Life After Death...

[Aa_Doodaa]

For a while i've had this question in my head, but no one to explain it to. The question is:

Do people of different religions experience the same afterlife?

In further detail, let's say there was a religion which harbored the idea that after death, a person experienced his/her own life again, and there was another religion that said people were reincarnated as a different person in a different time and place. Let's also say that there are two people that are very orthodox one of these religions, to each their own.

Would the person belonging to one religion experience what he was taught that he would experience after death, and the other person what he was taught? Or would they each experience the same as everyone else, what universally happens after death?

Also, an attached question, what do you think the afterlife consists of?