ODIPack3 submissions (Release when graphics are done)

[dascookieman]

i love you guys you're making this pack superawesome =)

necros, i won't postpone the deadline for several different reasons. get something done, for italy!!

patashu i don't think i could possibly hate something like that, get to work

Originally Posted by TC_Halogen

I've been talking with others about it -- wasn't exactly expecting my file to get outright rejected, but for the constraints of this pack, I understand. Not too happy about it, but there's not much I can do.

I'm not too sure I'll submit the other file I planned on sending in, because I feel like while it's a really diverse/elegant piano file, it's pretty easy and would probably bore higher level players.

yeah i'm sorry about the confusion i didn't realize you were debit13. i would love to try your piano file, that sounds very promising! something i could tell right away from your other file is that you hear the music very well and you use sound layering techniques that makes it easy to follow what's going on

there is no minimum level of difficulty, but the easier your file is the better and more unique it has to be. the reason for this is that people who play competitively mostly play harder files, and there are already soo many easy files made over the years. for example a long <180bpm song with mostly easy 16th and a couple of drumbursts has been done so many times and doesn't have much replay-value to many





reviews:

can't hide your love
didn't enjoy this very much since it didn't have good flow at all. the song is crazy and could be made really cool and hard, but right now so much is being left out and sometimes it's just easy 16ths that often times doesn't seem to got to much in particular. then sometimes you have 32nd bursts and jumpjacks that also comes in kind of random compared to how the other sections are being done. this kind of song could be made a lot better and a lot more consistently challenging.

haereticus
HARD. pretty simple but still was a bit unique and there are no other files like this one in the pack. accepted

ignis fatuus
hard and fun. i can see this being accepted

m16-33 why are there quads? they should just be trips like the rest
m38-44 don't think you should have quads here either
m54-62 i don't get this section, i think it should be done differently
m62-72 you should take the mines out of this section, they're not needed at all here and it just becomes a bit too much
m75 the jack begins a bit earlier, perhaps have it first on rightarrow then on up halfway through. do as you like
m76-89 once again the quads

thor's hammer
haaaaaaaaaard. it needs to be changed a lot but i can see this being accepted as well. but it has a many obvious errors when playing and it's very inconsistently difficult and some parts could be made more interesting and fun.

m2-6 it's not obvious what's going on here, it should be remade since it can become more fun too
m12 the long trill should not be on the same arrows as the ones before
m15 there are some color notes in here that you might wanna add, could be 32nds
m18 it's faster than 16ths
m16-25 don't think you should have quads in this section
m25 missing drum bursts in the end? you had them earlier
m26-27 missing fast color notes. if you don't want them you can't have 16ths instead since they have replaced the 16ths in the music
m28-32 ok hehe, now that's what i mean by inconsistently difficult hehe. you really need to tone this down a lot
m32 missing drum bursts
m37-44 the patterns need to be better. if the 32nds are gonna roll up and down like that it needs to change directions when the music does, it's a bit random now. also the 24ths can come in much more varied patterns since it's not as fast
m48-54 not just every 8th should be a jump like that. the drums are doing some different things here you need to look over it
m55 i don't think you should have melody notes as doubles here, just make them singles and then make them doubles after measure 56 instead when they are more emphasized it will be really cool
m56 one jump too much after the trip
m58-60 there are a bunch of drum stuff left out and i don't think you should make all the melody notes jumps here too. just put arrows to the melody and add all the percussion

tsugihagi contruction
didnd't like this and don't think many would enjoy it because it's mostly easy 8ths that are boring, and then there are 32nd bursts coming in that are superhard and has to be mashed. it's just not a fun concept for a file, you need to make the easier sections more interesting and the bursts can't be fully as hard. there were also lots of stuff left out and i think this could be made a whole lot better. the part with the jumps in the middle was pretty fun though

[04im]

japan file coming to you soon courtesy of squirrel

[Choofers]

https://soundcloud.com/lpshnt/loops-...onked-spectral

sending this today or tomorrow!

[Choofers]

Originally Posted by Arntonach

So we need to work on r, s & t then?

lmfao this post was brilliant

[Dj_Ossa]

Shiiiit I need to finish my file... Didn't realize deadline was coming in so soon!

