TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

[MixMasterLar]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

Why would they kill AA last night and leave Shado "as wolf" alive here?

That's sounds like a free ticket to a wolf win to me.

It would make more sense to kill someone like me and let town flip a coin over Shado/AA.

I feel like I already addressed this

If you leave AA alive he will absolutely have Shado lynched.

If you kill AA, even though it's super obvious, you can at least claim it's too obvious to be true and maybe worm out of it. There's no wiggle room when you re in the Thunderdome with AA for the 3rd day straight. Only the dumbest of wolves would not kill him in this scenario.

[thesunfan]

tbh it doesn't really make me feel better about you unvoting

I could read into it but I guess that's a waste of time

[Hakulyte]

Originally Posted by MixMasterLar

I feel like I already addressed this

If you leave AA alive he will absolutely have Shado lynched.

If you kill AA, even though it's super obvious, you can at least claim it's too obvious to be true and maybe worm out of it. There's no wiggle room when you re in the Thunderdome with AA for the 3rd day straight. Only the dumbest of wolves would not kill him in this scenario.

Not necessary, AA did leave Shado alone after he "claimed" VT.

[thesunfan]

I think AA came away from last phase with a townread on Shado
I think Shado, regardless of his alignment, was able to convince AA that he isn't a wolf, I think the part where Shado said he would /always/ fakeclaim JK is what convinced AA

I'm gonna reread it to be sure, but I think you're not correct in why AA died.

[Hakulyte]

Your posts makes me feel like you didn't really care about this EoD MML.

[thesunfan]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

Something's not right with that 3/5 Shado wagon being still a thing until close to EoD.

btw this was a really good post Haku
it means that Xel is literally lock wolf if shado is town from my pov

[thesunfan]

w&b's longer posts feel better to me than worse

his read on me feels too tentative, but I didn't think they were wolfy if that makes sense

I wish he would've interacted more towards the end of last phase tho

[MixMasterLar]

Originally Posted by thesunfan

don't mean shit if I read everything or not if I see one thing that I've never seen you do as town before

you wanna talk about why you were so confident in voting shado compared to the game where I flipped on you where you were cowering in fear up until the last half hour of the phase?

You mean the game I didn't vote for you and lost for it?

Gee golly greggles why would I be a little more assertive this time gosh darn why oh why? You honestly expect me to believe that after having to sludge through all those Shado v AA posts that there isn't a wolf between them?

You honestly believe that?

AA is town. Shado was the wolf. It's clear as day.

Originally Posted by thesunfan

not sure but I think there's one between you two now
at least one

Anything to say about Haku this phase or naw?

Originally Posted by thesunfan

like, I'm resetting everything except my townread on Haku at this point

Oh nothing to say about Haku this phase huh?

Resetting at this point is a co-op to not condemn Shado

[thesunfan]

wabby also had this weird like "do wolves have to pick names???" dumbtell that I'm not going to give more than the tiniest bit of credence to given the game state but

that'd be impressive for any of the wolves to make up, and also requires them to be using wolfchat optimally

I also don't know who (maybe shado but idk well enough) would think to make up a dumbtell like that

[Hakulyte]

w&b made a post about "assigned kills" affecting his "kill theory" that made no sense to me and when I asked him why it was important he said that it wasn't actually.

I found that pretty weird.
I still remember that roundbox didn't particularly deliver much either.

I think he's worth keeping an eye on, but I did like his larger posts.

Xel's wall was also really strange in his "Witch" section.

[MixMasterLar]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

Not necessary, AA did leave Shado alone after he "claimed" VT.

You have no idea what AA is like then. He would have been pissed that he voted the Vigi and hated himself for going against his lynch target twice in a row.

Same answer to you SunFan.

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

Your posts makes me feel like you didn't really care about this EoD MML.

We've already established you didn't read my 36 posts so I almost don't want to answer this but I will


Would someone literally spending most of EoD answering both current and 20 hour-old questions back to back "not care" about EoD?

