jTWG LXX: Flash Squadron - Game thread

[Red Blaster]

Originally Posted by j-rodd123

ok i saw he unvoted when i entered the thread, villager points for dfr for open mindedness

slowly building a village pile based on a couple of pages, now i'm gonna skim to find the most awkward post i can and vote them, this is exciting!

Going to assume that'll be Cry4.

[Jtehanonymous]

Originally Posted by Charles Claythorne

In which case, shouldn't you delve for reasoning to suspect me or points to refute the suspicion in order to be sure?

This is easier said than done when the majority of your posts are unbiased and simply informing on game mechanics/strategy.

Originally Posted by Charles Claythorne

Likewise, wouldn't it be useful to attempt to theorise a few associations between myself and others? Let's assume that I flip as a Wolf, whom will you thus suspect?

yeah, I'm going to start going through the reads lists again and think more on why people are placing people in green and red buckets. I'll let everyone know what I think about some of people's motives for placements.

Originally Posted by Charles Claythorne

Day 0 isn't always going to be a great lynch, but we want to make it an informative lynch. From your point of view, if I flipped as Human, you would gain nothing from the lynch, no?

Same is said for R. He's done virtually nothing. At least in your case, you've made SOME noise and others have attempted to interpret your actions. You're a better lynch for both reasons than R. You DO give more information than him, even if it's still not a bunch.

Originally Posted by Charles Claythorne

Of course, I'm not so confident on a lynch on anyone in particular either at the moment, so let me make my new suspicion list!!!

I look forward to it. I need you to convince me how terrible I am and why the wolves are probably laughing at me for doing their bidding for them.

[j-rodd123]

Originally Posted by tiloco217

Hello everyone, I am replacing sky kitten for this game. This is the first time I have played werewolf on forums but I play mafia (which is essentially the same game) very often online using cams and mics. Now I am going to spend the rest of my day reading 18 pages of text :P

oh well let's hope you don't suck like 86% of the video mafia players trying out forum werewolf*

*this is a true statistic backed up by science

regardless, welcome

[Jtehanonymous]

right now I can interpret your interaction with funnygurl as being a bit weird. You said that something is "off" about her, but then quickly added that you like her emotional tones and such, almost playing both sides and successfully placating her. In the following posts, she does seem to back off and even appreciates that you did notice her town-ness.

are you not trying to come down too hard or just being sure you're aware of all sides of the argument. hmmmmmm.

[tiloco217]

@funnygurl you never distanced yourself from her. In fact you aligned yourself with her because of the, at the time, baseless read and even though she hasn't said really anything you are still town reading her so that could very easily be you trying to buy a pocket.

I do think that charles is a decent direction to look although I don't see him being partners with funnygurl because of the early red check. I think that if you were going to red check someone for town cred he would do it to a town.

Jteh is definitely my top town.

YoshL's vote on iironiic is a bit out of the blue. I think that he would be a pretty bad kill today as his role flip would give zero info. Also voting without any backing is different than the rest of his pushes so far and at this point it is safe to assume that iironiic won't be showing up to see that post anyways so this interaction doesn't feel the same as with red and cry to me.

I am ok with J-Rodd at the moment. Hard to give a solid read on him this early as he would probably be active as either alignment but I don't want him gone today

[j-rodd123]

for the record, funnygurl is someone who i think i read pretty well after soul crushing her/cedolad in one post (but not following through on it the entire game and getting soul crushed myself), and through a select few pages of skimming i'm not getting the easy flowy/pure villager tone she gives pretty easily.

i'd be interested if someone wanted to make a case on her, either side

[Jtehanonymous]

well you've got tiloco right there who's putting up some opposition to funny~

[tiloco217]

j-rodd my case on her starts on page 19 with my reads list then continues near the end of page 21 and the first half of page 22

[tiloco217]

I also have a few other accusations against her in between 22 and here but a majority of my case is there

[j-rodd123]

Originally Posted by tiloco217

@funnygurl you never distanced yourself from her. In fact you aligned yourself with her because of the, at the time, baseless read and even though she hasn't said really anything you are still town reading her so that could very easily be you trying to buy a pocket.

