Submissions Reopened For FMO/FGO Simfiles ONLY

[Rebirth0]

Re: Submissions Reopened For FMO/FGO Simfiles ONLY

Yeah I kinda just started today, but I have 20 sims done already. Judging as strict as ****, and I'm not really seeing any really good sims so far

jx, what sim of mine got the x? haha

[EnR]

Re: Submissions Reopened For FMO/FGO Simfiles ONLY

jx, what sim of mine got the x? haha

Setsuju or w/e..

And Tera, theres no way rebirth will accept it after what he said in this post, judging strict as ****.

[Netjet!]

Re: Submissions Reopened For FMO/FGO Simfiles ONLY

Haha mine sucked nuts, I bet it got a -- or worse..

[EnR]

Re: Submissions Reopened For FMO/FGO Simfiles ONLY

I don't like this fmo thing anymore, it's been pissing me off. **** sakes

[Netjet!]

Re: Submissions Reopened For FMO/FGO Simfiles ONLY

I'd rather just have another batch of regular files. And IMO the hands part of this fmo/fgo thing kinda makes it worse.

[jimerax]

Re: Submissions Reopened For FMO/FGO Simfiles ONLY

I doubt rebirth will accept double digit files from this batch.

[EnR]

Re: Submissions Reopened For FMO/FGO Simfiles ONLY

Rebirth told me this on AIM

ok so I'm really thinking
I might honestly be accepting under 10 sims for this batch
and 4 or 5 would be my own

[Netjet!]

Re: Submissions Reopened For FMO/FGO Simfiles ONLY

<DIV id=5202 style="BACKGROUND-COLOR: transparent"><FONT color=black><SPAN style="FONT: 12px Arial; COLOR: #0f0595"> Rebirthsan

Huh lol

[gnr61]

Re: Submissions Reopened For FMO/FGO Simfiles ONLY

enr i had a small list of notes i was going to tell you about hardkore after i told you it was good and i couldn't really judge deep into it atm, but you never reminded me and i forgot ;_;

[EnR]

Re: Submissions Reopened For FMO/FGO Simfiles ONLY

out of all the people that tested it, nobody freghan noticed that one thing that could have made the file get accepted.

EW gavce me like 15 things to fix..lemme go back and see if anything involved 48ths

-end of bar 6/start of bar 7 should be a double jack
-9-20 section could stand to have jacks because pitch relevancy
-end of measure 20 could be 32nds (consistency)
-end of bar 37/start of bar 38 could either stay a jack or change; It took me until I went to the editor to see why you chose what you did.
-24th trills going to melody in 42-48 section are inconsistent and feel sorta weird
-49-57 section has some rhythms slightly wrong, e.g. missing 12ths
-pattern that looks like an 8 in measure 52 could stand to be jacked up a bit, e.g. change the inside double to an outside one
-Same 24th complaint in measure 53-54, plus it's covering up a 24thy drum pattern here so you wouldn't have to sacrifice the whole burst
-end of bar 66/start of bar 67 should have double/single switched around
-Burst in 66 is a little much, remove some jacks or doubles maybe
-end of bar 69/all of bar 70 has a unique loud synth going on, maybe use hands?
-same comment as for the 9-20 section at the start of the 73+ section

Yea.....

[Silver_Brian]

Re: Submissions Reopened For FMO/FGO Simfiles ONLY

Judging should be this strict for all files.

[EnR]

Re: Submissions Reopened For FMO/FGO Simfiles ONLY

I can tell rebirth is like 50x more strict then JX, rebirth accepted 3/30 files that he's tested so far rofl.

[Silver_Brian]

Re: Submissions Reopened For FMO/FGO Simfiles ONLY

They were all his rofl. Actually, I don't know at all.

[EnR]

Re: Submissions Reopened For FMO/FGO Simfiles ONLY

JX din't judge his own file, but Rebirth judges all of his own and that's like all he's accepting atm.. >_> we can't all step files like JX and Rebirth.

[bmah]

Re: Submissions Reopened For FMO/FGO Simfiles ONLY

>_> we can't all step files like JX and Rebirth.

It's more along the lines of "we can't all step files to everyone's liking" rather than comparing our simfiles to theirs.