Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2

[L.B.D.D]

yeah just go for it

[DossarLX ODI]

What happened in a nutshell:

October 6th
- jimerax asks who's available to judge the October batch with 120 files. He says it will require 8 judges (bmah said 6 would work however).
- I post that I'm available for a primary judge

October 10th
- TC_Halogen says he can be a supportive judge (managing official tournament, intensive class and work schedule, etc)
- AlexDest says he can be a primary judge
- Fission says he can be a primary judge
- kommisar says he will judge passed files if needed

October 16th
- i love you says "sure", assuming this means primary judge
- kjwkjw says he can fill in for 50% of the batch
- Choofers says he can be a backup judge

From this we have:
- 4 primary judges: Myself, i love you, AlexDest, Fission. Still two judges short for primary. kjwkjw said he could do 50% so I guess it's 4.5 judges.

FFR community repeatedly asks for batch picture, no reponse from jimerax.

Now it's October 29th.

[o____________o]

i said i can be back up

[rCaliberGX]

sent southern cross v2

[Coolboyrulez0]

the day ffr died

[L.B.D.D]

Live Fast And Die With A Broken Heart

[VisD]

in before this snowballs into a 240 file batch

[Xiz]

Originally Posted by DossarLX ODI

What happened in a nutshell:

October 6th
- jimerax asks who's available to judge the October batch with 120 files. He says it will require 8 judges (bmah said 6 would work however).
- I post that I'm available for a primary judge

October 10th
- TC_Halogen says he can be a supportive judge (managing official tournament, intensive class and work schedule, etc)
- AlexDest says he can be a primary judge
- Fission says he can be a primary judge
- kommisar says he will judge passed files if needed

October 16th
- i love you says "sure", assuming this means primary judge
- kjwkjw says he can fill in for 50% of the batch
- Choofers says he can be a backup judge

From this we have:
- 4 primary judges: Myself, i love you, AlexDest, Fission. Still two judges short for primary. kjwkjw said he could do 50% so I guess it's 4.5 judges.

FFR community repeatedly asks for batch picture, no reponse from jimerax.

Now it's October 29th.

Golly. I would hate for this to rollover into a 240 file batch. That would suck so much for judges.

[Xiz]

Double post oops.

[o____________o]

Its not like the batch limit is strict lol. It could be split into smaller ones since submission is so slow

[L.B.D.D]

360 file batch yeaA

[Xiz]

I still think it would be better to have like 60 batch increments every month (SAP resetting every other month)

Judges will have less amount in one batch, i feel like 120 is kinda pushing it a tad.

(Then again I am not a judge, so I wouldn't know)

[DossarLX ODI]

120 files, 6 judges

Two groups of judges, 3 in each group

60 files for each judge

Look at how many files were in the hard songs batch (46 total files) and how late the notes were

[M0nkeyz]

Originally Posted by o____________o

Its not like the batch limit is strict lol. It could be split into smaller ones since submission is so slow

don't know the updating is very slow as well sent a file like 3 days ago hasn't been updated yet

[DossarLX ODI]

The batch may have to be judged in smaller chunks at this rate. There are already 120 files waiting to be judged and it's just going to pile up and not get resolved if this keeps up.

[trumaestro]

What sort of qualifications does one need to be a judge and do I qualify

[Fission]

write some reviews to prove that you can look at a file objectively and distance yourself from personal bias

don't really have that much time to elaborate, but i'll give you more information later if nobody replies

[YoshL]

probably would need to talk to bmah about being a judge?

[Fission]

yes but it still comes down to what i mentioned

[M0nkeyz]

Originally Posted by Fission

write some reviews to prove that you can look at a file objectively and distance yourself from personal bias

don't really have that much time to elaborate, but i'll give you more information later if nobody replies

what is personal bias in relation to a file? whether it's your music type or whether you like the person who stepped the file? or whether you like burst more than stream etc?

but isn't that the reason we have multiple judges to have people who prefer different things give their 2 cents?