FFR Hall of Fame 2023 - Voting Thread

[jh05013]

Re: FFR Hall of Fame 2023 - Voting Thread

PS. If you have other reasons or achievements you can think of for our nominees to be voted for, please share them! The more we know about our nominees, the better.

Shoutout to Deamerai and Pizza69 for creating some of the hardest files on FFR (goTe EX, Blue Streaks of Happiness, and DsMaxInkd). After 3 years of charting myself, it's still unimaginable to me being able to touch a realm of 115+ and make it well-received and interesting even to lower-level players.

[Josemba]

Re: FFR Hall of Fame 2023 - Voting Thread

samurai7694

This man got full Tier Points once 1000/1000
He also achieved 1.00 avg rank, and had all the songs AAA'd only Death Piano and RATO being left (which he had good ranks in these). Membrane kb and Standalone version lol

[T-Force]

Re: FFR Hall of Fame 2023 - Voting Thread

As an update, after thinking hard on it, I realize that with 13 nominees - and only 5 votes allowed per ballot - 50% is probably to harsh of a cut-off.
40% seems more accurate seeing as 5 of 13 is approx. 38.46% so you'd still need to make a good portion of ballots, considering the competition, and that's not even factoring ballots that can have under 5 votes.
It would also keep in line with last year as 40% was the unofficial cut-off as well.

(for transparency, 2 people are currently over 50%; 5 (including the aforementioned 2) are at 40% or higher, and the 3 non-50's are close to dipping below)

If a year came with only 10 or 11 nominees, 50% would be more feasible, imo, but as it is with 13, I think making it equal to the amount of votes allowed versus people that can be voted makes more sense.

If this is a bad idea, yell at me now before I make this change.

EDIT: That said, even if 6, or more, people break the 40% threshold, only the top 5 get in.

[xXOpkillerXx]

Re: FFR Hall of Fame 2023 - Voting Thread

As an update, after thinking hard on it, I realize that with 13 nominees - and only 5 votes allowed per ballot - 50% is probably to harsh of a cut-off.
40% seems more accurate seeing as 5 of 13 is approx. 38.46% so you'd still need to make a good portion of ballots, considering the competition, and that's not even factoring ballots that can have under 5 votes.
It would also keep in line with last year as 40% was the unofficial cut-off as well.

(for transparency, 2 people are currently over 50%; 5 are at 40% or higher, and the 3 non-50's are close to dipping below)

If a year came with only 10 or 11 nominees, 50% would be more feasible, imo, but as it is with 13, I think making it equal to the amount of votes allowed versus people that can be voted makes more sense.

If this is a bad idea, yell at me now before I make this change.

EDIT: That said, even if 6, or more, people break the 40% threshold, only the top 5 get in.

My first thoughts reading this is that it's a bit of a weird timing/situation. You're a nominee, and you seem to know the current state of the votes. This decision seems like it could be perceived as bias in your own favor.

That being said, I voted for you so I'd hope you win it, and the above concern is as objective as possible.

[XJ-9]

Re: FFR Hall of Fame 2023 - Voting Thread

I'd be fine with a 40% threshold because of how it would match with last year. However, I wouldn't argue if most people would rather have it stay at 50%. Next year will most likely see some adjustments either way.

[xXOpkillerXx]

Re: FFR Hall of Fame 2023 - Voting Thread

If only for the sake of avoiding any conflict of interest, I'd suggest any changes are made after the event. There will also be 2 result sets to take into consideration once this one is done so it'll be even better to discuss the changes with the community (as opposed to analysing things mid-voting-phase).

[Lights]

Re: FFR Hall of Fame 2023 - Voting Thread

As an update, after thinking hard on it, I realize that with 13 nominees - and only 5 votes allowed per ballot - 50% is probably to harsh of a cut-off.
40% seems more accurate seeing as 5 of 13 is approx. 38.46% so you'd still need to make a good portion of ballots, considering the competition, and that's not even factoring ballots that can have under 5 votes.
It would also keep in line with last year as 40% was the unofficial cut-off as well.

(for transparency, 2 people are currently over 50%; 5 (including the aforementioned 2) are at 40% or higher, and the 3 non-50's are close to dipping below)

If a year came with only 10 or 11 nominees, 50% would be more feasible, imo, but as it is with 13, I think making it equal to the amount of votes allowed versus people that can be voted makes more sense.

If this is a bad idea, yell at me now before I make this change.

EDIT: That said, even if 6, or more, people break the 40% threshold, only the top 5 get in.

do it. fuggit

[T-Force]

Re: FFR Hall of Fame 2023 - Voting Thread

If only for the sake of avoiding any conflict of interest, I'd suggest any changes are made after the event. There will also be 2 result sets to take into consideration once this one is done so it'll be even better to discuss the changes with the community (as opposed to analysing things mid-voting-phase).

I appreciate the apprehension here, especially with your prior post talking about the bias that I may have. All I can give is my word that I'm not doing it for my own sake, and hope that my judgement can be trusted on this if the change does occur.

[xXOpkillerXx]

Re: FFR Hall of Fame 2023 - Voting Thread

I appreciate the apprehension here, especially with your prior post talking about the bias that I may have. All I can give is my word that I'm not doing it for my own sake, and hope that my judgement can be trusted on this if the change does occur.

Erff I really tried to word things carefully. I'm sorry, honestly. Look I wouldn't have voted for you if I didn't believe one of the major point in your nomination text, which is that you're a very trustworthy person. I just wanted to keep things as fair as possible but I probably shouldve simply not commented on this. Fwiw I personally don't mind whatever decision is made on this idea.

[T-Force]

Re: FFR Hall of Fame 2023 - Voting Thread

Oh, you're all good, dude.

[xXOpkillerXx]

Re: FFR Hall of Fame 2023 - Voting Thread

Oh, you're all good, dude.

Woop~

[rayword45]

Re: FFR Hall of Fame 2023 - Voting Thread

do it. fuggit

yes

[Wayward Vagabond]

Re: FFR Hall of Fame 2023 - Voting Thread

Wow i havent been active in years and haven't contributed anything in just as long and i wasn't nominated?! Blasphemy