Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2

[One Winged Angel]

ok there

[mi40]

notes r out

[YoshL]

clockwork gearman - 6.5 (oh cmon)
black [resub?] - 6.5 (OH CMON)
pollyanna rmw - 6.5 (seriously)
PuFUDOR - 8/8/8/PASS PLEASE DEAR GOD
Powerhaus - 3 (totally expected lmfao the difficulty spikes)

[bmah]

Link for those of you who don't know: http://www.flashflashrevolution.com/...=114965&page=3

[Xiz]

Exogenesis: 7 / 6 / 6.5 / 7 = 6.625
Kirby Smash: 8/ 9 / 7 / 6 = 7.5
Taking Wing: 8/ 8 / 7 / 6 = 7.25
The Whip: 8/ 8 / 7 / 6 = 7.25


Cool, 3/4 accepted (I think)

@Bmah / Jimmmmmerax
I would like ALL of my accepted files to be put on hold till I send in an updated version with fixes.

(Will post my comments for judges after I make fixes)

[TC_Halogen]

Exogenesis -could- potentially make it in depending on how the judge strictness/standard deviations play out, because the cutoff for this batch is supposed to be 6.7.

Gonna be close...

[gameboy42690]

I Can't Wait - 8/9/4.5/8

choofers why u gotta h8 ):

[Xiz]

Originally Posted by TC_Halogen

Exogenesis -could- potentially make it in depending on how the judge strictness/standard deviations play out, because the cutoff for this batch is supposed to be 6.7.

Gonna be close...

if so, expect fixes for that as well.

[T-Force]

7.125 average. Please be enough. ;__;

[Charu]

Holy moly, Medley Rush #2 got some unexpected love, hah.

I'm glad the folks that judged it liked it a lot.

I'll take a look at it due to Halogen's notes!

Raccoon Flicka on the other hand got a some hate. Ah well, better luck next time. Don't know if I'll try again with that file, but eeeeeeh...

[yo man im awesome]

Kirlian Isles I: 8/7/6/Pass

Choof I'm curious, why you pass?

Edit: AJ 90% of your notes i agree with, only these two i'm a little iffy on:

- 35.727: could be a right arrow, with the next three being L/R/U
- 43.172: make a left arrow; repeats same pitch as before

with 35.727, why would i do that, that wouldn't make any sense PR-wise rofl, unless i'm hearing that wrong.
43.172, could be my mind playing tricks on me, but i actually hear the pitch going down here. That's no big deal though.

[mi40]

these judgements are all OVER the place, random 4s killing my score

AQ Children
aj 7
alex 7
choof 5
kommi 6

derezzed
aj 5
alex 6
choof 6
kommi 6

herbie goes ballistic
aj 4
alex 7
choof 9
wayward 7

the artichoke king
kjw 7.5
samurai 6
dossar 4
silvuh 6

we are hi-speed
kjw 7
samurai 6
dossar 5
(passed)

[Zaevod]

6/6/5/6 for Labyrinth of Logic... Meh, not as bad as I expected. No comments about Northwing Fury I, though.

[bmah]

Originally Posted by mi40

these judgements are all OVER the place

Yep, I think it's getting a bit crazy IMO.

[ilikexd]

eos 6 7 7 7 <- expected, file is weird lol
mirage garden 7.5 7 9 <- meh

[mi40]

i agree w/ most judgements but those 4's on artichoke king and herbie really hurt

[TC_Halogen]

Sorry about the 4, Anaru D:

EDIT: holy SHIT, I'm really sorry about the 4 - I had no idea that I was being so harsh on that file compared to others; I'm more than willing to talk about it and potentially reconsider it, but I actually did hold back on notes for that file because there were a lot of things I kept picking up. The notes just kept stacking up and I do consider myself a bit more of an objective/technical judge -- there were a lot of mis-rhythms/layering inconsistencies.

[mi40]

nah it's fine ima make fixes and send next batch

ps) it seems that all the hard/very hard files got very inconsistent & low scores for some reason.. i thought you guys had a tournament to run but i guess that's not happening anytime soon lmfao

[DarkZtar]

Lapis 6/8/5.5/6.5 = 6.5
Laplace 7/8/6/7 = 7


amber shores bombed o well~

(also dunno how to directly convert bms files to get the mp3's guess I should figure out and start doing that hehe~)

[dore]

Originally Posted by mi40

nah it's fine ima make fixes and send next batch

shit man I thought you were supposed to yell at people and complain