Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2

[Nullifidian]

I can see merit in both sides of the argument but how I view carlos's argument is like an art gallery (l0l painting analogies all day errday). You can paint gorgeous landscapes or stong emotional pieces, or you can paint the most flawlessly-painted guro hentai. Chances are guro hentai won't be admitted since it's not a something for public viewing (given the premise that they're not looking for shock material that is). However, at some underground art gallery it might be more accepted if that's what they're looking for to showcase there. Guro hentai is to art gallery as Robotomy is to FFR and the underground art gallery could be the equivalent of stepmania packs. Robotomy is a really out there song and while I really dig IDM I can see carlos's point as well.

[Wayward Vagabond]

sf gets what im talking about

for the record i dont hate robotomy as a song or the file. both are enjoyable i just dont see it as a great addition to ffr ya dumbs

[mrpreggers]

i wouldn't mind some guro hentai on ffr.. the way aj described robotomy makes it sound like an assload of fun i wanna play it let's go

[cedolad]

I'm just sick of this objective vs. subjective argument that happens every fucking batch.

[Xx{Midnight}xX]

Originally Posted by mRpREggERs

i wouldn't mind some guro hentai on ffr.. the way aj described robotomy makes it sound like an assload of fun i wanna play it let's go

Someone sync me slashmaid and send it here. Give me the vocal version because dossar was a pussy and charted the instrumental.

[04im]

it's not a good idea to talk about guro in public js

[iironiic]

Originally Posted by _.Spitfire._

I can see merit in both sides of the argument but how I view carlos's argument is like an art gallery (l0l painting analogies all day errday). You can paint gorgeous landscapes or stong emotional pieces, or you can paint the most flawlessly-painted guro hentai. Chances are guro hentai won't be admitted since it's not a something for public viewing (given the premise that they're not looking for shock material that is). However, at some underground art gallery it might be more accepted if that's what they're looking for to showcase there. Guro hentai is to art gallery as Robotomy is to FFR and the underground art gallery could be the equivalent of stepmania packs. Robotomy is a really out there song and while I really dig IDM I can see carlos's point as well.

Exactly this. And my point with my previous post, namely:

Originally Posted by iironiic

Just step whatever you want. Who cares about the ratings you get from the judges. If it was rejected because of song choice, then derrrrpp... Life's unfair. I have been constantly told that piano files are not suitable for FFR, but who's to tell me what to step. It's that simple guys.

is to just "paint", regardless if it inevitably gets merit or not. Who cares if someone judges how you paint? Some will judge, others will appreciate. Regardless, just be happy about what you are contributing to FFR (be happy about your artwork).

[MarioNintendo]

- I think Robotomy in the game would be acceptable in the game. Truth be told, it is a pretty extreme/contemporary attempt at making a challenging file. It's the kind of files that mark a turning point in our game; it's the first of its kind. There might be no other files in the future like this one, or it could spawn an entire sub-genre. Technically, the file is 100% coherent and represents perfection. In all honesty, I don't believe it deserves the red carpet treatment by getting scores of 9 or such. For one, not everyone will embrace this file, and I'd be surprised if anyone would think otherwise. While it is arguably a perfect file, it is very raw and hard to apprehend in a game that's often about sight-reading and pick-up and play in style. Right now, it is a misfit, there is no way around it. For those reasons, I believe the file should borderline-pass; it is good, but it is also a black sheep. Hence, it should be accepted with a grain of salt. The score it gets in the end doesn't matter if it gets released anyway (I don't think choof was looking for SAP when making this, even though I could be wrong).

- I think it's not unfair if, even though you worked hard on a file, it doesn't get accepted right away. Sometimes, the timing has to be right. The mindset of the players must be in tune with what you are providing. See what happened to my Stress - xKore file; I stepped it and sent it in 2011 over FFR, Thirdstyle and even Dragons Fury, where it got rejected on all fronts, saying it was a counter-intuitive file that demanded memorization, something that went against the way the game was meant to be played. I worked super hard on the file, and it's just sitting there in my folders and in the Fall 2011 community pack. My pinky says someone will contact me to make it see the light of day again (actually it's happening), though, and that is why I think it is not a big deal if you get rejected the first or second or third time when you send something.

Let the riot start

[Nullifidian]

Originally Posted by MarioNintendo

Let the riot start

[MarioNintendo]

Originally Posted by 0

can you paint with all the colors of the arrows

You can try, but I'm not sure most "general public" art galleries would see them as approprite, e.g.,






edit good night y'all keep this thread alive for me. in 2010 i was a n00b, there should be more n00bs in ffr, there i said it and I am NOT talking nonsense, im a judge i have power what i say is true, goodbye my friends.

[DossarLX ODI]

Originally Posted by Xx{Midnight}xX

Someone sync me slashmaid and send it here. Give me the vocal version because dossar was a pussy and charted the instrumental.

I could send you my syncing skeleton if you're serious about this. It's basically the same song just with vocals removed so the BPM is still the same
Please don't do it

[Elite Ninja]

Just sent in Prismatic Lollipops so guess it'll have to wait for the next batch.

[SKG_Scintill]

@Doss: u still pussy & tuk mah fiel

[Xx{Midnight}xX]

Originally Posted by DossarLX ODI

I could send you my syncing skeleton if you're serious about this. It's basically the same song just with vocals removed so the BPM is still the same
Please don't do it

You know what? Send it here. I'll make an easier chart for it so everyone can enjoy Slashmaid.

The return of the [Parental Advisory!!] label will make it's return.

[Nullifidian]

Originally Posted by Xx{Midnight}xX

You know what? Send it here. I'll make an easier chart for it so everyone can enjoy Slashmaid.

The return of the [Parental Advisory!!] label will make it's return.

Ah yes I've been awaiting the return of the return of the [Parental Advisory!!] label!

[One Winged Angel]

If you're going to send in an easier Slashmaid for the rape version, just pls don't make it too easy.

[AlexDest]

Originally Posted by One Winged Angel

If you're going to send in an easier Slashmaid for the rape version, just pls don't make it too easy.

slashmaid [the not too gentle version]

[04im]

[SKG_Scintill]

It's probably too late for this, but can I send in a revision of Bubble Bath Aftermath with a little more layering outside of the funky solo to improve difficulty consistency?
...And make the file even more awkward?

[Razor]

no