New Song Artist's Special Batch - Submission Closed

[Niala]

Originally Posted by 00Razor00

Oh no, mod threats. What ever shall I do? As for your second point, I'm not trying to make any point. I gave my honest opinion on the notes/judges/ratings and you simply white knighted. Stop pretending to be so oblivious to the fact that the 2 judges I called out have absolutely no idea what they're talking about.

Been playing pad for 7 years and keyboard for 4.
NOPE NO CLUE WAT I'M DOING
seriously, don't be so butthurt just because your awful files got rejected.

[iironiic]

Originally Posted by 00Razor00

More like, mass confusion. Especially coming from Niala who uses his own judgment scale to rate files (when there's already one in place, lol?) and iironiic who's just a flat out retard when it comes to rating files (Rating GD's file a +? after 3 +'s), rofl.

Anyway, grats on the accepted files br0s.

Hey, I'm sorry that I'm new to judging and may not give consistent reviews. But I'm giving my honest opinions/feedback of what I saw in the files. You can call me a retard for me being completely honest. Perhaps I'm not suitable enough to be a judge, but oh well... it's a learning process for me and will take a considerable amount of time at my part. Please respect that. If you don't think I'm worthy enough to be a judge, go ahead and chat with JX about it. I don't mind giving up my judging opportunities to someone who is worthy of them.

[TC_Halogen]

Originally Posted by 00Razor00

Oh no, mod threats. What ever shall I do? As for your second point, I'm not trying to make any point. I gave my honest opinion on the notes/judges/ratings and you simply white knighted. Stop pretending to be so oblivious to the fact that the 2 judges I called out have absolutely no idea what they're talking about.

1.) you made a point about how the structure of the scoring system is being misused by judges, when it clearly is not

2.) giving your opinion about judges is perfectly acceptable, calling them out as stupid/retarded as you did to iironiic is not

3.) all of the judges here are coherent enough to be judging, whether you believe it or not.

4.) it's getting absolutely ridiculous that people think they can skate around the rules, or sit there and call out moderators for actions that are perfectly justified.

With that being said, take a break, because you're obviously getting out of hand now.

I like it: you were warned too.

People are getting out of hand and we can easily do without certain people on this forum who feel like they are entitled to behave however they want.

[t-rogdor]

@wc and psychoangel
32nds go to some quiet drums that you can hear if you slow it down
but I'm kinda leaning towards qqwref on this in that some of them are unnecessary (except the ones at m44 and m50; those are 32nds, not 24ths lmfao). I'll probably just re-submit a version w/o any 32nds except the really prominent ones.
heh, guess that's what I get for not using DDReam

cool that Immigraniada got in though

[jimerax]

Originally Posted by 00Razor00

I gave my honest opinion on the notes/judges/ratings and you simply white knighted. Stop pretending to be so oblivious to the fact that the 2 judges I called out have absolutely no idea what they're talking about.

Honest criticisms for judgement results is completely accceptable here (as long as they are constructive), but some words you've used sound objectively offensive to particular persons, that's all.

[TC_Halogen]

I have absolutely no issues with people expressing their thoughts about how the judging system works. Fact of the matter is: Razor has been flame-baiting/trolling on and off for the past week in multiple threads, and has had multiple posts deleted. He needs a break. I was -very- light with the punishment considering it's been going on and off repeatedly.

[who_cares973]

Originally Posted by t-rogdor

@wc and psychoangel
32nds go to some quiet drums that you can hear if you slow it down
but I'm kinda leaning towards qqwref on this in that some of them are unnecessary (except the ones at m44 and m50; those are 32nds, not 24ths lmfao). I'll probably just re-submit a version w/o any 32nds except the really prominent ones.
heh, guess that's what I get for not using DDReam

cool that Immigraniada got in though

oh iight, yeah i never bothered to slow down the song =x

[who_cares973]

also totally saw this thread heading this direction from weeks before

[TC_Halogen]

Originally Posted by Niala

EDIT: Halogen I thought the Hard Songs Batch was just going to be used if we were going to do an official tourney, but I might be wrong about that.

There's still uncertainty about the batch happening or not, but if it does in fact happen, then it'll have the same structure as listed in the Simfile Judgment subforum (no SAP, three file cap, etc).

[megamon88]

Lolz +? +? +? -

I guess that's what I deserve for trying to poop out a file an hour before the deadline. I'm starting to lean more towards stepping for sm, so I didn't really put as much effort into this as I could've.

[t-rogdor]

Originally Posted by who_cares973

oh iight, yeah i never bothered to slow down the song =x

haha, it's cool man. Looking over the file, I kinda needed to fix it up a bit anyway. It's almost an exact copy of the FFRCPSummer File, and that one I only pooped out b/c the artist asked me to

But I figured you of all people would look at it in ddream and see it on the waveform



wait, shit

Originally Posted by who_cares973

also totally saw this thread heading this direction from weeks before

also this

[TC_Halogen]

hahahaha

way to ghost

[YoshL]

lol even if wc does give me a 5 on chopsticks..lol

ah well, file really does need reworking like crazy. but then again, hard songs batch...not able to count it as a resubmission...AGAIN.

[t-rogdor]

Well they're there!!! They just don't show up very obviously on the waveform?

The second one does.

Probably should drop that first one though lmfao

[TC_Halogen]

You can clearly see the spike on the second one, but that first one is masked pretty bad by a...crash? not an audio technician, I'm too lazy to open up the file

[Niala]

Originally Posted by who_cares973

also totally saw this thread heading this direction from weeks before

Er'ry time brah

[who_cares973]

oh right chopsticks
i'll judge that right now lmao

[who_cares973]

chopsticks - sync issues and some more jacks triplets during aggressive sections would be awesome. mainly sync issues though +?

[t-rogdor]

Originally Posted by TC_Halogen

You can clearly see the spike on the second one, but that first one is masked pretty bad by a...crash? not an audio technician, I'm too lazy to open up the file

It's a bass kick, and yeah. It's there, but the kick sorta hides the snare, so it's not worth stepping.
Again, what I get for not using ddream lmfao

yo speaking of ddream, AJ, PM me. I've got something to show ya.

[Xx{Midnight}xX]

Originally Posted by Silvuh

Lavender Town +? ? +? ? = 10
Speedcore 300 ? - - - = 5

I can't say I'm surprised, but I do thank (most of) the judges for their good notes.
Especially Aj's Speedcore notes. Already working on it for the next batch. Lots of little things I hadn't thought about. (As a side note that 32nd wall note was hilarious and my mom asked me why I was laughing so loud.)