jTWG LXXXIV: 8 New Players and Raeko Game Thread

[MarioNintendo]

Re: jTWG LXXXIV: 8 New Players and Raeko Game Thread

Everyone seems to trust you and your arguments sound good.

There's a flaw in your reasoning.

Yes, everyone trusts I'm town. BECAUSE I'm town, it also means I do not have knowledge of who the wolves are. The way I see this is, the more you know someone is town, the more you know they don't know anything. I'm just shooting ideas.

If you follow my ideas blindly, you are one of two things:
- A wolf taking advantage of my ideas (because they fit your agenda)
- A lazy town

I liked you more when you were voting for gold stinger. Alas, I disagreed with your vote, but at least it showed some effort to challenge ideas (gold stinger is a hard town). You were starting to make waves.

Your tone/intent completely shifted right after my posts. It's too sudden. It's weird. It's as if you didn't believe anything when you were voting for gold stinger.

[ShyYoshiGuy]

Re: jTWG LXXXIV: 8 New Players and Raeko Game Thread

wait, what happened to your gold stinger vote?

He’s close behind, but your reasoning is better than mine. My reasoning’s just that his argument doesn’t hold any bound.

[dragonmegaXX]

Re: jTWG LXXXIV: 8 New Players and Raeko Game Thread

Fair enough, I kind of assumed each thought was it’s own separate thing and weren’t necessarily connected. Just wanted to clarify.

[Antori]

Re: jTWG LXXXIV: 8 New Players and Raeko Game Thread

my vote is gonna be back on goldstinger if dragon flips town cause i had gut he's wolfing
i still dont think mellon would be this inactive as wolf

[Antori]

Re: jTWG LXXXIV: 8 New Players and Raeko Game Thread

thanks for the "my takeaway"s MN

[ShyYoshiGuy]

Re: jTWG LXXXIV: 8 New Players and Raeko Game Thread

There's a flaw in your reasoning.

Yes, everyone trusts I'm town. BECAUSE I'm town, it also means I do not have knowledge of who the wolves are. The way I see this is, the more you know someone is town, the more you know they don't know anything. I'm just shooting ideas.

If you follow my ideas blindly, you are one of two things:
- A wolf taking advantage of my ideas (because they fit your agenda)
- A lazy town

I liked you more when you were voting for gold stinger. Alas, I disagreed with your vote, but at least it showed some effort to challenge ideas (gold stinger is a hard town). You were starting to make waves.

Your tone/intent completely shifted right after my posts. It's too sudden. It's weird. It's as if you didn't believe anything when you were voting for gold stinger.

Well ‘cuz my argument doesn’t sound as good in my head now, you convinced me. Though, I mean, voting for GS was just so he would explain himself, but that didn’t work, so.

[Antori]

Re: jTWG LXXXIV: 8 New Players and Raeko Game Thread

people i think are pretty town: mellon, MN
people i think are suspect wolf: GS, dragon

[ShyYoshiGuy]

Re: jTWG LXXXIV: 8 New Players and Raeko Game Thread

If you follow my ideas blindly, you are one of two things:
- A wolf taking advantage of my ideas (because they fit your agenda)
- A lazy town

Much less lazy, much more because I have no clue what I’m doing. But I am also lazy because I’m busy.

[MarioNintendo]

Re: jTWG LXXXIV: 8 New Players and Raeko Game Thread

Just realize that by voting on melloncollie you are defending her more than she could have ever hoped to do by herself, is all.

[the sun fan]

Re: jTWG LXXXIV: 8 New Players and Raeko Game Thread

Sanzath (1)- gold stinger
Dragon (1)- Antori
Antori (1)- Dragon
raeko (2)- Mario, Shy

[ShyYoshiGuy]

Re: jTWG LXXXIV: 8 New Players and Raeko Game Thread

Just realize that by voting on melloncollie you are defending her more than she could have ever hoped to do by herself, is all.

So it’s a bad thing that I agree with you?

[ShyYoshiGuy]

Re: jTWG LXXXIV: 8 New Players and Raeko Game Thread

It was a bad idea the last times I forgot to say I had to go, so I’m saying it now. I’ve gotta go help move.

[MarioNintendo]

Re: jTWG LXXXIV: 8 New Players and Raeko Game Thread

So it’s a bad thing that I agree with you?

It's just the last thing I expected you to do. Because it challenges the way I pictured you as I was making my vote, it challenges my vote.

I'm sticking to my guns and will leave my vote here for the moment. But I don't like this situation one bit.

As far as I'm concerned, you guys should wait for melloncollie to defend herself (I know she will) before jumping on the wagon.

[MarioNintendo]

Re: jTWG LXXXIV: 8 New Players and Raeko Game Thread

In the post above I'm talking about my vote for melloncollie, sorry for the confusion d-future peeps

[mellon_collie]

Re: jTWG LXXXIV: 8 New Players and Raeko Game Thread

I don't think gold stinger is the wolf....
But if my earlier reasoning is correct, I don't think you're wolf either.

Really, one scenario I'm seeing here that ticks all the boxes is melloncollie

* Doesn't post a lot
* Town reads everyone (she did ask Antori to defend themself, but melloncollie never made a flat-out wolf read)
* Is the most likely to tell Shadow_God to STFU in wolf chat as illustrated in my thought #2
* I can see Shadow_God reacting within 2 minutes to melloncollie telling him to STFU


(melloncollie probably didn't use the words STFU, but you get the idea)

Your first two points are fair enough, especially about not posting. I'm hoping to get better in that regard today. I'm really not town reading everybody but I get that I haven't exactly made that clear

as for your other point, your posts are a bit dense so sorry if I'm missing something

but just to be clear you think shadow's partner told him to stop trying?

even if I was a wolf I would never ever tell my partner to give up, ever. one of my biggest peeves in this game is when people self vote or otherwise give up, I think you should always try to somehow talk your way out or at least meme rather than giving up.

I'm not sure how much I buy into that theory anyway. I think it's entirely possible shadowgod just realized his position was pretty impossible and gave up on his own. I don't think he would have needed someone else to tell him he only had four minutes