FFR Compilation Pack Of Pure Awesomeness

[Choofers]

sin should be the song for the next single song pack

are you gonna do that any time soon

[ScylaX]

I sent some fiels
I was planning to send "PUMP UP UR NRG" but when I was making the easier chart I ACCIDENTALLY replaced my hard-standard difficulty by that one. That means I have to remake it all from the beginning.
I'm raging as we speak.

[moches]

more reviews I'm a little tired because I spent the entire day at the library, sorry if my tone is a lil' cranky haha

9. (DDRBaller123) Kz (Re-Edit Mix)
why do I remember this from Keyboard Ultimax/Xoon 5/other packs from 3-4 years ago?? file doesn't seem like it's changed much either...NO

10. (DDRBaller123) City Lights (Rough Twilight Club Mix)
technically proficient, but very very random patterns and simplistic layering. follows basically only one instrument at a time. freezes near the end are also way too long and limit the potential for that part a lot. I didn't necessarily have a bad time playing this, but I think you could do a lot more with this song. NO

11. (DDRBaller123) Rock Ur Body
I smiled at the song choice and this file, not going to lie. quit out after the third verse, but it's a decently structured easy file (at least based off Heavy). with a song cut and some tweaking of the layering/patterns, I see this being a pretty dope beginner file. I'll PM you later (sorry I'm tired today aaaagh) CONDITIONAL YES.

12. (DDRBaller123) Winter v2
there are already tons of great files for this song. rejected on song choice. NO

13. (rparty89) World's Fastest Guitar Player 2
paging Rebound right now. NO lol

14. (rparty89) Diavolo
quit out near the 24th trill section. misrhythms to the synth/piano 16ths, layering seems unfocused and some of the polyrhythms are inappropriate difficulty spikes. basic structure is solid in most parts, but it needs to be more coherent. NO

15. (rparty89) Freedom Dive
rejecting this on song choice + difficulty alone. NO

16. (rparty89) Not Eternity
rly nice song choice, chill but plenty going on. file is decent but suffers from a lack of detail (especially in the patterns, which seem very very haphazard to be honest). a lot of those grace notes are actually two grace notes (which is fine if you're simplifying the rhythms, not if you're going for accuracy. just to clarify.) are you sure all of them are 32nds? by ear, it sounds a lot more like 24ths to me. I would accept this file with some pretty heavy revision and a song cut, but as is, probably not. NO

17. (blind) Skate Session
song cut is really abrupt. sync should be on 8ths/16ths, not 12ths/24ths. adjust the BPM+offset. file itself is okay albeit pointless until the guitar solo (just a bunch of jumps lol), so I'd suggest stepping some of the background 16ths going to the bass. solo patterns can be simplified a bit. could be a neat short file but NO for now

18. (blind) Warhead
basically way too intense, especially with hand usage. tone down the layering a bit. 24ths+16ths are horribly patterned and organized. small misrhythms here and there you might want to check on a slower rate. NO

guys, I know I said that there weren't any rules, but you still have to try your best. a lot of these files could have been good but needed a lot more polishing. comment if you need specific details and I'll try and help as much as possible, hopefully these comments aren't too harsh

[moches]

also...it's fine if you submit released files, but I prefer unreleased files b/c we have so many released files already. that said if the files are good all is good. just make sure you let me know so I can mark it as such!!

@Scylaax: Four Pieces Of Heaven and tick are both revised versions, right? the dates on the .sm files are both pretty recent

[icontrolyourworld]

I don't think rparty has ever gotten a file into any pack

Originally Posted by moches

also Thrillseeker owned, adding that to the pack stat

and <3

Originally Posted by moches

@Scylaax: Four Pieces Of Heaven and tick are both revised versions, right? the dates on the .sm files are both pretty recent

Roar176 stepped this song, I asked him to have it in nuclear blast 3 a couple of years ago

[EzExZeRo7497]

He got a file into one of the FFR seasonal packs iirc.

