Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

[Tasselfoot]

NO! files that are available for public distribution are automatically disqualified for consideration of being on FFR.

and i'd even go so far as to say that you if INTENTIONALLY did it, we'd ban you from submitting files to FFR for at least a few months. do it again, permanent (hint, hint blazze).

[Shashakiro]

I read Tass's post wrong and was about wtf, lol

without the exclamation point it looks like you're encouraging it in the first sentence >_>

[macgravel]

I don't mind QCing some files, to give you guys a break so you can keep on with the updates.

[Valtrix]

Seriously guys, I just rechecked Monster and it only has 8 measures of stream, most of which is fairly random, but why does that need to be tweaked at all? >_>

[MetalMethodMan]

God you people are so horrible at judging.

Wow, what a thankfull little guy.

Just FYI, I sent in cranky's Pure My Heart. The second one has the files needed, stupid me forgot it the first time.

Cheers, and a quick thanks to everybody helping to make this possible. You guys are obviously swamped.

[SulferDragon]

Originally Posted by MrPopadopalis25

Alright than. If somebody offers to review it (like dore, rebirth, hi19, etc.), are we allowed to send it to them?

Yeah, I'm pretty sure you can send it to people for checking.

P.S. All you guys are ungreatful crybabies. Be thankful you even have the chance to submit your files. You don't hear me whining about anything, do you?

[dore]

Originally Posted by SulferDragon

P.S. All you guys are ungreatful crybabies.

lol
QFT (except not directing at everyone ;p)

[Cyanite]

I'd be willing to if nobody else takes up the offer anytime soon.

[macgravel]

Originally Posted by MrPopadopalis25

Sweet.

So, anybody want to check my file?

Originally Posted by macgravel

I don't mind QCing some files, to give you guys a break so you can keep on with the updates.

I'll QC anyones files, but I will give harsh criticism.

[dAnceguy117]

Originally Posted by Tasselfoot

the above batch was up until March 28th.

I sent Color of Giggles to you on the 20th, and it's not on the list.

[hi19hi19]

Someone with some time please post a list of all the songs remaining in the queue and what batch they were reviewed in, so we can tell what is going in the game soon?

Thanks!

[Tasselfoot]

ugh... Alucard did this... but it doesn't say which batch it is from...

QUEUE
Abyss by Silver_Brian
Angel Stays on this Ground by Silver_Brian
Angelic Layer by Doug31
Battle Ax by macgravel & exag0n
Binary Rendezvous by rednanaki
Blue Army by Rebirth0 & Kit-
Bike Thief by Vote4Nixon & Rebirth0
Calm by hi19hi19
Chinaman by pokelda
Color of Giggles by danceguy
Dawn by Triplex72
Destiny v2 by hi19hi19
Disconnected by dore
Divinity by hi19hi19
Dokudenpa by macgravel
Drum Song by pokelda
Emotions v2 by Silver_Brian
Endless Dream by hi19hi19
Excite Bike by hi19hi19
Expedite by jimerax
Exotica by dore
Fahrenheit by Valtrix
Forza Azzurri by hi19hi19
Go! by Kit-
Harry Potter Techno Remix by jimerax
Hatten Carnival by BDN
Idol by hi19hi19
Incognito v2 by hi19hi19
In Memory by BLAZZE
J219 by Cyanite
{James Bond Techno} by BLAZZE
Judgement Days by Rebirth0
July by hi19hi19
K8107 by Exag0n
kakke ecko by jimerax
Kyuin by hi19hi19
Lesson by Rebirth0
Lift Up by ~Zero~
lolharp5000 by hi19hi19
{Losing Touch} by Cyanite
Love Cheat by Rebirth0
Luna Marionette by BDN
Manhattan Sapphire by Talisman
Maxx Attaxx by Silver_Brian
{Midnight} by jimerax
Mou Uta by Kotarouchan
Nice Nice Noise by Cyanite
Nippon Zenkoku by pokelda
Party4U v3 by hi19hi19
P8107 by Exag0n
Planetz by BDN
Plastic Mind by Kit-
Prison Break by hi19hi19
Prototypical by Silvuh
R3 by Silver_Brian
Ride Out by Cyanite
ROMeo & Juli8 by BLAZZE
Satori v2 by Kit-
Solitude Sun by Silver_Brian
So Long to the Circus by mead1
Speed Kitty by Valtrix
SSSG v2 by Silver_Brian
State of Emergency by Silver_Brian - do you want the heavy or oni?
Stunt Flying by Silver_Brian
{Sunlight} by MeaCulpa
Sunny Starry Carnival by Rebirth0
Sunshine Stone by sleeplessdragn
Sympathizer by Cyanite
Take Me Back by Brilliant Dynamite Neon
the Brain of the Moon by Rebirth0
the Pylons are TRAP BALLS by Alucard4_6
Trisection by hi19hi19
V1 by Silver_Brian
What-ever by Silver_Brian
Wrath by Psychozerosk8r
Youkoso! by Rebirth0
Zenon by rednanaki
Zodiac by dore

[Tasselfoot]

