Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2

[psychoangel691]

Originally Posted by Red Blaster

Glad you edited your post.

On topic: I think the thing with this is most of us that aren't currently associated with the stepfile process already don't really have too much to offer in the way of actual useful feedback. Would you rather have 4 people who know what they're doing or 100 people giving completely useless input?

I'd help but at my skill level the only files I could accurately give input on would be the 1-30 range and even then, not really knowing anything about this process, the information I could give would probably be absolutely pointless and a detriment to the process at the end of the day.

I didn't edit my post I deleted the first one and really there was no reason to bring that up in your post.

Heze isn't super familiar with the process, yet he's been in there giving input on files. The point of a public system is to get the community involved regardless of experience. This is a chance to have your voice heard about what you like and dislike, don't throw that opportunity away.
Maybe you should go take a look at the reviews that have been given so far. Most of them are not some real extensive review like you'd see from a judge. We also have it setup to where it needs a judge's final approval before a file is accepted, that way everyone's comments get looked over and considered but nothing should get pushed in that absolutely doesn't belong.

[HeZe]

Originally Posted by Red Blaster

Glad you edited your post.

On topic: I think the thing with this is most of us that aren't currently associated with the stepfile process already don't really have too much to offer in the way of actual useful feedback. Would you rather have 4 people who know what they're doing or 100 people giving completely useless input?

I'd help but at my skill level the only files I could accurately give input on would be the 1-30 range and even then, not really knowing anything about this process, the information I could give would probably be absolutely pointless and a detriment to the process at the end of the day.

Well I don't basically have any idea what I'm doing when I'm judging...

Judging is just looking at the file and using your experience as a player. If something feels odd, have a closer look and report what you found. I'd suggest you to have a look at Jan/Feb 2015 set 5. All but one in that set are around difficulty range 30.

[TC_Halogen]

Originally Posted by Red Blaster

On topic: I think the thing with this is most of us that aren't currently associated with the stepfile process already don't really have too much to offer in the way of actual useful feedback. Would you rather have 4 people who know what they're doing or 100 people giving completely useless input?

I'd help but at my skill level the only files I could accurately give input on would be the 1-30 range and even then, not really knowing anything about this process, the information I could give would probably be absolutely pointless and a detriment to the process at the end of the day.

While your point is viable and quite sensible with regards to those who don't have a large amount of experience, there is one very important take home that you and everyone else should gather here: player opinions are now somewhat being taken into account in a situation where judges have the final say. There's now a potentially intermediary process between players and judges, where the players get to highlight files that they think are worthy of the game and have their word actually heard this time. This new system benefits you, because the process of having judges is no different than how the system used to be. You guys are the ones who can help make a difference.

Now, it goes without saying that this doesn't give players the opportunity to play games of bias and favoritism, as there is still a quality assurance put in place by actual judge. However, you guys have some power, as your ratings actually do matter and can help assist files that may be just below the line of acceptance in an actual judgment situation. Between having a public system for users to vote on, a judgment group responsible for quality assurance, an appellate system, and a situation that gets a secondary judge to identify a content's quality in edge cases, everyone has a respectable amount of power to influence the game content, so long as they do it responsibly.

[Deidara837]

Aside from some files whose charts/stepartists I recognize, I haven't really gone through the sets yet due to time constraints arising from a heavy college load. If I do get the chance however, I'd be willing to go through a few sets (there are a ton though haha)

[psychoangel691]

Originally Posted by Deidara837

Aside from some files whose charts/stepartists I recognize, I haven't really gone through the sets yet due to time constraints arising from a heavy college load. If I do get the chance however, I'd be willing to go through a few sets (there are a ton though haha)

Not everyone has to go through every set, that's kinda the beauty of this.

