Wish (Reprise) Petition

[HammyMcSquirrel]

Originally Posted by Tasselfoot

perhaps you should get a petition going.

You got it! =P

Originally Posted by Rebirth0

I'd sign it. Hammy's Wish file is good.

This is a petition to see who wants Wish (Reprise), a stepfile of mine, in FFR. The artist of this masterpiece is iPatcH.

Here's the situation...

This stepfile has gone through a few batch reviews over the months, and has gone through multiple revisions each time. It has improved greatly, and it could hold a place in the game. In the most recent batch review, it got the following marks:

Originally Posted by Rebirth

Wish: +
- Good simfile

Originally Posted by Jimerax

iPatcH - Wish (Reprise) (HammyMcSquirrel) [+?] - too many crossovers/runningmen without good reason

What I can do is fix up those parts until Jimerax agrees that the file is decent enough for a +. The problem is, though...

Originally Posted by Tasselfoot

Wish - don't need a 3rd file for Wish

This is where the petition comes into play!

I feel that this file does deserve a place in FFR. Tass sees it as a 3rd file of Wish, but I would hardly call Wish (Kyrn Remix) a "Wish remix" (Wish (Kyrn Remix) was the second file of Wish that was recently put in the game). There are no recognizable beats in it to make it sound like the original Wish, and the only thing that even brings it to being related to Wish are the lyrics, which are remixed from Wish (Radio Mix). Don't get me wrong, the melody was done well...But it doesn't do a good job in having the status of a Wish remix. Therefore, I look at that file not as a second version of Wish, but as its own separate song, since it is so different.

As you saw with the remarks earlier, this stepfile is decent as it is. I can make it better by fixing up the few kinks Jimerax noted, but I want to be able to get it in the game. If the majority wants it in the game, then why not have it in the game? It shouldn't be turned down just because Tass doesn't want a "third" version of the song. Give this a chance!

I appreciate any support in this! It's worth a shot.

Pages 255-257 (@ 20 posts/page) in the "A List of ALL the Songs in the FFR Queue" thread explain what led up to this petition.

List of those who want to give Wish (Reprise) a chance:
HammyMcSquirrel
iPatcH
dore
Rebirth0
eastsideman09
DarkbearX
jugglinguy
Janeille
Kotarouchan
All_That_Chaz
rshadow8888
Silvuh
Fantasticone
hi19hi19
Xandertrax
thechild
behanjc
spinal_compression
SulferDragon
smartdude1212
Shouka
Sequal
blindreper1179
MixMasterLar
psychopete
y0ttabyte
Justice Beloved
revolutionomega
Valtrix
flipsta_lombax
DrugstoreCowboy
FrenzyMidget
jellygod
-Moo-
Zageron
hyprskillz
BEN.(SPEIRS) 7.5
Coolboyrulez0
bmah
scottish
g4z33b0
Brilliant Dynamite Neon
TK_pavonineukon
GamerShadow
bluguerrilla
swamp14
Bottlecaps Music (Bottlecaps)
freakysnots
EnR
jpcduran
remedy1502
magirocker
Cj_leonine
mike2727
andili
Xezial
stargroup100
JoyaOscura
SoultakerNFH
Conorn
6 p01nt3d*st@r
Coolgamer
ieatyourlvllol
TK_Breed
Koltasquick
Black Yoshi
Gray Fox
Draigun
MagicCarpetRide
MrRubix
Neonatrias
CR_fLiP_fOaM
lXD
brothaice
.dot
customstuff
dAnceguy117
Turboyoshi
T3hDDRkid
Spenner
u84
[HectoGtzMX]
Sprite-
Tayfun
burningeyes88
DarkManticoreX2
gabgabo
arsonistsgetallthegirls
l Endorphin l
powerfull
HighBuddha
gnr61
Biff_tech
PsYcHoZeRoSk8eR
Problems
Fimbulvetr
omgitznpv
ninjaKIWI
dawg4321
ninjafury
sheckler

Total: 100