Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2

[TC_Halogen]

Simfile Artist Points
NORMALIZED SCORE THRESHOLD: 6.7

PASSED FILES:
Get Squirrely (1), Holy Winter (1), Lawn Wake III (1), Sincerity (1), Visitor (1)

SAP +3 -- 8.3 <= x => 9.0
A Yodeler In Texas (gameboy42690)
Fill Me Up with Snacky Happiness (gameboy42690)
It’s Over (SKG_Scintill)

SAP +2 -- 7.5 <= x => 8.3
Arianrhod (hi19hi19)
Artemis (DarkZtar)
Autumn Breeze (Silvuh)
Chaos (SKG_Scintill)
Clockwork Gearman (YoshL)
Day’s End (Silvuh)
Daybreak (Fission)
Direct Advance (MrPopadopalis25)
EOS (ilikexd)
Electric Butterfly (ilikexd)
FUSE!! (SKG_Scintill)
Gee [Areia Remix] (DarkZtar)
Gonna Take You Down! (Reshiram)
Laplace (DarkZtar)
Malicious Fingers (Silvuh)
Neurotoxin (Reshiram)
Run Away (bmah)
Scrambooch (Silvuh)
Senorita Bonita (hi19hi19)
Sneakman (Silvuh)
T&J (ilikexd)
Tsumeawase Pt. 3 (bmah)
Twirling Star (Wayward Vagabond)
warm sea (Silvuh)
We Are The Vampires (gameboy42690)

SAP +1 - 6.7 <= x => 7.5
Accelerator (MarioNintendo)
Artificial Rose (hi19hi19)
Axel Man (hi19hi19)
Black (YoshL)
Eirin’s Clinic that People Queue Up (MrPopadopalis25)
Euphoria v2 (DossarLX ODI)
Fading Star (VisD)
Indignant Divinity (Kyuji Sayomi)
Kirlian Isles I (yo man im awesome)
Lawn Wake IX (ilikexd)
Live and Learn (Zen Death Squad Remix) (DossarLX ODI)
Monkey Island (PrawnSkunk)
NO MONEY DOWN LOW MONTHLY PAYMENTS (DossarLX ODI)
Once Upon a December (DarkZtar)
Play It Loud (gameboy42690)
Premium Pine (MrTea)
Prismatic Lollipops (Elite Ninja)
Ray of Moonlight (DarkZtar)
Still Blastin’ (SKG_Scintill)
Strength (bmah)
Timepiece phase II (High-transparency Mix) (bmah)
VALEDICT (VisD)
WANDERLUST (Gradiant)
Zanzibar Green (DossarLX ODI)

ACCEPTED FILES NOT ELIGIBLE FOR SAP
Touhou Judgment in the Sixtieth Year – Fate of Sixty Years (FFR Pro 21 + Silvuh)
Euphoric Field (Final Shaft Remix) (Coolboyrulez0 + bmah)
lifework (Niala + bmah)

EXCEEDING CUTOFF BUT NOT ACCEPTED
Lawn Wake XI (MrPopadopalis25) – above accepted threshold, but lower than other Lawn Wake XI after scoring is normalized

My Fxxkin Desire For You v2 (gameboy42690) – too similar to in-game chart structurally, unfortunately

RESUBMISSION PRIVILEGES
To be determined when passed files have been judged and have finalized ratings (because the top 10 non-accepted files fall into this category, I want to make sure that the data is finalized).

I'll calculate the respective SAPs and add them into the OP tomorrow.

[rCaliberGX]

southern cross - 7/6/6/7, 6.5 average

ouch

[yo man im awesome]

Originally Posted by MrPopadopalis25

You put your pick in a spoiler tag and then I, without looking, will post mine afterwords. I definitely will not cheat, but you still gotta go first.

both of you send me a PM of your pick, and I will post them in the thread with the winner/if there needs to be a rechoose

[DossarLX ODI]

Zanzibar Green - 8/7/9/4
Live and Learn (Zen Death Squad Remix) - 6/7/9/8
NO MONEY DOWN LOW MONTHLY PAYMENTS - 7/8/6.5/7
A Pierce of Flesh - 8/6.5/5/7
Euphoria v2 - 6/7/7
Somerset Blather On and On - 7/6.5/5.5/5.5

Fluctuations in ratings can happen, but in the case of Zanzibar Green it was pretty disappointing considering the notes (it reminds of me of the 4 bomb on Extratone Pirates with no helpful notes).

I was surprised No Money Down got the ratings it did. I'll ask the judge staff first before my changes since they would be rather substantial.

