FFR Community Pack Autumn 2011 Released

[FFR4EVA_00]

he rated what he thought was an average file 5/10?
BURN THE WITCH

[Madokidoki]

Originally Posted by FFR4EVA_00

he rated what he thought was an average file 5/10?
BURN THE WITCH

5/10 is only average for these files if you've never played a real 1/10. Sure if you want to rate a file as 5/10 for this pack exclusively, fine, but 5/10 considering all the absolutely trashy files I've played? Sorry, but none of these files are that bad. He references Exige files and it's also impossible to judge any simfile outside of the context of the entire stepmania history, so you can't just take a pack and try and rate files without taking in influence and other such things. And, no offense, but if Alien Temple wasn't overly special, but the stepping was on par with Daydream Syndrome by most peoples standards. And Complete Darkness had awful overlapping freezes and stream that makes for ugly steps. Even if you appreciate everything else that's going on there, it's not any better than the files he rated 5/10. and you're telling me that Complete Darkness is 3 points away from Planet Karma, Bedtime Story or Staring at My Spaceship? Sorry, but I'm not seeing where this guy is even coming from. And his justifications are almost always, "boring patterns herp."

[FFR4EVA_00]

who said i was agreeing with any of his reviews

[Madokidoki]

Originally Posted by FFR4EVA_00

who said i was agreeing with any of his reviews

Who said I cared. I'm only justifying my opinion, nobody said I cared about yours.

[ninjaKIWI]

Originally Posted by Madokidoki

5/10 is only average for these files if you've never played a real 1/10. Sure if you want to rate a file as 5/10 for this pack exclusively, fine, but 5/10 considering all the absolutely trashy files I've played? Sorry, but none of these files are that bad. He references Exige files and it's also impossible to judge any simfile outside of the context of the entire stepmania history, so you can't just take a pack and try and rate files without taking in influence and other such things. And, no offense, but if Alien Temple wasn't overly special, but the stepping was on par with Daydream Syndrome by most peoples standards. And Complete Darkness had awful overlapping freezes and stream that makes for ugly steps. Even if you appreciate everything else that's going on there, it's not any better than the files he rated 5/10. and you're telling me that Complete Darkness is 3 points away from Planet Karma, Bedtime Story or Staring at My Spaceship? Sorry, but I'm not seeing where this guy is even coming from. And his justifications are almost always, "boring patterns herp."

wait

(0+1+2+3+4+5+6+7+8+9+10)/11 = 5 yeah pretty sure that's average sorry dude

[FFR4EVA_00]

Originally Posted by Madokidoki

Who said I cared. I'm only justifying my opinion, nobody said I cared about yours.

who said i cared
also am i supposed to know you who are it's really bugging me

[Madokidoki]

Originally Posted by ninjaKIWI

wait

(0+1+2+3+4+5+6+7+8+9+10)/11 = 5 yeah pretty sure that's average sorry dude

Average in relation to all simfiles you've played? So, apparently Alien Temple is so below average of every simfile he's ever played? It's a subjective opinion, so he'd have to take into account his other experiences and, unfortunately, I can't say Alien Temple ranks in the top 50 simfiles I've played and it's not a 10/10 or 9/10, but a 2/10? If you've played only simfiles that are so much better than Alien Temple that it's relegated to below 5/10, you would have almost never played a bad file.

Also, yeah, 5/10 is average, but only in the most objective sense. Taking into account that these files have been prescreened and are technically accurate and unique, 5/10 is basically saying, Any average simfile maker could've made it. Which is untrue. If it is, let's see someone else make it. Sorry, but an average simfile is worse than any of these by most anyone's standards.

@FFR4EVA_00: Not sure. I'm diokatsu.

[FFR4EVA_00]

i would argue that files that aren't "prescreened" don't exist anymore, since simfile databases are dead and most people would rather not bother with releasing a rejected file
therefore the typical file that gets through most possible judge panels is forcibly a 5/10, and files that do not get into a pack receive no rating period
in other words stepmania is dead

[Madokidoki]

Originally Posted by FFR4EVA_00

i would argue that files that aren't "prescreened" don't exist anymore, since simfile databases are dead and most people would rather not bother with releasing a rejected file
therefore the typical file that gets through most possible judge panels is forcibly a 5/10, and files that do not get into a pack receive no rating period
in other words stepmania is dead

Opinion heard. RPI Stepmania ilu bro c u in heven

[FFR4EVA_00]

me and stepmania

[sakura080789]

downloading

[TC_Halogen]

Futari no Manifest (Circle of the afternoon MIX) (bmah) [5 charts]

this file is getting a video tomorrow

also: Eyes of June -- I did not know Leonid knew how to do all of that; sick shit

[lnick]

Originally Posted by t-rogdor

hey guys I'm cool doctor stepman and super low edgy reviews without any merit for such a low review make me a popular stepmania haha dossar jokes are funny

all files in this pack get 4/5 for trying
songs with music directly from an anime ost, subtract half a point from your score

this man is right anime music is bad and you should be ashamed for stepping it

[codcrille]

Seems like my opinions made Madokidoki mad so let's get this straight.

You are angry becuase I didn't rate Adventure Tune as anything but a joke file, but then your own review was "Hahaha, no need to rate this. Fun shit." Hypocricy much? Only difference I see here is that you found it funny, I didn't.

And you are mad because I don't automatically give all files atleast 7/10 because "these files have been prescreened and are technically accurate and unique" and that is complete bullshit. If a file is what you call a true 1/10, I would just call it a bullshit file and not even give it a rating, maybe -1/10 or something just for good measure. I have played loads of horrible files and I know what you're saying but just because a file is on synch and on par with the current "stepmania threory" doesn't mean I will enjoy playing it and that's what these reviews are, completely subjective opinions of mine on how I enjoyed them.

Your opinions clearly differs from mine, but do I go on a rage on how yours are wrong? Nope, because I respect others opinions.

[Madokidoki]

Originally Posted by codcrille

Seems like my opinions made Madokidoki mad so let's get this straight.

You are angry becuase I didn't rate Adventure Tune as anything but a joke file, but then your own review was "Hahaha, no need to rate this. Fun shit." Hypocricy much? Only difference I see here is that you found it funny, I didn't.

And you are mad because I don't automatically give all files atleast 7/10 because "these files have been prescreened and are technically accurate and unique" and that is complete bullshit. If a file is what you call a true 1/10, I would just call it a bullshit file and not even give it a rating, maybe -1/10 or something just for good measure. I have played loads of horrible files and I know what you're saying but just because a file is on synch and on par with the current "stepmania threory" doesn't mean I will enjoy playing it and that's what these reviews are, completely subjective opinions of mine on how I enjoyed them.

Your opinions clearly differs from mine, but do I go on a rage on how yours are wrong? Nope, because I respect others opinions.

You're entirely right. My bitchfit wasn't necessary and I apologize.

[GideonB]

Downloading now
It has 2NE1
This is automatic yay for me
Also yay more simfiles I can't A xD

[AlexDest]

Originally Posted by codcrille

reviews

sums up mine for this pack

[xferrarix]

i thought moches quit ?_?

[LJRoX]

Originally Posted by TC_Halogen

Futari no Manifest (Circle of the afternoon MIX) (bmah) [5 charts]

this file is getting a video tomorrow

also: Eyes of June -- I did not know Leonid knew how to do all of that; sick shit

he's asian KOREAN POWAHZ

[Yesssss]

revieiw drarma,,,

Do what I do and adjust reviews by taking off about the two highest and two lowest then compare the upper and lower bounds with the rest of the scores.