FFR Community Pack Winter 2011 (Submissions Open)

[XxMidigamixX]

Re: FFR Community Pack Winter 2011 (Submissions Open)

i'm withdrawing cygnus and sending something else tonight (almost done with ez chart and gfx are already done)

rip mars volta :<

[NeoMasterPie]

Re: FFR Community Pack Winter 2011 (Submissions Open)

i will probably still release it just not in this pack since it's kinda boring to do an easy chart for that song

[XxMidigamixX]

Re: FFR Community Pack Winter 2011 (Submissions Open)

sweet. I can finally enjoy a Mars Volta file in SM \o/

[Gundam-Dude]

Re: FFR Community Pack Winter 2011 (Submissions Open)

reviews possibly tonight

[XxMidigamixX]

Re: FFR Community Pack Winter 2011 (Submissions Open)

reviews possibly tonight

sweet \o/

[Profraine]

Re: FFR Community Pack Winter 2011 (Submissions Open)

Please don't forget my simfile. Please.

[XxMidigamixX]

Re: FFR Community Pack Winter 2011 (Submissions Open)

Please don't forget my simfile. Please.

pfft, that's nonsense xP

[leonid]

Re: FFR Community Pack Winter 2011 (Submissions Open)

Sent another KOOL file

[hi19hi19]

Re: FFR Community Pack Winter 2011 (Submissions Open)

asdfjkl; I keep meaning to send fixes but I always get busy because I'm on vacation.

If I don't get around to sending my fixes just move all the charts in Rave7 up one difficulty, with Oni -> Edit

But I really want to send in my fixes, just not finished yet >_<

[XxMidigamixX]

Re: FFR Community Pack Winter 2011 (Submissions Open)

Let's see if I can pull off a 2/2 here <3

@hi19: hurry up and send your fixes I'm dying to play Rave7 <3

[leonid]

Re: FFR Community Pack Winter 2011 (Submissions Open)

Sent the pack boss file (o:

[TheNoSoMan]

Re: FFR Community Pack Winter 2011 (Submissions Open)

i hope this pack doesnt close too quickly

[Gundam-Dude]

Re: FFR Community Pack Winter 2011 (Submissions Open)

Pair of Aces V2(Midigami)
Standard
- You forgot to shorten the holds for this. Do this and this'll be acceptable.
- Hand usage is debatable but you can keep them in if you wish.
Maybe

Heavy
- Better with shorter holds. As a result though, you have a lot of empty gaps which gives you more layering opportunity. I'd suggest layering jumps to every 4th note to go with the bass. It'd keep your layering super consistent and fill in all those gaps which will also improve file flow.
- All the 4th notes as bass jumps and this'll be good. I'm only being picky about this because this is a very short and quick file.
Maybe


Super Bass (WTFBrandon)
Don't care if this doesn't have an easier chart. You're ****in Brandon and we haven't see a file from you since like 2009.
YES


SIN (Nohara & Yume)
- Plays out very similarly to Puppet's file in DCP but has some neat gimmicks on its own.
- Could use an easier chart considering how difficult this is.
Pending


Flames Within These Black Feathers (Szalu)
Offset was early by 0.04. Global offset probably.

Heavy
Acceptable
Yes

Challenge
- Jacks are questionable but I'll let it slide since it adds a nice scoring factor and makes it interesting.
- Sync might be slightly off because of the stops but it's not by much.
- Layering is straightforward and neat. No real commentary.
- JAPAN SONG CHOICE ALERT. I'll let this slide since file's good.
Yes


Innovation (Detrimentalist)
Standard
- Could be simplified further but this is acceptable.
Yes

Heavy
YES


SAMBA de ASPEL (bmah)
Standard
- You know what you're doing.
Yes

Heavy
- No real commentary. Layering's great and file's fun.
Yes


Negus Nagast (Wineandbread)
Light
Acceptable
Yes

Edit
- This is so swag. eXPReSSiVe and very danger mines.
Yes


Sjalv (Szalu)
Heavy
- 48th stream, uhhh yeah. This isn't the right pack to send this to. Save this for a hard or dump pack, lmao.
No

Challenge
- 48th trills, uhhh yeah. This isn't the right pack to send this to. Save this for a hard or dump pack, lmao.
No


worldenddominator (Profraine)
Heavy
- Acceptable but the gap between this and Challenge is ****ing out of this world.

Challenge
- The 24ths in the beginning feel way too overemphasized especially when what they're supposed to represent is very subtle in the song itself. I personally wouldn't even bother layering them in, especially when you're starting off a file.
- I would trim all the holds shorter in length by as much as an 8th note or so long. Avoids awkward holdstreaming patterns like what you've got when you start throwing in 16th jacks and polyrhythms, and it opens up your patterning/layering opportunity. Holds don't need to be as long as the sound they go to, as long as it's there regardless of length, players can distinguish what they go to in a single playthrough.
- The minijack section after M42+ was a neat concept. However everything after M50+ the file goes to hell, lmao. It's climactic, I get it. Was it necessary to make the entire ending super awkward jackstream, lmao.
- No offense and all, file was very... korean/japanese style file influenced. In other words, focused on difficulty factor e.g. jackstreamz. Although I don't have anything against that, I can't find this file to be suitable for this pack in particular. Save this for something else.
No


Byakuya Gentou (leonid)
Standard
- Acceptable
Yes

Heavy
- Hard pain swing.
- I'd shorten the length of the holds more personally. Other than that, file's great and difficulty
Yes


BabeL ~Next Story~ (leonid)
Heavy
- Acceptable
Yes

Challenge
- LEONID HARD PAIN STEP
Yes


File queue is at 35 files. Also a new GFX list is up and posted in the first post

[Wineandbread]

Re: FFR Community Pack Winter 2011 (Submissions Open)

woop file got in

For the record Edit should be Heavy, I forgot to change that

I am adding standard though so I will fix it

[XxMidigamixX]

Re: FFR Community Pack Winter 2011 (Submissions Open)

Alright will fix up the holds on standard and the jumps on Heavy in a moment~~~

Sending it~