Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2

[hi19hi19]

PJSalt

Kappa Keepo

etc etc

[ilikexd]

was Full Mast the marathon you were talking about a while ago that you were really proud of, because i thought you said it was like an 8+ minute file but this wasn't

also, i'm still surprised that tomorrow untrodden got all 9s when it's only 400 notes long, it was the one i was most afraid of having rejected

[Poison-]

Glad to see some Monstercat files in there

[hi19hi19]

rofl i just saw the ratings for Full Mast:
10/10/8/6

cool 6

Originally Posted by ilikexd

was Full Mast the marathon you were talking about a while ago that you were really proud of, because i thought you said it was like an 8+ minute file but this wasn't

no, you'll know that file when i submit it srsly

Rape:
8/7/6.5/6

passed by two different people lmfao
i guess ill resubmit it with some of the suggested changes
if im telling the truth im kinda surprised it even got the ratings it did 0_o

Synchronized Hearts:
8/7.5/6.5/4

well, im not surprised at the ratings given who was judging
i guess FFR has just moved on from this type of file, probably not worth one of my 5 SAP in the future to try to get a file like this in, even though I think the game needs them
EDIT- just to be clear, not implying my file was perfect, far from it.
just that i think this genre of file has quite an inbuilt bias against it because people are so much more keen on PR and ~artfiles~ these days

DARK KNIGHT:
9/8/8/7

i like silvuhs notes for this file. even though he gave me a good rating, he suggested things i could do better. i wish more judges did that instead of being like "7/10 nothing to say" because the fact you took 3 points off kinda implies you have something to say *cough*
I mean even if you say "the song was boring and 7/10 is probably the most anyone could have done with the song choice" then at least i know what i did wrong was choosing a boring song. calling it simple gives a clue but like... how do i do "not simple" rofl i thought the file was pretty un-simple with the 24ths and stuff give me something specific to work with in the future maaan

Cheat Codes:
9/9/8.5/8

Pretty proud of this one actually. Glad to see it get good reviews.

[Niala]

Originally Posted by hi19hi19

rofl i just saw the ratings for Full Mast:
10/10/8/6

cool 6

hi

i bet u all love me again
'cause i totally love you all <3

[XelNya]

It's been a while since you showed your head in the judge panel D:

[TC_Halogen]

Originally Posted by hi19hi19

Synchronized Hearts:
8/7.5/6.5/4

well, im not surprised at the ratings given who was judging
i guess FFR has just moved on from this type of file, probably not worth one of my 5 SAP in the future to try to get a file like this in, even though I think the game needs them

dude, I realized what you were doing in like the first 10 seconds haha

it's such a shame, I really liked this

[Niala]

ya baby i'm back

8)

[kommisar]

Originally Posted by Gradiant

Can i get a fourth rating on valentine from someone that isn't an asshat? Thanks.

do you need me to elaborate or do you just want to call me an asshat

[XelNya]

Originally Posted by Niala

ya baby i'm back

8)

Will the real Niala, please stand up.

[Niala]

Originally Posted by XelNya

Will the real Niala, please stand up.

I will indeed

'cause i'm leaving~~~

[.Gazelle.]

Originally Posted by TC_Halogen

EDIT: Congratulations to .Gazelle. for his first queue'd file!

Took 2 years, but finally a non collab got in! 8) 8) 8)

[MarioNintendo]

ddrama

[TC_Halogen]

Originally Posted by Gradiant

Also annoying since i Asked bmah about how to become a judge and he said applications would be available 7 months ago, and i know that id be able to do a better job at being detailed and nonbiased rather than saying "yeah, this file is generic, heres a 3"

This is generally not your concern, and you shouldn't utilize a situation that is not pertinent/parallel to the situation of your file. You being a judge has nothing to do with the ratings you will receive.

I'll assume responsibility with the judgment applications not being done because there's something else that needs to be done with respect to that, and it's hard to do that because I'm literally hitting a short-staffed judgment team with back-to-back-to-back-to-back batches with short breaks. There should only need to be two more [batches] before things can slow down on the judgment side, but those logistics don't need to be exposed for any reason.

[TC_Halogen]

ACCEPTED/RESUBMISSIONS LIST v3

NOTE: THIS LIST IS STILL TENTATIVE UNTIL OTHERWISE LISTED AS FINAL LIST

Turns out that I forgot to input some of my own ratings because I'm an idiot, good game. This is why I never say it's final until I am certain!

SAP +3


SAP +2


SAP +1


RESUBMISSION PRIVILEGED

[hi19hi19]

Originally Posted by Niala

hi

i bet u all love me again
'cause i totally love you all <3

I ain't mad.

We're all wrong once in a while :P

Originally Posted by TC_Halogen

dude, I realized what you were doing in like the first 10 seconds haha

it's such a shame, I really liked this

Well thanks to the corrections above I now have a chance to resubmit it. Definitely worth trying again if it costs me 0 of my submissions to do so!
I can definitely do some parts better so I think I can get it in.

[M0nkeyz]

meh 4/6.5/5/5 on chill me, kinda suspected something like this would happen, the file is very chaotic and my biggest problem right now, is trying to not have conflicting note patterns

5/5.5/6.5/6.5 on sonata, too bad.. I know sonata is very repetitive, but it has a nostalgia feel to me, because it's a classic o2jam song.

all in all it could be worse

[TC_Halogen]

FINAL ACCEPTANCE LIST

SAP +3


SAP +2


SAP +1 - note: Truth (xKore Remix) is not eligible for SAP


RESUBMISSION PRIVILEGED


Updating the SAP spreadsheet now, and then adding the queue'd files to the first post of this thread.

[hi19hi19]

lol rip Full Mast

[ilikexd]

full mast more like half mast