TWG XCVII: The Flame War (Real Version)

[James May]

There goes a cop...rip Pedolad...

[James May]

And now to wait whether or not I got a seer...

[James May]

*sigh* blocked again...

[James May]

Tps, jrodd, ymia, v. I need to know exactly where you were last night phase.

[yo man im awesome]

I was at the Restaurant last night.

[James May]

One of the two is going to lie. We need to keep an eye on those who random'd

[James May]

Come on jrodd, tps and v...location is key...

[Vendetta21]

there's no keeping an eye on anything. this is bullshit simple james you must decide if jrodd or tps is a wolf.

two people have claimed fireman. there is only one fireman. quit looking for something besides their behaviors to analyze, that is what you must analyze and you must do it from the very beginning of the game up until now using your knowledge of who is who to reinterpret their posts.

i have made my decision but i am waiting for you guys to read the whole thread over again before i have this discussion.

also, pretty much anything jrodd or tps say now is moot in terms of the body of evidence you need to convict them. you can ask them for clarification, but mostly you should ignore everything that happened after dawn and go read the fuckin thread. you will not get any new information at this point. you should feel a good amount of stress and pressure right now because if anyone fucks up we all fuck up.

[Vendetta21]

and by "if anyone fucks up we all fuck up" i mean if any human votes for a non-wolf we lose

it is just that fuckin simple

[Vendetta21]

once everyone has read the thread we will then have a discussion whereby we don't vote until we have all (everyone but jrodd and tps) had a chance to weigh in

[cedolad]

glad I died, was weighing you guys down, I lost interest. Good luck.

[Tps222]

The difference is that JRodd claimed when he was nearing insta. This is purely defensive and was done solely to bide time to get an attempt to hit and end the game at night. He failed.

I'm 100% convinced he's an arson. My only fear is that he's the roleblocker instead of the last remaining arson. If this is the case, we will have 4 remaining people (TPS, V, YMIA, James) and 4 remaining houses. Instead of attempting to seer the last arson, we can just assign one person to each house. This makes it so that the max that can die tonight is 1, leaving us with 3 people at the start of tomorrow (assuming that to be some combination of either myself, V, YMIA, and James). At that point we'd have the difficulty of needing to make the right choice then and there. My gut is heavily leaning towards YMIA.

Although if JRodd is the sole remaining arson (which could be evidenced by his desperation claim yesterday) then we won't have to worry about any of that at all anyways.

Is there anything I missed in this plan? It seems pretty solid to me.

[Tps222]

Forgot to bold my vote. jrodd

[yo man im awesome]

Originally Posted by Vendetta21

once everyone has read the thread we will then have a discussion whereby we don't vote until we have all (everyone but jrodd and tps) had a chance to weigh in

pretty sure you missed this part, Tps, hah. We're trying to avoid putting votes on until we have all made our points, and we've all made a definitive choice.

[Tps222]

No, I read it. Jrodd falsely claimed my role, so unless he's a retarded human, I'm confident in my vote on him. Its assumed jrodd and I would vote for one another, which is why V said to wait on casting anymore votes.

[Vendetta21]

Originally Posted by yo man im awesome

pretty sure you missed this part, Tps, hah. We're trying to avoid putting votes on until we have all made our points, and we've all made a definitive choice.

so you caught the part where I told you to read the thread but decided to only respond to the superficial details?

come on man we don't need all the time in the world we just need to come to a conclusion.

[Vendetta21]

YMIA i'm extremely interested in your reasoning

[Vendetta21]

who do you think is a wolf and why

[yo man im awesome]

yo man im awesome
tps
James May
Vendetta
J-Rodd

I still haven't changed my thoughts.

I still think you're crazy enough to kill off your own ally to gain ultimate clemency. Your ability to lie straight through your teeth is impeccable, and it makes it nigh on impossible to tell what is and is not truth. But with the state things are in, I see no other way it could be. With James as the remaining Policeman, and my knowledge that I'm green, that leaves you, J-Rodd, and Tps.

Between J-Rodd and Tps, I still believe that J-Rodd is the other Red. Both parties have made some stupid mistakes, but J-Rodd's claim to Firefighter was out of pure desperation, while Tps' counterclaim was done of his own free will. He could have easily waited to be pressured into a near-insta situation, but he brought his point up as soon as he could.

[yo man im awesome]

And with that, in order to decide whether or not J-Rodd or Tps is in the right..

J-Rodd