Stepartist Report Cards

[fysx]

Originally Posted by Mollocephalus

as much as some of them could be overrated, i don't think you can compare with files like peaches en regalia, especially considering the moment in which they were made.

kil's older files are (were) underrated tho, so it kinda balances that.

kil's older files still annihilated ap's older stuff

vundabar and tranzport, while interesting, arent nearly as fun

[Mollocephalus]

grades are supposed to be objective (to an extent) but it's rather funny that you edit them in regard to people's reactions lol

[moches]

the only ones I really changed were the ones I had missed (because they weren't balanced with the ones on page one) and stargroup's/Rebirth's.

I dunno actually, my taste in files changes almost daily. like, I used to HATE Kn33grow's files, then I played them again and loved them, then liked them, then hated them again, then didn't play them for a long time and now I think they're just okay. so it's fine if my grades aren't totally concrete.

right now they match my feelings exactly so I'm not going to touch them until tomorrow morning when I suddenly realize the profoundity of Almsty's Sealed Time and hate Patashu's files.

edit: and uh Necros you never answered my question

Originally Posted by moches

what files would you recommend I play out of ap's, Reach's, and Nemosta's? those were the three least played to me out of that list. if I played some more of theirs, my opinion might change, but probably not by much. I have weird taste in files anyway.

[Mollocephalus]

aperson:

turtle turtle up
peaches en regalia
vunderbar
manchurian candy

reach:

neoclassical shredfest 2
superluminal
disabled the flaw
felys v2

Nemosta:

what do they know
i hate jimmy page
scream squad

[stargroup]

I'm not your teacher anymore

you can bet your ass that I'm never reviewing one of your files again

[leonid]

lmfao

[WTFBrandon]

Originally Posted by fysx

You all get Fs because you arent stepping solo

+1

[who_cares973]

I step solo stuff



Champion freeverse was a serious file btw :<

[Gundam-Dude]

Originally Posted by Mollocephalus

grades are supposed to be objective (to an extent) but it's rather funny that you edit them in regard to people's reactions lol

This is why I didn't give grades in the first place, lmao.

But you can more or less translate if you read the comments.

[xferrarix]

amy: B+. 2 files released by her and yet they are both amazing. Only complaint is no more files
aperson: B. Only a few noteable files from what I remember.
b00mba: B-. Has a handful of files but i don't really replay them. I think there'd be more seen in them if you played index.
bahamut-x: B-. Old school simartist
behanjc: B-, i didn't like any of this guys files in dcp. Only file i love him for is mario minor, which is in ffr.
benny1: B-. Nothing too great.
bluemystic: n/a, never played any files from him
bursurk lurk: A-, all his files have high replay value.
cetaka: A-. very hard files but incredibly replayable (difficulty = replayability)
danceguy117: B. 1989 is all i really remember and that bryans fury file in vgmp3
dethev: solo
dew: B... only remember shind bad
dj ossa: C+. FREEZES
dondon151: B+, most of his files lately are much better (dcp2 files, vgmp3), but his previous files to me were never noteable.
ducky: A-, not many files released from you but i like the ones you have released.
evilpeer: n/a
exige: C+, never was a fan.
ferrari: n/a, but to judge my own files i'd say a B-. nothing thats exactly commendable.
glove: A. I love these files, universal mind is by far my favorite file to date
hayden: B+, A is the only file i remember adn that was fun to play
hst: C+, i hate your files sorry
iamme: A-, good for the most part.
jimerax: B, you try too hard for technicality
john11: party in the shop...B
kil: A+, great files overall
kilgamayan: A-, bb evo is still awesome
kneegrow: A-, pretty good
kommisar: B+, i'd give you an A minus but your stepping style is totally random
linus: C, i hate your files too sorry
macgravel: A-, can't hate macg for his simple yet fun files.
malice: A-, overall great files
necros: B+, basic files overall and generally around MA but still fun to play
nemosta: DMYK B.
npv: B+, i love your files just not enough of them
patashu: A, every time u step something and release it its always a good file.
puppet: A-, cool files but u kinda died from the community
reach: C... don't like these files either
rebirth: B-, technicality is always wrong for the most part
stargroup: B+, dunno how anyones hating on you
t0rajir0u: A, great files.
tear: B, only played the ones in odipack.
the rai-rai: n/a
toph: A-, died so long ago but yet everyone still plays your files.
tsuka: B, basic index files for the most part
velious: B+, died from the community
vospi: n/a
yesssss: A, great files.
z3ratul: B-, COOKING BY THE BOOK
zaghurim: A, st scarhand
zanthro: B, eh nothing commendable to me

[buizel8888]

