TWG 194 - Game Thread

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

Namely, the possibility that MML was scum. Timing wise, he claimed after DBP, so there's that. He did have one post before the claim that seemed to hint at his claim of roleblocker, but it came after my post fully claiming. It's the "I forgot" excuse that makes this look weird, as it makes it convenient as to when he chose to go after Mikey. Of course though, it's things like the D2 claim that the roleblock was on Mikey specifically that makes this a little hard to believe, as scum had to have roleblocked Xiz. It would have had to be a lucky accident, although it does go with the "I forgot" excuse and waiting to claim after all power roles are out.

If MML was scum then why wouldn't wolves just roleblock -and- NK DBP ?

That's where it doesn't make sense to me.

[leetic]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

if you mean "rescind" then bitch WHAT

Kill this man next phase

It is notable that MML and DBP have posted a lot of the same thoughts, sometimes at the same time (so it can't be sheeping). It is hard to see a world where they are not the same alignment.

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

If you believe that DBP is real, I think it's reasonable to also believe that MML is real.

[leetic]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

If MML was scum then why wouldn't wolves just roleblock -and- NK DBP ?

That's where it doesn't make sense to me.

As I said, the only reason wolves would no kill is to add believability to a roleblocker claim. Since it's MyLo, they really have nothing to lose.

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

As I said, the only reason wolves would no kill is to add believability to a roleblocker claim. Since it's MyLo, they really have nothing to lose.

Well, if that's true then your wolf team would be DBP/MML/X.

[leetic]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

Well, if that's true then your wolf team would be DBP/MML/X.

As I said, a roleblocker claim. At least one of MML/DBP must be town.

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

In that world, Duskfall would also be town and the goal would be to fake a Haku/Duskfall thunderdome.

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

As I said, a roleblocker claim. At least one of MML/DBP must be town.

I would simply never no kill in that scenario and always eliminate the town roleblocker.

That's a really awkward play if real.

[leetic]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

In that world, Duskfall would also be town and the goal would be to fake a Haku/Duskfall thunderdome.

In that world, there would be only two wolves, as well as an SK. That world is not worth considering.

[MixMasterLar]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

Alright, so I grilled DBP on this issue. So there's one more thing that's possibly a bit tinfoil but we need to get this out of the way to ensure we are looking at this from all possible sides.

Namely, the possibility that MML was scum. Timing wise, he claimed after DBP, so there's that. He did have one post before the claim that seemed to hint at his claim of roleblocker, but it came after my post fully claiming. It's the "I forgot" excuse that makes this look weird, as it makes it convenient as to when he chose to go after Mikey. Of course though, it's things like the D2 claim that the roleblock was on Mikey specifically that makes this a little hard to believe, as scum had to have roleblocked Xiz. It would have had to be a lucky accident, although it does go with the "I forgot" excuse and waiting to claim after all power roles are out.

IDK if you particularly want to hash this out with me as the counter argument but if I'm scum and DBP is town I was drinking bleach when i decided to jump all in instead of let two towns do my job for me.

If both DBP and I are scum then it's....a little less stupid? It's still really dumb and I 100% just let my partner handle it in this case. Most players here only hesitated on the FFA wagon because i claimed and that called DBP into question, otherwise had it just been the 2 of them I'm sure DBP seeing the hardclaim after Mikey caused so much trouble with his bullshit "totes got a redcheck then we would have all lynched him no issue. Had I been VT and saw that, woulda done the same.

But I wasnt and when I realized that i actually had the proof that Mikey was full of shit I came forward then because sitting on it past that point woulda been worse.

But as wolf? Coming forward doesnt benefit me if I'm wolf

[leetic]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

I would simply never no kill in that scenario and always eliminate the town roleblocker.

That's a really awkward play if real.

They only need one mislynch to win though. If they can get one of their team members to never be voted, that's a huge advantage going in.

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

While it's not 100% full proof, I still think it's relatively safe to clear DBP/MML/Leetic from the game.

I wonder if everyone is relatively okay with town reading Ulli/ShadoWolfe.

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

Note that I'm usually wrong on these calls so, MML/DBP is probably W/W.

Haku, stop

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

I think without the MML claim, DBP would have died in the FFA/DBP thing especially if FFA didn't rescind.

The question is if it was the right call.

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

I still think they have enough progression to justify being town read.

If MML got lucky with the hypocop FFA thing as a wolf then gj I'd say.