Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2

[qqwref]

You know what, I'm tired of this whole "so and so isn't a good file" "this file should be in FFR" "if you can't do this or that you shouldn't step" etc, etc. Frankly NONE of us make perfect files. Every single one of us has made a mistake while stepping before. Kommi made his mistakes too. It seems that no matter what song you choose or who steps it, no one will ever be happy.

Originally Posted by psychoangel691

This batch had to be one of the highest acceptance rates we've had in a batch and STILL people are complaining.

What are you talking about ?_?

[psychoangel691]

Originally Posted by qqwref

You know what, I'm tired of this whole "so and so isn't a good file" "this file should be in FFR" "if you can't do this or that you shouldn't step" etc, etc. Frankly NONE of us make perfect files. Every single one of us has made a mistake while stepping before. Kommi made his mistakes too. It seems that no matter what song you choose or who steps it, no one will ever be happy.


What are you talking about ?_?

When exactly have I ever gone on about a file having to be perfect to go in game? I'm one of the people who was against the harsh judging.

[TC_Halogen]

I'm so sorry that you're getting upset at me for pointing out obvious errors that no one else did. I'm also so sorry for advocating some sort of better quality control.

I'll start here - honestly, it's absolutely pathetic that sync errors typically don't get caught, and it's even more annoying that some people are saying that it should be allowed to have minor offset errors. Nothing is being done to fix these offsets unless it's ridiculously off, and no one wants to normalize sync (or audio, for that matter), or alternatively, give a person CAPABLE of fixing sync the means to do it. I'm not going through flasm or whatever the hell to guess and check sync, nor do I feel like it's necessary to convert files a million times to get the right offset.

Files have been going in game with poor sync, and overall, file sync is inconsistent as a whole. No one wants to go out of their way to do it -- I've offered multiple times but I don't have the means to do this because I don't have the files to fix up. I can get the recent batch and redo sync, but I still have absolutely no way to communicate with anyone, not to mention it's absolutely pointless because no one ever seems to care. It took me a lot of persistence just to get a single file uploaded to the engine with proper sync. I'm so sick of people acting like they're upset about something for reasons that are absolutely irrelevant. I'm not advocating elitism, and I'm not forcing a particular style. I'm advocating quality and consistency.

EDIT:

You know what, I'm tired of this whole "so and so isn't a good file" "this file should be in FFR" "if you can't do this or that you shouldn't step" etc, etc. Frankly NONE of us make perfect files. Every single one of us has made a mistake while stepping before.

and I'm sorry but when in the hell did ANYONE mention that? I pointed out that I found multiple errors in the chart and you're taking it as me saying I'm telling people how to chart?

[who_cares973]

I'm a perfect judge

[TC_Halogen]

think: I'm showing them errors based off of their own intention based off of what I can see - when it's incredibly obvious that something was left out, then I'm going to point it out, and if a person disagrees with me, then they are entitled to appeal with me, tell me what they were trying to do, and I'll level with them

[hi19hi19]

The hell is this drama again ?_?

Dunno about you guys but I figured out a loooong time ago that this game is full of subjectivemanias and everyone's going to have opinions...
If you got a problem with judging, mention it privately instead of shitting in the batch discussion thread.

FFR really bad at taking it easy or something, unbunch your panties it's a goddamn game

[nois-or-e]

Originally Posted by hi19hi19

...mention it privately instead of shitting in the batch discussion thread.

Smartest post in this thread yet.

[TC_Halogen]

cool so let's keep the problem closed within a small group rather than presenting it to people who might have a legitimate thing to say about it

if people don't have a legitimate contribution, then they shouldn't post - it's even worse when someone who rarely even comes into this thread and decides that their word is law - oh wait you're staff so I guess that makes you right, cool.

people who don't know what they're talking about really need to keep their mouths shut -- honestly, while the argument between qqwref and me was slightly heated, it was more relevant than the last two posts in this thread and it discussed a legitimate issue, so if you think that's stupid, then that's on you

[hi19hi19]

My point was not that the topic being discussed was stupid, but rather the manner in which it was being discussed.
I don't see how getting slightly heated benefits any of us- that attitude should be taken privately. If it's posted publicly it should be mannered.

I realize I'm basically backseat modding and not entirely helping... regardless, the point was worth making. I'll stop now.

[bob bob]

Originally Posted by XxMidigamixX

but it needs to stand out...a picture of the earth blowing up is not enough lmfao.

Trust me its a good file

Although to be honest i was not expecting it to get accepted, let alone 15++...

[Choofers]

Originally Posted by DossarLX ODI

I really have to second this, his notes are very weird

hate to break it to you, but your files suck

[who_cares973]

what are we arguing about again i want to get in on this

[Choofers]

Originally Posted by who_cares973

what are we arguing about again i want to get in on this

why kommisar should be a judge

[who_cares973]

dudes legit and has years experience

[i love you]

From looking at this thread, there is only one thing I want to say.

We are all bad judges. You want to know why? Well think about it, during/after every batch, there is always people complaining about judges ratings. If we are too strict, you are hated but you followed the rules given to you. If you too lenient, you are loved but you go against the rules. There is no in-between because if they were then neither side would be complaining so therefore, nobody is a good judge. We all suck pretty bad!

PS: I find it funny that this whole conversation started when LJRox mentioned that Kommisar should judge. You guys are...lol

[XxMidigamixX]

Originally Posted by i love you

I find it funny that this whole conversation started when LJRox mentioned that Kommisar should judge. You guys are...lol

we're all silly Rebound :3. Then again, there's always FFRama in these batches xD

[Choofers]

Originally Posted by who_cares973

dudes legit and has years experience

he posted a picture of a penis while he was hammered, obviously he is not responsible at all

white text that says I'm trolling for those that are retarded

[Ziergdsx18]

Originally Posted by i love you

From looking at this thread, there is only one thing I want to say.

We are all bad judges. You want to know why? Well think about it, during/after every batch, there is always people complaining about judges ratings. If we are too strict, you are hated but you followed the rules given to you. If you too lenient, you are loved but you go against the rules. There is no in-between because if they were then neither side would be complaining so therefore, nobody is a good judge. We all suck pretty bad!

PS: I find it funny that this whole conversation started when LJRox mentioned that Kommisar should judge. You guys are...lol

trig(o:

[who_cares973]

Originally Posted by Choofers

he posted a picture of a penis while he was hammered, obviously he is not responsible at all

white text that says I'm trolling for those that are retarded

everyone has posted a picture of a penis on the internet when drunk whether it be their own or someone elses. lets not kid ourselves guys

[SKG_Scintill]

Now to make things worse, what if I were a judge?