Stepmania Nostalgia Pack (Submissions REOPEN)

Re: Stepmania Nostalgia Pack (Submissions REOPEN)

These were all of my reviews before submissions went down. This page will NOT be updated. I will just post what I judge just so people do not have to come back to this same post every time I judge new files which can get very annoying.

Broadbaned (8M Remix) [Kommisar] (Accept)
Haha, this file was pretty fun and replayable. This definitely is bring back that old school feel to files which is what we are looking for! [B]

Ememy Storm [Hawke] (Accept)
Heavy - Oh man, this chart was just hella fun and HIGHLY replayable.
Oni - WOW, this chart was like the PERFECT difficultly gap for heavy.

FFReedom [MarioNintendo] (Maybe)
This file was more on the repetitive side due to the dragging on of the song but it was still fun to some extent. Holds felt a bit abused as well and the song itself had a low volume so it gave it that ~feel~ that it was more boring than it really is.

Less Than Three [Kommisar] (Accept)
Less-than-three! You love me! Typing out my random thoughts! Meet me here on this thread! L-O-L-O-L!

Less Than Three [plopadop] (Accept)
This chart was pretty good as well. I think it would be a great idea if this chart was the heavy version of Kommisar's version.

Macau Underground [Kommisar] (Accept)
Oh shi, bringing back that DJ Sharpnel back is dis bitch. Fuccen amazing chart btw.

MASTER MAID [Kommisar] (Accept)
Again, bring back that DJ Sharpnel into this pack is awesome. This looks similar to the FFR version but longer. Still thought it was fun as an old school file. That slightly repetitive feel brought be back to 2005 hehu.

Papaver Rhoeas [Kommisar] (Accept)
And yet ANOTHER DJ sharpnel file lmao. Still found it really fun and replayable though hehe.

Reunion [Hawke] (Accept)
Wow, another old school ~feel~ JS file. Definitely something i would want to play again.

Super Lovely [Kommisar] (Accept)
I almost quad this! Jokes aside, another great JS file that i think a lot of people would enjoy.

Tinkerbot Boss Battle [Duplica] (Accept)
Cool stream file. Seemed a bit like a unique old school file in a way which is something we want.


These are the files I just judged today and yesterday:

(Aeterna Imari) A Thousand Miles (Speedo Mix) - This file has blue note syndrome and it was off measure but it was fun to some extent. The way you layered everything was hella confusing and it did not match the song at all. It might be the fact that the whole file is off measure. Fix that and resend again. No

(Aeterna Imari) Neckbreaker Plus System Remix - This felt like another F5 file haha. Definitely want this. Yes

(Aeterna Imari vs. TypeMARS) MAHOROBA - Before I review this, I just wanted to throw out that this felt like I was playing a file from F5 which is something I enjoyed when I first started playing stepmania. Anyway, heavy chart was fun to some extent and replayable. Oni chart was good as an oni chart. Overall, both chart are fun but not exactly indexable. Yes

(Aeterna Imari) Final Audition Episode 1 - This file was pretty fun but at the same time straight forward. Definitely felt old school material in my eyes hehe. Also, The patterns were a bit random but that's not really a big deal in this case since you layered it right. Yes

(Aeterna Imari) Xepher - Sorry, this has been stepped a whole lot of times so I am not going to accept this sadly. No

(BeatofIke) Piano Mania VS Drum no Tatsuj - This one has new generation all over it. This is not what I'm looking for. I hate having to reject a perfectly stepped file but save that for another pack. No

(BeatofIke) Target Smash - This one was slightly on the repetitive side but it was fun and replayable to some extent. Those 12th rolls should just be 16th triples and try to layer some of those empty parts like on m23 where you just step the background noise as single notes. Do that then I will take your file. Conditional Accept

(BeatofIke) Xecus - You already stepped this for hsmp as the medium difficutly so I am not going to take this. No

(HawkE) Identity Part 3 - Holy shit this felt like one of those harder NLVM's old school dump files. I'm not sure if I'm ready to add dumps like this yet so I will keep this on hold until I decide if I want it in or not. N/A

(IcyWorld) Love Is Dreaminess - This file was also really fun on index. I can see index players replaying this file a lot because of how fun it is. Yes