I do think that charles is a decent direction to look although I don't see him being partners with funnygurl because of the early red check. I think that if you were going to red check someone for town cred he would do it to a town.

Jteh is definitely my top town.

YoshL's vote on iironiic is a bit out of the blue. I think that he would be a pretty bad kill today as his role flip would give zero info. Also voting without any backing is different than the rest of his pushes so far and at this point it is safe to assume that iironiic won't be showing up to see that post anyways so this interaction doesn't feel the same as with red and cry to me.

I am ok with J-Rodd at the moment. Hard to give a solid read on him this early as he would probably be active as either alignment but I don't want him gone today

funnygurl is an obvious villager when she's a villager, i haven't seen that at all, but again i've read like 5% of the thread lol. are you mainly looking for connections day 1? i think that's pretty pointless in forum werewolf day 1's, find awkward as posts and vote them.

also the red check thing can you link me to this? was under the impression there were no n0 actions unless im misinterpreting what ur saying

[Charles Claythorne]

I feel you act as if I haven't contributed very much, which I disagree with! I haven't done as much as I usually do, but I would argue my activity is purely circumstantial (in this case, due to a headache). I think you're focusing too much on the big strategy post I made at the beginning and it's obfuscating my smaller contributions throughout the other pages. I've given my opinions on Players as time went on before organising my thoughts into a reads list (e.g. Funnygurl, fanceflashrevo, Red Blaster, YoshL, reuben_tate, from my memory) and gave a few pushes (e.g. iironic, soramimi) to incite some activity. I feel like the accusation that I've only talked strategy or made null posts is rather unfounded.

I said something was off on Funnygurl but also mentioned that was a feeling I had at like 6AM. And I also mentioned later that it was likely due to her avatar change. Further, when she began acting emotional, I adjusted my view on her with evidence that she's done so in a previous TWG (in which I, regrettably, suspected her anyway!). Your theory that I could have stated so to placate her is certainly possible, but you can't just ignore that I'm a Human using my rationality to come to such conclusions either!

[j-rodd123]

alright i'll go read that

the people who have been in the thread since i've subbed in have felt quite villagery, if this was a turbo i'd not be voting any of them

that's the problem with subbing in so close to end of day rather than just wait till end of phase, such an awkward time for me i dont think i've done this before

[Jtehanonymous]

tiloco, you make a really good point about the funny/mashi interaction that I didn't really think about. He's indirectly putting attention on her right off the bat by pointing out she's acting "differently", even if he is leaning on both sides of the fence with his read on her....

[tiloco217]

the red check was baseless and just made as an example of a way to push reads I don't think he has said anything about her after that

[Charles Claythorne]

There was no Night 0, he's likely referring (or misinterpreting) that I made a joke of having seered iironiic Red. I'll get the post for you.

[Charles Claythorne]

Here it is.

[tiloco217]

Originally Posted by Charles Claythorne

I said something was off on Funnygurl but also mentioned that was a feeling I had at like 6AM. And I also mentioned later that it was likely due to her avatar change. Further, when she began acting emotional, I adjusted my view on her with evidence that she's done so in a previous TWG (in which I, regrettably, suspected her anyway!). Your theory that I could have stated so to placate her is certainly possible, but you can't just ignore that I'm a Human using my rationality to come to such conclusions either!

guess i was wrong on him not saying anything else about her

[Jtehanonymous]

I liked that post~

Even if it does read as:

- Instructions

- Teaching by example

[tiloco217]

oh the red was on iironiic. guess I miss remembered that

[j-rodd123]

man everyone's reads lists posts feels so formulated, day 1 is gonna be a gold mine once we get some flips