ODIPack3 submissions (Release when graphics are done)

[Arntonach]

Re: ODIPack3 submissions (it's happening!)

So about them chart reviews...

[FissionMailed1]

Re: ODIPack3 submissions (it's happening!)

Pack is cancelled.

[rparty89]

Re: ODIPack3 submissions (it's happening!)

cool

[TC_Halogen]

Re: ODIPack3 submissions (it's happening!)

ugh, I really need to finish Through Her Eyes for this pack but I have like no motivation...

[Nullifidian]

Re: ODIPack3 submissions (it's happening!)

Sent in 2 files ;O
Modem - Wooly Mammoth Stomp (Nero's Day At Disneyland Remix)
Frazzbass & The Sickest Squad - Supermario (Exagon & Da Boomer's Anti-Remix)

[dascookieman]

Re: ODIPack3 submissions (it's happening!)

So about them chart reviews...

later today! have been doing shit this weekend

[dascookieman]

Re: ODIPack3 submissions (it's happening!)

if your file has not been reviewed, please resend it and let me know!!


asdfmovie6 (revision)
accepted, it's a really fun file. i have some minor suggestions, sent you a mail, but the file will be included no matter what you choose to do.


brave warrior
it's a bit too simple and repetetive, the minijacks parts are awesome and is obviously what really defines the file, but the beginning and when it repeats again is just pretty boring and uneventful, seemed fairly accurately stepped (except for randomly dropping layers when imo you would not need to at times) but it just got too long and uneventful. also i don't think the minijacks-patterns should've been copy-pasted. if the file is gonna make it you have to figure out a way to make the non-minijack-parts more diverse and interesting while still doing proper layering.


bright sound (dry lagoon) (revision)
meh i can't accept this it's just too easy . i like it cuz the pack doesn't have much of swing like this, but something else just needed to happen, it's soo easy all the way through and the standard for the pack is so high now, there are quite a few fairly easy files already, but this would become the easiest of them all. it would just have needed to have one more a bit more unique and memorable part and i would still have accepted it thought. not completly impossible that i could accept this after revision but it's not likely, would have to become harder without being an over-layered dump.


destination relapse (revision)
edit was empty for me this review is just based on playing heavy. i think it's too simple and easy, and only relies on mines to make you mess up the score. it's just simple 16ths rhythms without a single part that really presents you with anything different. there are already a few files with mostly easy 16ths in the pack, this file is not really on par and i can't have that many files like that either.


die winnipeg
hooly shit lol hard. it's really fun, challenging in a fun way. but it's pretty long and towards the end it just gets soooo much jumpstream, i feel like it's just slightly too much. i think you should remake 1 or 2 of the jumpstream sections to be different, and restructure some of the other streams you're keeping too (layer some of them diffferently)


forgive me
didn't find it very much fun at all. mines+random pattern streams after a boring beginning :P


dishevel (revision)
accepted. so awesome file. there's a lot of idm:ish music in the pack now but the files are soo good


in the name of god
it's really awesome, very similar to how i would've made, i thought about stepping this a few times. but the first long guitar tapping solo is completly wrong o_O, it's a lot more notes.

measure 16-32 i think it's inconsistent with what sounds are represented as a minifreeze, there are a lot of them
measure 54 missing drum note(s)
measure 57 missing drum note
measure 33-53 this part is not accurate

lawn wake II (revision)
the harder chart is really awesome now but the easier one needs to be a bit easier with few hands and just some parts toned down in general, also please rearrange it yourself so that the harder chart is oni and easier heavy! will be accepted


laste testamente of twelfth mother
it's pretty awesome. soo much fun, nice consistently challenging, greeat file for scoring. had a few very different and cool sections, didn't get repetetive. accepted


supermario
it completly lacks flow. it's just all those hands and jumps all the time and it never gives you any flow when playing it, it's not that hard either and at the same time not challenging in a fun way with just all the hands and jumps. it also has a few bursts that are cool but they are so much harder than everything else, it makes it inconsistently difficult too. didn't like this one very much, expected a really hard file with lots of different crazy sections


waltz no 17 in g minor (revision)
accepted


wooly mammoth stomp
it's a fun file but it's very similar throughout, i think you should try to make something a bit different and i can see myself accepting this.