[SKG_Scintill]

I am doing exactly what you're saying: lurking
scold me if you so desire, but I'm checking if this is worth joining

[t-rogdor]

what's uhhhh goin on with the hard songs batch now though
is that gettin publicly judged or are we still waiting on secondary notes

[One Winged Angel]

public notes for hard batch would probably provide fantastic reading material but afaik I don't think that batch is going to be up for public review

dw rog I dunked a lot of files but grind4 wasn't one of them (idk if you had anything else though)

[t-rogdor]

oh i'm not worried lol (good to know tho), just haven't heard anything about it in a couple of weeks and was starting to get worried it'd been forgotten about. all good.

i don't think public notes for it would be necessary but at the same time god would i love to read them

[psychoangel691]

I believe we're leaving the special batches as they are. I know we definitely will not release the OT batch.

With that said, it's been really hectic overall getting the progress done on all this. I believe AJ was being recruited to do some of the hard songs stuff but he's also been on the OT batch with me. There's very few people that are doing judging right now and we are trying our very best to get everything caught up for you guys. I'm hoping with the public system in place that this will be something that can be resolved faster.

On another note I messaged everyone listed in the judges group to see if any of them were available to help out (I didn't message the ones who were already recently judging), to try to completely finish up this Nov batch and make sure we have people to give the final say with the public stuff. Once I hear back I'll let you guys know who all is still planning on staying a "primary" judge.

[t-rogdor]

I mean hey, like I said a couple of pages back, if you guys need help I only work two days a week and spend most of my time on the computer anyway

[psychoangel691]

Originally Posted by t-rogdor

I mean hey, like I said a couple of pages back, if you guys need help I only work two days a week and spend most of my time on the computer anyway

Honestly helping get some reviews on the files in the public thing could help a lot. Dossar has it set right now where he wants at least 5 public judgements before a primary can give final approval.

I'm not heading up the hard songs batch so I idk if you could help over there or not that would be Dossar's thing.

OT I'm a little jumbled on and need to get my head on straight, but if something comes up that you can help me with I will shoot you a message

[t-rogdor]

I'll abstain from hard songs batch because i have a file in one of the 2 or 3 unfinished sections. That's dossar's baby anyway. I'll get at public review (knocked out one today!), and please do hit me up if there's anything you need for OT haha

[psychoangel691]

Awesome ^_^

[Red Blaster]

Originally Posted by HeZe

Well I don't basically have any idea what I'm doing when I'm judging...

Judging is just looking at the file and using your experience as a player. If something feels odd, have a closer look and report what you found. I'd suggest you to have a look at Jan/Feb 2015 set 5. All but one in that set are around difficulty range 30.

Well I landed myself off from work today so I'll give it a shot

Edit: I have zero idea what I am actually looking at.
Perhaps a tl;dr breakdown please?

[psychoangel691]

Originally Posted by Red Blaster

Well I landed myself off from work today so I'll give it a shot

Edit: I have zero idea what I am actually looking at.
Perhaps a tl;dr breakdown please?

Play the file in the engine, give opinions.

[MarioNintendo]

SENT A FILE \o/

[Luvox]

Sent a file :^)

[Wayward Vagabond]

hey dossar do your thing with that batch search engine. I want to see if files I think I submitted were actually submitted.

[DossarLX ODI]

Notes for Sets 1 and 6 in November 2014 have been posted in the Batch Review Thread. This leaves Set 2, Set 3, Set 7, and Set 8 (bmah has lead notes for Set 7 done). In addition, the BSE site is updated with these nine results.

Results for November 2014 Set 1:

Accepted
[8/10] Hatsune Miku no Gekishou {cosMo} (hi19hi19)

Conditional Queue
[7*/10] gorechestra {DEV/NULL} (klimtkiller)

Rejected
[5/10] Crystallized Silver {S.S.H.} (FFR Pro 21)
[2.5/10] lapis {Shiki} (rparty89)


Results for November 2014 Set 6:

Accepted
[8.5/10] Winter Night's Journey {LEAF XCEED} (DarkZtar)

Conditional Queue
[7/10] DATA DRAIN {DJ Sharpnel} (hi19hi19)
[7/10] Problematic {Kezwik & Protohype} (Xiz)

Rejected
[6.5/10] Real {Bumblefoot} (ilikexd) - Resubmission Privileges, also eligible for rating appeal
[6/10] Sunset Hamlin {The Flashbulb} (blanky!) - eligible for rating appeal