(IcyWorld) HOT STUFF - Holy hell this was really fun playing on index. Definitely fun and highly replayable. Yes

(Kommisar + WTFBrandon) Ending - Every pack needs an ending amirite? Definitely something I want for the pack as well. Really fun and highly replayable. Yes

(Kommisar) Wi-Ex-Doc-Va - This one was pretty interesting but definitely something I am looking for. Pretty fun and replayable as well. Yes

(qqwref) Epileptic Crisis (Index Edition) - Despite how many people stepped this same song, this file was fun to some extent. Some of those patterns though was not index friendly at all and since you were going for an index file, I will have to say that you must fix up some of those index patterns so that it will seem more replayable, otherwise it will get rejected in the long run. Conditional Accept

(Reshiram) Snowfall - Sync got slightly off near the end but was still a good file. I got a little meh when I saw those pauses but I see what you were trying to do so good job. Yes

(Sensationer) Uzzuda - Standard: Was fun to some extent but your pattern usage got really repetitive and started to drag on a lot. That includes the other difficulties as well. Heavy/Oni: These felt like one of those repetitive dump files that no one would play just because of how much it drags on. I hate to do this to you but I will have to reject this. No

(TNSM) Background Theme II - Wow, this file definitely brought me back to 2006 again. Pretty fun and highly replayable. Yes

(Xayphon) Form the Alliance - This one was pretty challenging but still really fun as well. Probably will be one of the harder files for this pack which never hurts. Yes

(Xx{Midnight}xX) S.Y.S.T.E.M - This file was already stepped as an old school file so we do not need another one. No

Re: Stepmania Nostalgia Pack (Submissions REOPEN)

I'm a dolphin I love you

Re: Stepmania Nostalgia Pack (Submissions REOPEN)

I'm surprised Emerald Sword isn't in there... it's like one of the most abused simfiles in history.

Re: Stepmania Nostalgia Pack (Submissions REOPEN)

Oh, I should add that in the OP haha

PS: Does anyone know who Sensationer is on FFR or any other places? If so, can someone tell him to resubmit the following files?

(Sensationer) I Love Rock & Roll
(Sensationer) Only My Railgun [Eurobeatchargemix]
(Sensationer) Dash

Would be appreciated :3

Re: Stepmania Nostalgia Pack (Submissions REOPEN)

Oh wow, once I return home I'll step some old beatmania songs for this

Re: Stepmania Nostalgia Pack (Submissions REOPEN)

wtf mang you disappear from AIM mang didn' no u was gunna do dis shit mang

came back from watching Scarface. sure if I get a good nostalgic song to step, then I'll send one or two files in for this

Re: Stepmania Nostalgia Pack (Submissions REOPEN)

Sweet! The more submissions, the better :3

Re: Stepmania Nostalgia Pack (Submissions REOPEN)

btw, what ever happened to your dump pack II?

Re: Stepmania Nostalgia Pack (Submissions REOPEN)

Yay, the pack is back. Going to submit a few.

Re: Stepmania Nostalgia Pack (Submissions REOPEN)

files accepted, stepped by me?!!! *super happy*

Re: Stepmania Nostalgia Pack (Submissions REOPEN)

Rebound Dump Collection Pack II was supposed to come out sometime in June but then staiain and Hawke released the Mina Mini Pack 2 which ruined literally my WHOLE plan with my dump pack so at the moment, the pack is on HOLD until I figure out a new plan for it. If not then I will probably never finish the pack. It was not their fault though because they never even knew about it nor did I ever knew that they were going to release that pack.

Re: Stepmania Nostalgia Pack (Submissions REOPEN)

If it ever releases...



enjoy

Re: Stepmania Nostalgia Pack (Submissions REOPEN)

I expected this to happen sadly. To tell you the truth, I lost the knowlege in stepping old school files, due to years of simfile elitism (I'm currently learning to step expressively). The only thing I remember about stepping old school files are index charts and pad charts, but I stopped stepping those kind of simfiles since 2009). I should take a look at my old files to regain my knowledge for this, before submitting any more files in this pack. Also, I seem to have a habit in stepping repetive songs/files (which destroys fun factor), which I have to stop doing. Besides that, thanks for the review.

Re: Stepmania Nostalgia Pack (Submissions REOPEN)

ike sCK files