[AlexDest]

i'll try making an easier chart for die winnipeg die after my AP exams are over with

gotta get at least 1 simfile in

[dascookieman]

yes get ya files done!! =) you have some time

[Choofers]

Originally Posted by AlexDest

i'll try making an easier chart for die winnipeg die after my AP exams are over with

gotta get at least 1 simfile in

#tyba

[04im]

#winnipeg

[TC_Halogen]

I'll try to finish Through Her Eyes, but with a move coming up, I'm not too hopeful, haha.

[Shadow_God_10]

Starting a new file for dis pack! It's gonna be SIIIIICK

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vPkHRmllvDA

(It's cut don't worry )

[Coolboyrulez0]

dont feel like fixing file nor starting new one

i let based gLover down

rip

[04im]

rip

[blindreper1179]

Give someone else the file to make fixes, and call collabsies.

[Arch0wl]

Can't make time for this. Way too much shit going on right now.

I do have the notes mapped out, so if anyone wants to take those and make a file, be my guest.

http://www.sendspace.com/file/esphbb

There are some errors (since I copy/pasted the synths from one of the songs it was a mashup of) but they're obvious errors.

edit: The notes are mapped out to KB7 and solo, not 4key, so if you make that into a file you can just put the notes you want into the first four columns and convert using the editor or by opening the .sm file in notepad and changing "dance-solo" to "dance-single".

[dascookieman]

it sucks to hear that some of you won't have time to finish your files but i can't postpone the deadline anymore, the pack is already huge and i don't want to postpone it, people have been waiting! i can just hope that you will find time in these last 8 days.

i also hope many of you who have files in purple will have time to make revisions, it should not take that much time

since it's nearing the deadline i'm gonna start asking around for graphics, i have a few people helping me but we could probably use some more help, it's a lot of files. give me a holler if you can help out with this =)

reviews coming later today

[Kraezymann]

Looking forward too it, wish I could have done something. *empty wishes*

[Nick Skyline]

Originally Posted by Arch0wl

http://www.sendspace.com/file/esphbb

I think I'll convert this to 4-key. It's a great friggin' song, but...what version of Stepmania would I need to view this chart?

[dascookieman]

a0 vs nick, looking forward to that


reviews:

fffff
accepted. in the beginning i thought it was gonna be too boring and simple, but the file becomes progressively harder and more diverse in a really cool way. more and more cool stuff happens with less and less boring parts in between. it's cool that it's low bpm like this too, it's a pretty unique file. really like it


empty skydiving
damn that's loooong lol. pretty cool though, the level of difficulty is good for a file this long and it's pretty cool overall. the pack needs another monstermarathon and this one is nothing like the other marathons in the pack so far. might go through it and mail you some notes later


street lethal guitar solo
it gets pretty old with all the 32nds and 24ths. it's just solos in annoying patterns that still are easy all the way through and it's all just 24ths and 32nds, didn't like it too much and i feel like it isn't accurate in quite a few spots. you can never really get into any kind of flow when playing this because of all the color notes..


the cry of youth
it has good tempo and flow and the patterns are good. but the file lacks a climax. the different 16ths parts get a bit boring and it's a shame that it doesn't build up to something more interesting. the end and the beginning parts have fun patterns to begin with but also gets a bit old as it looks so similar, i couldn't tell if it was accurate either. the stream in the middle is pretty cool but it would've been a lot better if the rest of the file was just similar 16ths rhythms all the time. if this was submitted in the beginning of the pack i would have given you lots of notes about how you should make it more varied and try to create a climax in the end of the file, but as of now the file has filled up it's quota of easy 16th files like this and i can't accept it.


autoprocess (revision)
really nice. accepted.


decomposition theory of loneliness and love
it's much too simple and uneventful. a long song with just easy 16th stream all the way through like this is not going to cut it. it would need some kind of build-up to a harder climax with something else than just 16ths, and it would also need a bigger part of it being at least in different rhythms (these things didn't exist in the song unfortunately), i kind of fell asleep playing this.

[xVaLoRx]

Originally Posted by dascookieman

fffff
accepted. in the beginning i thought it was gonna be too boring and simple, but the file becomes progressively harder and more diverse in a really cool way. more and more cool stuff happens with less and less boring parts in between. it's cool that it's low bpm like this too, it's a pretty unique file. really like it

awesoooooooooooooooome