(i wanna give you) devotion
really fucking cool file it seemed pretty much perfectly made, except for there were quite a few mines that i didn't think was creating any cool tricks and just were there to mess up your score and the replay-value. i think you should take out many of them and make many of those you keep single mines.


also added baqs insect digestion melancholy that we revised to the accepted list


someone make a challenging swing file please! the pack needs one

[moches]

Re: ODIPack3 submissions (it's happening!)

bright sound (dry lagoon) (revision)
meh i can't accept this it's just too easy . i like it cuz the pack doesn't have much of swing like this, but something else just needed to happen, it's soo easy all the way through and the standard for the pack is so high now, there are quite a few fairly easy files already, but this would become the easiest of them all. it would just have needed to have one more a bit more unique and memorable part and i would still have accepted it thought. not completly impossible that i could accept this after revision but it's not likely, would have to become harder without being an over-layered dump.


destination relapse (revision)
edit was empty for me this review is just based on playing heavy. i think it's too simple and easy, and only relies on mines to make you mess up the score. it's just simple 16ths rhythms without a single part that really presents you with anything different. there are already a few files with mostly easy 16ths in the pack, this file is not really on par and i can't have that many files like that either.

nah, no worries. a little bummed that Bright Sound's not hard enough, but that goes with ODI territory I suppose. I still have one more submission for this that will hopefully turn out well.

how many files are we at now, though? like 40+?

[EzExZeRo7497]

Re: ODIPack3 submissions (it's happening!)

Ji stepped Dishevel?

holy fjoeqajdoaiwojaolidjodedojiaswoqdjoqaswidjoqawidjmoqaiswdrjoqawidrjoqaiwdrjoqawjdrqwidrmjqwolicmnjolaswq

[baq12]

Re: ODIPack3 submissions (it's happening!)

Sent fixes to both in the name of god and lawn wake II

[dascookieman]

Re: ODIPack3 submissions (it's happening!)

how many files are we at now, though? like 40+?

40 yeah! looking forward to your next file =)

Ji stepped Dishevel?

holy fjoeqajdoaiwojaolidjodedojiaswoqdjoqaswidjoqawidjmoqaiswdrjoqawidrjoqaiwdrjoqawjdrqwidrmjqwolicmnjolaswq

hehe yeah it's real good

Sent fixes to both in the name of god and lawn wake II

will play them later, i think they will pretty much be auto-accept

[Nullifidian]

Re: ODIPack3 submissions (it's happening!)

supermario
it completly lacks flow. it's just all those hands and jumps all the time and it never gives you any flow when playing it, it's not that hard either and at the same time not challenging in a fun way with just all the hands and jumps. it also has a few bursts that are cool but they are so much harder than everything else, it makes it inconsistently difficult too. didn't like this one very much, expected a really hard file with lots of different crazy sections

I think you and I have a different idea of flow lol. It seems to flow fine for me, for as far as twitchy jumpy gabber goes. Even the bursts are easy to FC and even PA while still maintaining a bit of a challenge to PA it well throughout, but it's your decision

wooly mammoth stomp
it's a fun file but it's very similar throughout, i think you should try to make something a bit different and i can see myself accepting this.

I'm not entirely sure what you mean by this. Like, what would your suggestion be to change? I thought it was pretty distinctly structured for a 2 minute song:
1st section: easy buildup with some 16ths
2nd section: longjacks start coming in
3rd section: longjacks with layering to the kicks etc
4th section: flowing jumpstream to give the player a break
5th section: climactic part with some more jumpstream and some jacks
6th section: broken up and distorted longjacks (few of them) with some jumpstreams
7th section: da end

[dascookieman]

Re: ODIPack3 submissions (it's happening!)

wooly mammoth isn't bad at all, challenging in a fun way for sure but it's a lot of those similar jack sections that look very much alike. i thought it should be possible to make it bit more varied with for example doing something else than those green jacks since it seemed to be a pretty cool sound there, and mixing up the patterns a bit more. i think there were a few color note bursts missed too. but it has some parts that are different and it's a cool file overall i like it and would most likely accept it after a revision

[stargroup100]

Re: ODIPack3 submissions (it's happening!)

Nth Degree (JX & Don)

is this what I think it is

[AlexDest]

Re: ODIPack3 submissions (it's happening!)

Nth Degree (JX & Don)

is this what I think it is

yes it is

stephen kay