The Simfile Quality Debate

[Kraezymann]

So I am confused, please help me out.

Pertaining to the songs stargroup and kaiten123 are talking about; I haven't listened to either song, so no one can say that one song is better than another, right?. Because there is no proof that its true?

Its the same when I see posts about files. Until I play a certain file, no one is right, correct? Because at that point all I am reading are opinions about it. And so, the file becomes completely subjective (unless there is something mathematically wrong with it, like offset or the song is of poor audio quality), right?

I think that having something that doesn't have anything special about it (sg provided Planet Karma as an example) still wouldn't appeal to everyone, because of the fact that it doesn't have anything special about it:

Originally Posted by stargroup

==Planet KARMA== is almost universally liked because it doesn't contain strong features that the community is unfamiliar with

Wouldn't someone find that boring? Unoriginal?

Since it is impossible to please everyone at any given time, there can be no basis for something to be factually better than something else.

Or did I completely miss the point? Remember, I don't quite understand everything within the debate, so I probably screwed up somewhere.