Keyboardsmash Phase I: Legacy Submissions Open

[Ghakimx]

Originally Posted by stargroup100

Oh I just followed Rebirth's list because I wanted to review charts in the order of submission, and it wasn't on the list. I'll review right now, I apologize.

Amatias - I would've taken out a lot of those miniholds. I don't think they're necessary in my opinion, as the cymbals already have dedicated triples. Overall it has the potential to be really fun, but a somewhat significant issue is the pattern choices. It's hard to explain, but it just feels kind of weird throughout. There are a lot of ways in which you have the right idea, such as the piano section, but execution falls just a bit short because you miss certain details. A lot of these issues would be almost insignificant by themselves, but here they're so prevalent it almost pervades your charting style. It could be good though, it just needs that push. I get the feeling you might want, and you should ask for, a detailed review from me. Pending

Do tell, stargrope.

@ Gundam-Dude: the 12th guitar solo is a bitch. If I layer anything else, it becomes a polyrhythm and that's problematic, hence the super simplified layering. What do you suggest? Also, I don't really hear any other changes to the solo, other than 2 12th notes becoming 16ths.