-
Re: TWG CLIX: Form your special exclusive groups now! - Game Thread
No scum tells, hmm?
What about SK tells, Xel?
Originally posted by Vendetta21Comment
-
Re: TWG CLIX: Form your special exclusive groups now! - Game Thread
Sad that Pre only left a little bitty post and didn't talk to MML like I wanted.
Unfortunate, I expect the two of you to talk (As in both MML and Precarious are ACTIVELY in the thread) way in advance before EoD this phase. Failure to comply will result in unsatisfactory actions on Precarious.
Originally posted by Vendetta21Comment
-
Re: TWG CLIX: Form your special exclusive groups now! - Game Thread
Both the wolf and SK managed to hit town players and avoid doubling up on the same player. This isn't necessarily the best result for them, since as the player population dwindles, they need to worry about each other as well as the town.
You seem like you've been leading somewhere with night kills analysis, but you refuse to actually say something. Please do.
***
1. The wolf and SK won't necessarily target people that suspect them, as that's easily traceable. Of course that kind of thinking inevitably leads to WIFOM, but
2. While DFR is no longer in the game, you are, so roundbox's suspicion remains at least somewhat relevant.
***
Impression reads, before I actually iso. I don't know if the difference between how I feel now and how I'll feel after closer re-reads is relevant, but hey.
Zenith: Performance has been consistent. I don't remember any posts that really deviated from his basic way of playing, other than shit posting that story at the beginning of the third day. I found an illogical point in his thinking yesterday, which was never addressed, but to be fair it was a relatively minor point. Mostly smooth tone, other than our conflict yesterday.
Charu: Town mechanically. His actual play has been trending down (going from the huge page posts of the first day to actively refusing to answer questions today), but that has no bearing on his alignment. I just wish he'd say more, since he's clearly capable of it.
Prec: Town. Feel free to ask me whatever.
MML: Has been improving the towniness of his play since entering; his starting posts were overly antagonistic and argued with claimed PRs, but has made more thoughtful posts since, and pushes people to do things. I like that he challenged Charu to interrogate him.
Xel: Xel started out the game with a bunch of nonsense that never made sense to me (from the perspective of any alignment). Since then, he's turned to a more conventional style of play (the usual cocktail of reads and thoughts and basic interactions), although I frequently disagree with the conclusions. Overall it feels a little superficial, but not overly so.
Mellon: Extremely quiet and low on activity for most of the game, then made several good posts near the end of the second day and the beginning of the third. Those posts make me hesitant to wolf/sk-read mellon, but the lack of activity is not a good look, since it makes him less likely to be night-attacked. That he pushed DFR without being unfair about it felt positive. Not thrilled about how quiet he's been since.
***
Based purely on how I feel about their overall games, I'd lean toward Xel and Mellon as anti-town, but it's more complicated than that now. Since only one wolf is left, yesterday and today they've essentially functioned as a second SK. There's no one for them to protect or distance from, and it's as important for them as for us to find their counterpart (perhaps even moreso, since if the wolf or the SK nightkills the other, the killed one loses the game). I'm going to review the whole game and see what turns up. I'd recommend that everyone do the same.Comment
-
Re: TWG CLIX: Form your special exclusive groups now! - Game Thread
I'm not gonna share now, maybe later though.
Originally posted by Vendetta21Comment
-
Re: TWG CLIX: Form your special exclusive groups now! - Game Thread
It's not complicated at all. One of them has played kind of below average but not too far below while the other one is clearly a wolf trying their best to stay hidden.
Must be tough bein' an SK in that situation, eh? Looks like you're going for a gamble.
I can respect that
Originally posted by Vendetta21Comment
-
Re: TWG CLIX: Form your special exclusive groups now! - Game Thread
And by gamble, I mean what I just crafted for you to do.
Cute
Originally posted by Vendetta21Comment
-
Re: TWG CLIX: Form your special exclusive groups now! - Game Thread
Or, I wish you'd say more because your current style of play isn't productive. I ask you for elaboration, you say "Maybe later." When you're asked "Charu whatta ya thoughts on it?", you answer "No." You say you want to lynch Mellon, who you seem convinced is a wolf, yet you do nothing to persuade anyone else to follow along. I'm not even going to say you'd look scummy as hell if you weren't cleared, because your current game is so overtly anti-town that no actual non-town role would try it.
But this is a team game. Even if whatever assumptions you have (and aren't sharing) are perfectly correct, down to the smallest detail, they mean nothing if you don't share them with us. They provide no avenues for further conversation, they do nothing to pressure players or get others to trip up or join in, they do nothing to actually get players lynched. They exist in your head alone, and offer nothing to the game state.
You seem suspicious of me. Fine. Then share those suspicions. Because if it gets other people talking, then maybe I'll see something they say that rings false. You're certainly correct about one thing: we are facing a potential MiLo situation. If we mislynch and the remaining wolf and SK kill town again tonight, then we're looking at 1:1:1 tomorrow. It's critical that we get either the wolf or the SK today, and your play isn't contributing.Comment
-
Re: TWG CLIX: Form your special exclusive groups now! - Game Thread
Sounds like you're mad and you're attacking the one thing you can only attacking me about.
Originally posted by Vendetta21Comment
-
Re: TWG CLIX: Form your special exclusive groups now! - Game Thread
Though I guess I got a question for ya, my dear sweet highly likely SK.
Who is the SK you can point at right now without giving reasons.
Originally posted by Vendetta21Comment
-
Re: TWG CLIX: Form your special exclusive groups now! - Game Thread
Zenith darlin', if you could get to what I asked you about, that be much appreciated. Don't think I haven't notice you lurking the thread.
Originally posted by Vendetta21Comment
Comment