Keep saying bullshit maybe it'll magically be true some day

[thesunfan]

Originally Posted by MixMasterLar

You mean the game I didn't vote for you and lost for it?

Gee golly greggles why would I be a little more assertive this time gosh darn why oh why? You honestly expect me to believe that after having to sludge through all those Shado v AA posts that there isn't a wolf between them?

overt sarcasm is nagl (this is a serious read)

your change in gameplay from losing to me as a wolf is to do the exact opposite of never voting and vote instantly?

I'm trying to think of a funny scenario rn, best I got is throwing a Hail Mary on 2nd and short because you didn't pick up the first down the first play. But in this scenario Haku is a confused referee for some reason (I'm very tired rn)

[thesunfan]

been playing around with something in my head

wolves can't roleblock the same person 2 nights in a row

if the jailkeeper was roleblocked last night and they aren't a consensus townread, I think they should claim since wolves can't block them again tonight

kinda a fringe thing, but I do think we're in dire enough straights to need this if this is what happened

[MixMasterLar]

Ok well I got to step away to eat and fulfill my promise to do a #LarPlaysPlaystation so let me make this suuuppper easy for everyone who is paying a damn lick of attention.


Shado


Now when we don't instalose in 12 hours because he isn't town, I can safely conclude that SunFan at least is a wolf. Probably Haku as well.


Resetting your reads except Haku when Haku is actually citing post count right now is disgusting and just makes Haku look all the worst tbh. And he didn't need help looking worst.


I guess you could vote me in response and pray someone does the InD and jumps on me a la Time Travel again but I'm going to chose to have a little more faith that remaining town isn't fucking stupid.

[MixMasterLar]

See ya later tonight

[thesunfan]

if you think I'm ever with shado idk what to tell you bud

[thesunfan]

Originally Posted by MixMasterLar

We get it man don't be a tryhard



The longer you stay in the backseat the faster you fall.

It's ok to step back but by that time Charu really should have gotten back in the action.



Was going to say "Best Shado post" but now that I read SunFan's post after this I can answer it: He didn't get I was talking about DBP most of the time (how I don't know. I must have used a pronoun in a run on sentence or some shit) so of course he thinks I'm flipping around.





remind me that if we're in that weird alternate reality where Shado flips green that AA gets lynched 100% of the time.

It's def w/t between them.



I'm not sure I would have ever gotten this nice, full answer from Wolf SunFan, who probably would have been like "Oh that's what you mean, I guess I did second guess him and was wrong"

I don't like the "in the event you are town" because that almost seems like a way to call me a wolf if I don't buy this response, but I actually do like that he stands firmly behind that DBP didn't have a great game (which when you don't come back for EoD is pretty true). he still should not have been lynched though.

I hate the notion that you voted for him thinking "It's ok, no one else will join me" though because that's pretty stupid. At EoD only vote who you seriously want lynch. I can see why you'd want people to remember him the next day but just point it out the next day?

IDK I'm willing to back off Sunfan's case for the phase all the same.



Son are you dense?

I should address that I didn't vote DBP expecting no one to jump on, if you look at EOD, I campaigned for him to get lynched, I just didn't expect him to get lynched, if that makes sense.

I was glad when he was lynched, and I was glad to see votes accrue, like I wasn't voting him trying to make my vote disappear

[Hakulyte]

Let say MML is a confused town.

He just left a vote on Shado.

All 3 wolves vote Shado.

4/8 poof. already at 1 vote from insta.

Scary.

Probably should at the very least avoid having 2 votes on one person at all cost.

[thesunfan]

Originally Posted by AragakiAyase

I like jade's recent posts, this is more of an emotion read than anything but it feels like they believe what they believe

this is such a sunfan read fuck me

this made me smile btw
it totally is a me read, moreso now that I know he's town

[thesunfan]

yeah 2 is the number to avoid here