TWG CXLV: A Bad Joke - The 10th Edition - Game Thread

[Red Blaster]

Originally Posted by AragakiAyase

Red Blaster will not be revived. He should not have died, but because he was flipped he will remain dead.

Gayy lmao

Requesting removal of post-death posts pls
was replying as I caught up

[Vendetta21]

I am a town vigilante. Night 1 I targeted Xiz but according to charu I was blocked and night 2, I targeted red blaster. What is weird is how nothing about charu's role tells him anything about me chipping away at RB, I just assumed the wolves targeted RB once because Xiz and DBP died suggesting no wolf night kill.

It's why I found funnygirl questioning RB on his night power weird and why I find Charu's prescience that he thinks I thought I chipped away at RB's vest on day 1 here weird too, as his role power doesn't suggest that.

What was RBs flip?

Anyways right now I'm not sure whether or no to trust this claim from Charu because wolves potentially knew that their hit missed and that a vigilante hit Xiz so they know a vigilante would be looking for slips in their knowledge, which makes Charu's prescient thought about me thinking I hit one shot off RB's supposed bulletproof somewhat weird given his power, since there was still ostensibly a wolf kill (but I'm still somewhat under the impression that it seems much more likely that I killed Xiz)

Thinking about it I guess the host fuck up might clear Charu but I'll have to see if the mafia JOAT can jail people

I guess the other weird thing I saw was roundbox on day 2 seemed oddly out of place when he said this looked like my vigilante game, which in my mind, if I killed Xiz and wolves burned a shot on the SK, then obviously they are looking for or interested in finding the vigilante after the SK shot DBP because two non-wolf kills came up

Not sure what else to think

[Vendetta21]

anyways here is an imgur with a timestamp i made on day 1 after i made my breadcrumb post (please note the "Uploaded 8 days ago")
http://imgur.com/wdZ2E2J

here is what the image says telling you what my breadcrumb post is


and here is that post itself

Originally Posted by Vendetta21

bulletproof clearly the better decision, i commend your foresight

[Vendetta21]

hmm okay so charu could be a JOAT i suppose

[Vendetta21]

also blo0cking a claimed serial killer is a weird sort of contingency for someone to do only if they know they have a strongman kill later

but then again if charu blocked last night which posthumous host flip and unflip and flip for RB suggests charu did truly block, he would not have been able to make a nightkill, so charu is confirmed town

[Vendetta21]

the fact that red blaster died on accident means that red blaster did sustain either 1 hit or was investigation immune

funnygirl wanting to know what power SK had makes no sense tho because DBP died, and she says RB didn't target anyone, which at this point i think is impossible given the menagerie of rolls we have claimed

[Vendetta21]

actually it appears the logic of joat is tehy can always roleblock but can also perform the factional kill

Factional kill: Each night phase, one of you or your partners may perform the factional kill.
JOAT Powers: Roleblock, Strongman, Ninja
Roleblock: Once at night, you can roleblock a player.
Strongman: Once at night, if you perform the factional kill, it will be converted into a Strongman kill which will bypass Doctors/Jailkeepers.
Ninja: Once at night, if you perform the factional kill, it will be converted into a Ninja kill, which will bypass Trackers.

Going to say Charu here, he has said quite a bit but he always came out guns blazing with the idea that I thought I hit Red Blaster earlier, but that would be impossible for him to think if the wolves killed xiz (how did they suddenly get two kills in a night), which makes that thought totally schizophrenic and him not cleaning up his thoughts before he posted them

in scenario one he did roleblock me and the wolves killed xiz: Okay then where did the wolves get the extra kill to take a bullet off of RB that is important to you reading me as the JOAT???

in scenario two he didnt roleblock me and the wolves didnt kill xiz and i did: okay so then he is reappropriating the vigilante kill that i made as though it's a wolf kill and saying that i tried to hit RB the night before, that's great how did the wolves get two kills again? how would have i been able to be a wolf shooting RB night 1 if the wolves killed xiz????

we know there is a serial killer shot, (confirmed), a vigilante shot, and a JOAT shot. ask yourself what makes the most sense as a vigilante here

[Vendetta21]

yeah charu

[Vendetta21]

the simple idea of roleblocking a serial killer the phase before mylo is just wolfy as shit, it totally suggests he wanted to strongarm the serial killer on the following night to be at mylo tomorrow

[Vendetta21]

and besides the fact that red blaster was both killed AND got to fire a shot suggests sonmething more along the lines of Charu being the JOAT where the host wasnt aware that charu got to do two thing in the night and took his night kill but didn't take his roleblock and then charu had to assure him that he got both afterwards

[Vendetta21]

otherwise it would be extremely weird to both kill RB AND let him fire if charu's role is "jailkeeper", shit doesn't make sense

[Vendetta21]

and before you call this angleshooting, it isn't because charu was using it to defend himself earlier

[rzr]

Yo v I just got up let's get into this

If charu is scum what would the set up be assuming your but I and round is vengeful

[rzr]

Dance is vanilla?

[Vendetta21]

Xiz - Rolecop R
me - vigilante V
FG 1 shot tracker, Rzr tracker - II
Dance - hider - H
Roundbox - ?? - X

dbp 1-shot bus, t-force - goon, charu - JOAT, red blaster - SK = -6T

-6T = RVIIHXT was the role, X is unknown. Either way we must have roundbox or charu as having a role. If by some mistake I'm misreading charu, Charu claiming jailkeeper fits this.

Funnygirl and you are definitively cleared as your claims corroborate each others
If roundbox claims vengeful I think I'm definitively cleared

[Vendetta21]

also Red Blaster dying in one hit confirms him being investigation immune, which confirms funnygirls claim that she investigated him with her tracker role N1 and saw him doing nothing

[Vendetta21]

we can pretty cleanly take you and FG off the table

[rzr]

He did claim vengeful - which fits the original bill since I was suspicious of Charu. I want to hear funny's thoughts here too.

Which puts the liar pool between round/Charu? In this instance

Or in the instance charu is jailkeeper, the liar pool is you solely I believe? As it would be danceguy could lie about hiding behind Charu, but there would be an unclaimed PR if I follow this corectly.

Making the 1st situation more likely and the only possibility with rounbox's cliam?

[Vendetta21]

actually round is clear then

[Vendetta21]

it's actually stuck between charu/danceguy