Stepartist Report Cards

[moches]

Re: Stepartist Report Cards

aperson- B+
played Tranzport, enough said

but that's as high as aperson goes for me sorry

[Patashu]

Re: Stepartist Report Cards

what about growth grass. no one ever plays that any more sadface

[Mollocephalus]

Re: Stepartist Report Cards

growth grass honestly is one of those things you can either love or hate. i really like how the chart is structured, but the song i don't like at all. maybe i just haven't played kirby when i was little.

[Rin-Dude]

Re: Stepartist Report Cards

aperson didnt make enough spread files. his index files are outdated nowadays and only have replay value if there's nostalgia value present.

[Mollocephalus]

Re: Stepartist Report Cards

ap's index files were as creative as they could get... for index style. macgravel brought that to a new level, but a lot of time has passed since then.

[fysx]

Re: Stepartist Report Cards

aperson's files are horribly overrated, particularly his more recent "serious stepman" stuff.

Kil outstrips him by far when it comes to singles, and his solo stuff was obnoxious.

[Mollocephalus]

Re: Stepartist Report Cards

as much as some of them could be overrated, i don't think you can compare with files like peaches en regalia, especially considering the moment in which they were made.

kil's older files are (were) underrated tho, so it kinda balances that.

[moches]

Re: Stepartist Report Cards

that explains why those files mean a lot more to you than to me since I wasn't around in those eras. once again, experience plays out. gotta remember that dude

I'm actually quite interested in hearing the reviews of some of the more prolific people around here.

[stargroup]

Re: Stepartist Report Cards

moches you gave me the same grade as rebirth

kill yaself

edit: also anyone who does not give kil and amy an instant A+ are retarded because they are a bajillion times better than any of us will EVER BE

[moches]

Re: Stepartist Report Cards

:noose:
:neck:
:choke choke choo--:

to be fair his grade is kind of biased for me since his files were what originally got me into Stepmania (Musou Uta is baller as hell). for you, it's more like even though you definitely left a mark on Stepmania and that's great, I don't think I've ever played one of your files a lot. they're more like "oh that's cool" than "I'd replay this for sure". the exception to this is Bullet Timing.

I bumped you to a B- and moved Rebirth down a notch if it makes you feel any better (or in this case, remorse for my suicide).

[fysx]

Re: Stepartist Report Cards

as much as some of them could be overrated, i don't think you can compare with files like peaches en regalia, especially considering the moment in which they were made.

kil's older files are (were) underrated tho, so it kinda balances that.

kil's older files still annihilated ap's older stuff

vundabar and tranzport, while interesting, arent nearly as fun

[Mollocephalus]

Re: Stepartist Report Cards

grades are supposed to be objective (to an extent) but it's rather funny that you edit them in regard to people's reactions lol

[moches]

Re: Stepartist Report Cards

the only ones I really changed were the ones I had missed (because they weren't balanced with the ones on page one) and stargroup's/Rebirth's.

I dunno actually, my taste in files changes almost daily. like, I used to HATE Kn33grow's files, then I played them again and loved them, then liked them, then hated them again, then didn't play them for a long time and now I think they're just okay. so it's fine if my grades aren't totally concrete.

right now they match my feelings exactly so I'm not going to touch them until tomorrow morning when I suddenly realize the profoundity of Almsty's Sealed Time and hate Patashu's files.

edit: and uh Necros you never answered my question

what files would you recommend I play out of ap's, Reach's, and Nemosta's? those were the three least played to me out of that list. if I played some more of theirs, my opinion might change, but probably not by much. I have weird taste in files anyway.

[Mollocephalus]

Re: Stepartist Report Cards

aperson:

turtle turtle up
peaches en regalia
vunderbar
manchurian candy

reach:

neoclassical shredfest 2
superluminal
disabled the flaw
felys v2

Nemosta:

what do they know
i hate jimmy page
scream squad

[stargroup]

Re: Stepartist Report Cards

I'm not your teacher anymore

you can bet your ass that I'm never reviewing one of your files again