I wanna grade for back when I cared

amy: B+. Solid stepartist. She needs to make more stuff
aperson: C. Was never a fan personally, but the files weren't terrible
b00mba: C+. I think I found 1 file fun at one point. Can't remember which one
bahamut-x: C+. See above
behanjc: B-. Meh
benny1: B. I liked MOLC
bluemystic: C. Again, not really a fan
buizel: I gave myself a spot cause im awesum
bursurk lurk: B-. Half of your files I think you are zagh on accident. The other half blow cock
cetaka: B. Meh, again
danceguy117: B-. Some of your files are okay
dethev: B. Had fun with some of your solo charts
dew: B+. A few cool files but I never could FC Nefertiti even though it was piss easy so I hate you
dj ossa: B-. Again, a few cool files, but nothing amazing
dondon151: B-. Sorry, never really liked your files, except for one from VGMP3 and some other one I forget
ducky: B+. A few fun files
evilpeer: B-. Eurobeat
exige: B. Hi exige
ferrari: B-. I think I may have liked one of your files.
glove: A. One of my favorite simfile authors overall
hayden: B. I still don't believe that you actually made your own files.
hst: B-. I am pretty sure I did like 2 of your files. Which ones, I forget
iamme: D-. Kill yaself all of your files blow.
jimerax: B-. You are too asain for my tastes.
john11: C+. Hi
kil: B-. Was really never a fan of kil's files, except for the occasional one here and there
kilgamayan: B. I know i liked a few of your files
kneegrow: A-. Pretty solid charts
kommisar: A. You have so many ****ing files its hard to not like some of them. Also Epileptic Crisis
linus: B. Sure why not
macgravel: A. I like xmods
malice: A-. Very solid charts. I hated golden cross tho sorry
moches: B+. While your song choice usually bores me, your files are never that bad
necros: A-. =)
nemosta: B-. Wasn't a huge fan of you sry
npv: B. One of the biggest kb nazis ever...but not that many great charts produced
patashu: B+. Most of your files are hit or miss
puppet: A-. Your name is on epileptic crisis so you get credit
reach: B-. *shrugs* a couple okay things i guess
rebirth: C+. Not a rebirth fan
roar: B-. Files are mostly just scattered bs. Organ Grinder wasn't completely terrible though.
stargroup: B. Cool charts, but they had 0 replay value for me for the most part. Mostly because of song choice
t0rajir0u: B-. Good chart here and there
tear: B+. Not bad at all
the rai-rai: B-. k?
toph: B. Not a huge Toph fan, but nothing too terrible
tsuka: B+. A couple of fun files
velious: B-. Nah
vospi: C+. Sry bro
yesssss: A. Always was a yesssss fan
z3ratul: B+. K
zaghurim: A-. Files were usually solid
zanthro: B. Sure why not


there.

[moches]

Originally Posted by stargroup

I'm not your teacher anymore

you can bet your ass that I'm never reviewing one of your files again

don't worry Picasso I'll make it up to you

[i love gabba]

amy: A- I kil u
aperson: ?
b00mba: ?
bahamut-x: B. I like old skool stuffs
behanjc: B-. I wouldve gave u A- if you had more file in Stepmania, still love ur file
benny1: C. Nothing noticeable
bluemystic: ?
bursurk lurk: B+. I replay your files a lot
cetaka: A+. awesome
danceguy117: ?
dethev: ?
dew: B- shind bad
dj ossa: C. some of your files are awesome, some are weird
dondon151: B-. Some of your files are bs but fun
ducky: B. blazing solo
evilpeer: ?
exige: C. sharp
ferrari: B. You improved so fast omg
glove: A+. Awesome files
hayden: B. DnB
hst: B+. Cool
iamme: C+. Some really really BS files (stream of consciouness)
jimerax: A. I always loved your file. Release more ****
john11: ?
kil: A. Im a fan
kilgamayan: B-. Lol at ur old files, but ya, B.B.
kneegrow: i dun remember
kommisar: A. fun factor, simplicity
linus: C-. If every restep of your songs are improved versions than....
macgravel: B.
malice: A. chill song choiceé
necros: B-.
nemosta: C. lol dmyk
npv: B-. Not much replay value, except for one file, that i dont remember the name
patashu: A. fun and perfect pretty much
puppet: B. Creative use of color notes
reach: B. I found cynthia fun honestly
rebirth: B-. Old school fun factor.
stargroup: A-. planet karma solo, but srsly, **** ur piano demos ****
t0rajir0u: B. Cool simfiles
tear: ?
the rai-rai: ?
toph: B+. I still play your files a lot
tsuka: B. okay simfiles
velious: ?
vospi: B-. Bleh, depends on the simfile.
yesssss: A. love the jazzy feel etc.
z3ratul: C-. but cooking by the book
zaghurim: A. Insane replay value quality
zanthro: ? bleh

as you can see I dunno a lot about old school sim artist

[stargroup]

what is everyone's problem with piano demos

how are they in any way less likable than generic techno

geez

[cetaka]

theyre just jealous that they will never be able to afford the keyboards that the songs are advertising

[stargroup]

lmfao good one

[Rin-Dude]

ferrari how is my stepping random its as simple as can get lmao

[fysx]

Originally Posted by stargroup

I'm not your teacher anymore

you can bet your ass that I'm never reviewing one of your files again

LAMBDAMAD

[Choofers]

Looks like I have some stepping to do.

[xferrarix]

HEY EXCUSE ME SIR WHAT U SAID ABOUT ME IMPROVING is not true. i don't go ALL OUT in my files, its like a half-assed effort, and buizel is jealous because my files are all so amazing that he can't like them.

kommisar you'll have files that are SUPER TECHNICAL (that one in rfpack2?) then u have other files that are totally different like arrogant cobbler