FFR Community Pack

[Nightfirecat]

Originally Posted by omgitznpv

Submitted Gachagacha Cute Figu@mate (New Take).

Moches, if the Hardkore Atomic that you link to is not the one that's been sent to the e-mail, remove it. I've had EnR fix up a lot of stuff, and I don't want you guys playing the wrong file

Yeah, I thought the same thing... Didn't download the one that was listed, did the e-mail one...

[moches]

Originally Posted by omgitznpv

Submitted Gachagacha Cute Figu@mate (New Take).

Moches, if the Hardkore Atomic that you link to is not the one that's been sent to the e-mail, remove it. I've had EnR fix up a lot of stuff, and I don't want you guys playing the wrong file

Yeah, don't worry it's fixed now.

[kommisar[os]]

Originally Posted by robertsona

Kommi posted that he wanted to be a judge after I posted, fyi. But whatever, I guess it's up to you.

experience also comes into play when choosing judges

[Nightfirecat]

Quick note... When should first batch notes be ready by--how many files are we judging for batch 1?

[omgitznpv]

Originally Posted by kommisar[os]

experience also comes into play when choosing judges

yeah and robertsona knows jack **** about real judging. just says good, bad, etc.

Originally Posted by Nightfirecat

Quick note... When should first batch notes be ready by--how many files are we judging for batch 1?

i'm wondering about this too.

[moches]

Originally Posted by Nightfirecat

Quick note... When should first batch notes be ready by--how many files are we judging for batch 1?

i'd guess somewhere around 10-15....we're closing batch 1 in a week so yeah.

working on a couple files.

EDIT: Oh snap nevermind BATCH 1 is closed.

[EnR]

I also finished I <3 Voltage by Sabrepulse. I don't know how good it is now, since I suck at finiding errors in my own files.

[omgitznpv]

EnR: http://www.flashflashrevolution.com/...ad.php?t=86118
you can also hit me up on aim and have me test it like usual.

I'll probably have Gachagacha Hertz Figu@radio done this weekend. If I'm lucky, I'll have two Touhou files submitted, too.

Moches, sorry to bother you again- it's Gachagacha Cute Figu@mate (New Take)

[jimerax]

hehe Figu@.

[kommisar[os]]

i'm just gonna post reviews of whatever file gets submitted


Hardcore Atomic (*) - Rofl this is literally a mashfest. Gimmicks would've been cool in this and instead you added a bunch of jacks. The beginning was wrong also

Leave Brittney Alone (**) - Ok so the song isn't generous on giving good steps to work with, but this was pretty good. The middle part with hands was completely off though and needs to be fixed.

That mosaic.WAV song (**) - why didn't you submit this to rf2 it was way better than let's nyancing. it could've actually made it with a few fixes. so the song is way too long and should be cut since it pretty much repeats itself and gets annoying. great job with the steps though they were really fun. a few technical mistakes and inconsistencies but very fun.


so the last 2 i'd accept with those changes

[operationstrawbarry]

Have a bunch of songs... but between Rpack2 and this pack... kinda in a predicament. These files that I have are pretty good also... I guess I can send the ones I know wont get into the RFpack into this one.. Granted, these files are still pretty good even though.

Is RFpack even still going on though, because I heard of the hacking.

[moches]

oh, also, Kommi, could you give the star ratings with these? also, you could judge your own file if you wanted. yeah, otherwise, BATCH 1 is closed. I'll post my reviews in a sec.

edit: here they are

to people who submitted files:

look at what all four judges gave you in star ratings. if you got 12+ stars, the file is accepted, otherwise, keep working and getting better.

and remember, there is always room for improvement.

thanks for submitting!

Call of the Ancients v2: * A lot of misconstructed rhythms, lack of pitch relevancy. From what I played, this is kind of dumpy. I suggest you take a look at it and fix it up.

Elysium: ***1/2 Oh my god, I love this file. I’ve played it like ten times already. Pitch relevancy was awesome, and so was the rhythmic progression. Even though it was easy, it kept my attention for the whole file. One minor niggle, you missed a 16th note somewhere around 550 combo, but it’s purely optional, as that part could be interpreted two different ways. Kommi, you’ve impressed me once again.

Hardkore Atomic v2: **1/2 Okay file. Pitch relevancy wasn’t there, but this was really fun. I agree with Kommi on the basis that some parts required mashing.

Leave Britney Alone: *** My own file, lol. I’d say it’s pretty fun. Heavy has some vocal errors I’ll fix soon. Oni is better. I could make it more pitch relevant if you want, I guess, but that’s about it.

Gachagacha Cute Figu@mate: ***1/2 Snap, this definitely met my expectations. Freezes were well-executed, layering was clear, and the hands were a nice touch. Uh, the little 5-note scale thing wasn’t very pitch relevant, but that would just be stupid, pitch relevancy for the sake of pitch relevancy, so I’ll let you decide. Graphics were…..unique.

[EnR]

Rofl, I din't make mine PR because it's a DnB song and it would be repetitive as hell.

I can if you want tho.

[SkySeal]

The only judge I know is npv haha
if you're going to have just three judges, just make sure they're really strict.

[kommisar[os]]

i could get nazi but then nothing would make it in =<

[Nightfirecat]

Kay.. I'll post my reviews when I get home... But mostly they look a lot like moches' reviews, just not as extreme.. most are in the 2+3 range, but call of the ancients is a 1 or a 2.. pretty dumpy...

I liked gacha, scatter v4 and elisyum, and I didn't really like call of ancients and britney... All of them could use a bit of fixing up, but the first 3, I think are worth putting in, even as they are.

[omgitznpv]

wait if i played the right scatter v4 it sucked like wtf

yeah kommi about my file

i don't really songcut since i really don't believe in them. i only cut when it makes you want to throw your head out the window. but then again, why would i be stepping the song in the first place. also i submitted nyancing because everybody told me to and because i knew right off the bat that rebirth liked it anyways. also i didn't think my gachagacha cute figu@mate was too great anyways. it was just a sm'd up old file with holds and a couple of hands. the whole verse is a technical inaccuracy but i have the **** in there because it feels fun and if it was technically accurate it doesnt flow very well and it would either be as hard as fucc or easy as fucc or annoying as fucc. also i just realized its only da end of the file that really starts to make it tedious for me but i dont want to cut it

also why does batch 1 end now i still need to step gachagacha hertz figu@radio ;__;

oh well next batch i guess haha

i accepted HA barely it didnt seem like it could get too much better because of the song and the mashing parts were pretty fun for me anyways...
scatter and call of the ancients rejected as fucc
elysium accepted but there was one part that could be improved a tad
leave britney alone was pretty good but the song is too repetitive = repetitive steps = not too cool song choice sry rejected
gachagacha cute figu@mate obviously accepted my own file

[dood gone krazee]

Man, I gotta get stepping. I'm working on three right now, 2 for RFP2.

Bad timing for this pack.

How many batches are there going to be? If there were only like 6 stepfiles in this batch and your going for 30 simfiles... well thats 5 batches. **** I gotta hurry. XD

[omgitznpv]

*edit*

I think I played the wrong Scatter v4. I'm going to have to re-judge tonight. Sorry, guys, but just wait a bit

[Nightfirecat]

Originally Posted by dood gone krazee

How many batches are there going to be? If there were only like 6 stepfiles in this batch and your going for 30 simfiles... well thats 5 batches. **** I gotta hurry. XD

Uhh... actually, it looks like only 3 (maybe 4) are getting accepted, so it'll be more like 6-8 batches... About 1 per week, the way things are going.