And of course I will look at the other files again. Euphoria is receiving a cut.Bonus: Doki Doki Robo Bunny was an attempt at an index submission.

[DarkZtar]

Yay 5 cap submission get~

AJ gave me a rating lower than Dossar WHAT (╯°□°）╯︵ ┻━┻

[rCaliberGX]

MN seriously your notes

wat

[gameboy42690]

Originally Posted by TC_Halogen

Simfile Artist Points

SAP +3 -- 8.3 <= x => 9.0
A Yodeler In Texas (gameboy42690)
Fill Me Up with Snacky Happiness (gameboy42690)

Okay wow how the holy hell did this happen??? Especially Yodeler, I was expecting that to get like 4's and 5's.

Can't say I'm surprised about MFDFY v2 not getting in.

[VisD]

sap cap 4 w0

Glad to see VALEDICT and Fading Star made it in. Gonna see what can be done about Aventyr and Slam Crunk (...I'm xandertraxing this until it gets in )

P.S. The 6/10 review for Aventyr - not sure whose - has been copied twice under both halo/yoshl and yoshl/bmah. Can I get an actual 4th rating on this pls thanks <3

[TheSaxRunner05]

I don't think I'll step again anytime soon. My 5.5 average has been consistent over every file I have ever submitted. I even went to about 5 different people this time with it for advice. Most consistent issue remains layering, which has always felt like a 'damned if I do, damned if I don't' situation. Any attempt at Climax theory is over layering, while leaving the steps exactly the same every time would make for a boring file. If I chose to highlight certain parts of the song that stands out and add a little variation, it's inconsistent.

Yes, I have taken a couple of the suggestions and improved those technical errors. I am thankful for that. But I am frustrated with a lack of progress in my own charting.

[Elite Ninja]

Prismatic Lollipops - 8/3.5/6/9.5

....... I'm done with stepping lol. Atleast for FFR.

[TC_Halogen]

Originally Posted by VisD

sap cap 4 w0

Glad to see VALEDICT and Fading Star made it in. Gonna see what can be done about Aventyr and Slam Crunk (...I'm xandertraxing this until it gets in )

P.S. The 6/10 review for Aventyr - not sure whose - has been copied twice under both halo/yoshl and yoshl/bmah. Can I get an actual 4th rating on this pls thanks <3

Will fix tomorrow, sorry about that.

[VisD]

thanks!

[ilikexd]

Originally Posted by Elite Ninja

Prismatic Lollipops - 8/3.5/6/9.5

....... I'm done with stepping lol. Atleast publicly.

if you have questions about my rating (the 6) feel free to talk to me in pm or skype, same goes for anyone, i have free time now

[MarioNintendo]

Originally Posted by rCaliberGX

MN seriously your notes

wat

I want to get better... what's wrong?

Also, Accelerator made it in. There. I'm done. lol

[ilikexd]

Originally Posted by MarioNintendo

I want to get better... what's wrong?

Also, Accelerator made it in. There. I'm done. lol

Visitor

pros:

- Another chiptune in the game!

cons:

- Another chiptune in the game...

note: 8/10

The other ratings were a 3 and 1.

[gameboy42690]

Okay so looking through the notes right now for We Are The Vampires and

Originally Posted by DossarLX ODI

- I'd still personally prefer the 3/64ths to be 24th swing

I'm guessing framer issues once it gets converted? If that's the case I'll see what I can do to fix it (but I'd rather leave them colored as 64ths). The song cut's an easy fix though, I'll definitely correct that first.

Originally Posted by Fission

@ 38.9s: this pattern is really mean. consider changing it to something easier.

Probably the one thing I struggled with most here. Any good suggestions?

[Xiz]

Back to the drawing board for me

[YoshL]

Originally Posted by ilikexd

if you have questions about my rating (the 6) feel free to talk to me in pm or skype, same goes for anyone, i have free time now

this, same w/ anyone else

first time notes, hopefully i wasn't shit

[ilikexd]

Originally Posted by ilikexd

if you have questions about my rating (the 6) feel free to talk to me in pm or skype, same goes for anyone, i have free time now

fission says the same - you can also skype him with questions on his judgements

fissionmailed1

(can't post because banned)

[MarioNintendo]

Originally Posted by ilikexd

Visitor

pros:

- Another chiptune in the game!

cons:

- Another chiptune in the game...

note: 8/10

The other ratings were a 3 and 1.

Well, if that's the case, you just convinced me never to judge again. Why didn't you people tell me I lacked skill before giving me the job? That would've saved me the trouble of playing all of those songs. I'm not even going to defend myself. I'm out. I'll get better at something else.