging up this thread for no good reason.

[Fission]

Originally Posted by Wafles

I'm not retarded, I know how stepmania works, I know how mines work.

it's pretty clear you don't know how mines work or you're just bad at stepmania. everything choof screen capped isn't hard to hit at all and i don't need to "playtest it" to see that. you don't have any objective basis to say that those sections are hard to hit and you are simply being biased against them.

calling me annoying is exactly what i'm referring to when i say you are over reacting to criticism. granted i could not be posting in here about this, but if you are going to try to call me out then i'm not going to stop posting here.

[SKG_Scintill]