[moches]

Originally Posted by icontrolyourworld

I don't think rparty has ever gotten a file into any pack

he got Watch Out Part 2 into FFR Summer 2012. that was a decent file, I expect some good stuff from him this pack

judgments for Scylaax/Charlo's submissions because I'm freaking tired and bored

19. (Scylaax) Four Pieces Of Heaven
you can do better than this but this is perfectly fine. YES but I reserve the right to pull this if you submit better files

20. (Scylaax) Heavenly Army
sry. weird layering, difficulty spikes here and there...your other three files are better so I'm gon say NO

21. (Scylaax) Log On
neato. some of the jumpjack gluts are pretty tough compared to rest of file, though. maybe tone them down in Heavy and make a harder Oni? YES

22. (Scylaax) tick
very cool. YES

23. (Charlo) ...In A Movie
best of your four submissions. ridiculously fun, reminds me a little of a really old GLoVE file w/o crazy guitar solos. YES

24. (Charlo) Demon Desire
reminded me of a Warmen file for some reason lol. I'd accept this but the freezes are a little sloppy in some parts and there are definitely at least a few misrhythms. CONDITIONAL, if you want a more comprehensive look I'l take one later

25. (Charlo) Maximum Overkill
just kinda...there. not particularly well-done either. NO

26. (Charlo) Valhalla - Vexilium
drags a little compared to Demon Desire. it's not bad but nothing stuck me as particularly great about it. of the two marathon files I think I prefer your other file better NO

[ScylaX]

Yeah I revised tick for a bit haha
However about Four Pieces of Heaven, I just opened the file in the smeditor, I didn't really thought about revising it since I had in memory the fact I couldn't do better since it technically respects the song the most I could do.
But my memory must be biased, I'll take the time to look at all my "unreleased" files to see what I can make to increase quality.

[buizel8888]

Originally Posted by moches

12. (DDRBaller123) Winter v2
there are already tons of great files for this song. rejected on song choice. NO

I feel like I've posted this video in response to this same comment 100 times.

[blindreper1179]

Moches, could you go into detail on skate session. Pm is fine. I don't know why it's 16ths, and not 24ths when it matches... I synced it myself, so an explanation would be greatly appreciated!

[codcrille]

As with alot packs, I will silently try make a file for this but get stuck and never finish it.

[intensez]

just to make sure this is realized this is an alt for ~ Ferrari ~ vroom vroom

codcrille pls make a file for this, if you half finish a file ill reinstall stepmania just so its finished

[Charlo]

Originally Posted by moches

23. (Charlo) ...In A Movie
best of your four submissions. ridiculously fun, reminds me a little of a really old GLoVE file w/o crazy guitar solos. YES

24. (Charlo) Demon Desire
reminded me of a Warmen file for some reason lol. I'd accept this but the freezes are a little sloppy in some parts and there are definitely at least a few misrhythms. CONDITIONAL, if you want a more comprehensive look I'l take one later

25. (Charlo) Maximum Overkill
just kinda...there. not particularly well-done either. NO

26. (Charlo) Valhalla - Vexilium
drags a little compared to Demon Desire. it's not bad but nothing stuck me as particularly great about it. of the two marathon files I think I prefer your other file better NO

Cool, thanks. I just replayed Demon Desire and couldn't figure out where the "errors" were. Freeze placement also seemed logical to me, although who knows what's going on in my brain at times.

[eastsideman09]

I'm gonna finish up a file I'm working on and send it here. Might have another one or two lying around too.

[rparty89]

bmah where are you?

[bmah]

Originally Posted by rparty89

bmah where are you?

Aegis is not anywhere close to being ready. I don't know if I can continue collabing if you step like what the file currently is.

[rparty89]

meh i'll try again

got headphones (better ones) so it should be more accurate

[kommisar]

u got told

[rparty89]

meeeehh

[AlexDest]

okay wow i might actually step this for the pack:

a real fucking unique song this is unf