Needs Minor Tweaking
Kill 'Em All by dore - bad song choice for FFR, 700ish, overstepped, parts near end (PS - Metallica's Kill Em All... ftw)
Lataia by rednanaki - 32nd triplet possible 3-framer, missing notes in softer sections
Life Light by starfalcon176 - some melody not stepped, awkward
Lift Up by RashaHessh - zero's is better. some streams/jumps out of place
Orchestral Angels by Valtrix - gap wrong
Over the Frail Dream by SulferDragon - 200bpm jumpstream? 4th beat on blue arrows
Zen 2k5 by brothaice - ending slowdown? opening non-stream, flow.
Zen 2k5 by rednanaki - stream patterns, some 16ths go to nothing
~Monster~ by Valtrix - fix up stream patterns a bit
101 kittens by rednanaki - jacks, little bit of sync, background sounds stepped more in 1st half
Arashi by unforgiven0 - jump use, flow in beginning
Bike Theif by bluguerrilla - overstepped in parts, under in others. V4N & Rebirth's is better
Blue Sky by pokelda - repetitive, not a great Sharpnel song, patterns could be better, beginning a tad off
Crow Song by BDN - 12th chains (tass comment). jacks (shash comment) [tass comment: i don't remember if the chains ARE the jacks]
Dies Irae by BDN - fix up patterns to opening tune throughout
Disconnected Hazard by rednanaki - 2nd stream patterns
Happy Rainbow by bmah - no 12ths or 24ths in the file. long left handed trill.
20031023 v2 by Vishnal - offsync in beginning, yellow jumps... honestly, no need for a v2 for this song
AAA by Rebirth0 - blue/red switch
Delta Beat by ~Zero~ - jacks, jumps from jacks to 650ish
Digital Confession by ~Zero~ - 1st big 16th section is off
Euro Freak by Rebirth0 - 12th minijack
Melonman's OP by hi19hi19 - 12th jack
Panic Attack by dore - jumpstream, 16th jumps, 32nds
Song for all Time by dore - fix up final 24th
Sunshine Stone by Goldenwind - jumpstream, sleepless' is better
Twilight Zephyr by ~Zero~ - opening, blue/red switch
V1 by Rebirth0 - overstepped... Silver_Brian's is better
Winter by Rebirth0 - runningmen, 12th jack
A Beautiful Wings by Doug31 - inconsistent difficulty, some stream patterns
AAA by Cyanite - 450-480 offsync, some patterns
Absence of Light by MixMasterLar - too jumpy, fix runningmen
Blue Rose by Cyanite - overstepped, jacks, 24th trills
Comic Bakery by MixMasterLar - mp3 quality sucks, none of the non-8th notes fit
Dokudenpa by Cyanite - end offbeat, 16ths in quiet part, part in beginning should be blue jumps, part between the 2 streams understepped
Final Audition by bob bob - do we have permission? opening, trills, jacks
Fish on a Parachute by Valtrix - sync, 5 16th bursts rhythm, 8th jump-taps
Happy Rainbow by bmah - non-static difficulty, parts offsync, jumpjacks
Harry Potter by MetalMethodMan - better than jimerax's, but offsync and a bit overjumped.
Melonman's OP by Valtrix - overstepped, patterns
K8107 by Brilliant Dyanmite Neon - Exag0n's is better
Otter's Dance by starfalcon176 - beginning bursts has notes to no music
Pretty Green Onions by pokelda - yes, the all 64ths is cute... fix it to real noteskin colors please
Shind Bad by rednanaki - jump use, some rhythms could be better
Solitude Sun by Brilliant Dyanmite Neon - repetitive, jumps, awkward 16ths
We Met Dat Night by MooMoo_CowFreak - sync? patterns could be fixed up a bit
{Colossus} by SulferDragon - bpm, jacks, 8th beats in a few places off
{Sunlight} by Silvuh - parts overstepped, 16ths understepped

[eastsideman09]

i know the songs ive submitted are prolly in the next batch...

but

im getting anxious to see some feedback on them

[rshadow8888]

Same here

[macgravel]

Originally Posted by Tasselfoot

QUEUE
Dokudenpa by macgravel

I didn't know that got accepted XD

[SulferDragon]

Originally Posted by Tasselfoot

{Colossus} by SulferDragon - bpm, jacks, 8th beats in a few places off

Haha, I completely forgot about {Colossus}. I think I'm going to go back to it. I know exactly what to do now, and I have a different idea for the steps at a few spots XD

[Cyanite]

I'd update my Doku file but your review for it was pretty vague.. not sure what to change.

Not really complaining, I'm fine with leaving it unfixed.

Originally Posted by Tasselfoot

i'm going off of some others... best examples are rednanaki and cyanite. both will likely admit that they submitted a TON of files right off the bat, and every single one of them was Needs Work or worse (MAYBE 1 Needs Minor Tweaking). so from there, they had to go back, take our advice... re-submit. many of their stuff is on 4+ revisions and still rejected, but they both ARE getting some of their stuff in now.

Yeah I sent some of my first simfiles to you immediately, though your initial advice definitely helped me out while you were still sending me it.

Though up around the time I had about 11 files in the queue at one time, I thought most of them landed in Needs Minor Tweaking. Most of the unbearably bad files I sent you were sent before you even made this thread.

[Tasselfoot]

yea... most of your really big batch went into NMT. you and red were just the best examples i could give of someone sending in a buttload of files at once without a single file already in queue.

batch != queue... don't interchange the words.

[Brilliant Dynamite Neon]

WTF, I never submitted a Dies Irae. You must be referring to rednanaki's. And I fixed Crow Song already.