Rate/Rank All Of Your Packs

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • moches
    FFR Player
    • Aug 2005
    • 3996

    #1

    Rate/Rank All Of Your Packs

    On a scale of 10.

    SMGroovePack3- 10/10 Unfriggin' believable. How amazing.
    FFRCPII- 9.5/10 I really can't say how mindblowing this pack was. Out of twenty files, nineteen of them were amazing and warranted replay value. That's 19:1, the highest hit-to-miss rate any pack to date has had so far. Wow. Just wow. This might mellow over time, but I loved this pack at first sight.
    RFpack- 9/10 I actually really like this pack too. A lot of great files, some good, and a couple of bad ones, but that doesn't happen that much. Still, this just goes to prove that the best packs are usually the ones nobody sees coming.
    ODIpack2- 8/10 I guess this one goes here by default. It's not a perfect pack by any means, but everything about this was well done and I always find a file that I love which I had previously thought was just okay.
    DCP- 7.25/10 This one gets a +0.25 just for the massive effort that everybody put into it, but unfortunately, you can try too hard. In this case, they tried too hard. There were so many files it was hard to find standouts. Good pack, I guess, but it could have been trimmed down a bit and been just as enjoyable. Oh, and the graphics for this pack RULED.
    VGMP3- 7/10 Decent pack, I suppose, though nobody saw it coming. There weren't that many great files, but there weren't that many I hated either, which is always something, I guess.
    DCP Mystery Pack- 7/10 If DCP had been one-fourth of the size and the cdtitles had been scrambled, this would have been it.
    FFRCPI- 6.5/10 I actually still play this pack once in a while, and it's passable, but would have been better if there was some better quality control and npv/Kommi didn't have a combined 18 files in here. Out of 32. I think it was a nice start, however, and I was 13 when I launched this, technically making me the youngest guy who ever worked on a pack. Not that that matters or anything.
    Xoon2- 6/10- Surprisingly, this pack wasn't half-bad. Lots of fun files, some okay, some bad. All in all about average.
    Kirby Pack 2- 6/10 Kirby. What can I say? Pretty fun files, too, though some were sort of obnoxious.
    Xoon Mini 1- 6/10 Decent pack. About what I would expect.
    SMGPack2- 5.5/10 This was probably where Stepmania revolution broke out all the way after hints of it began in SMGPack1. This wasn't good, but I don't blame them, since they were getting on their feet, and by RFpack-era, they had notably figured out how to use this new method of stepping. Anyway, most of these songs were forgettable, but there were a few gems, so there you go. The end.
    VGMP2- 5/10 Mostly annoyingish files with a couple of good ones. The end.
    KBU- 4.5/10 KBU was an interesting pack because a lot of the people that submitted to it (hell, I'd stretch it to almost all) were unknowns at the time (other than a couple of people). Still, this pack was decent for what it was, and a lot of the people that were involved in it have gone on to bigger and better things. And I still play some of these files sometimes. ~Zero~ made a badass Chaos file. And SulferDragon rules. Too bad he left.
    Keyboard MegaPack 1.5- 4.5/10 Like SMG2, but this was a little worse and a little better at the same time. I don't know how that's possible. Shut up.
    SMGpack1- 4.5/10 A lot of these files didn't need to be in here. But Ossa's files (Tell Me A Story is like the best thing ever) and Rebirth's better stuff (along with a couple of other okay files) save it from being a bomb.
    Keyboard Collab III- 3/10 Oh, man. I know this was a long time ago, but I still have this pack. Some files are good, others totally 16th streamzzzzz. Not a bad pack for the times, but just outdated, I suppose. Oh, and boomba's Moon Child rules. Stop stepping it. I think boomba might be the coolest ancient stepdude ever.
    In The Groove 2- 0/10 Why the hell do I have this pack lmao ps I stepped D-Code for Xoon Mini Pack 1
    Last edited by moches; 04-25-2009, 01:43 AM.
  • moches
    FFR Player
    • Aug 2005
    • 3996

    #2
    Re: Rate/Rank All Of Your Packs

    ps hi ~Zero~

    I seeeeeeeee you

    Comment

    • Glitz
      FFR Player
      • Sep 2003
      • 59

      #3
      Re: Rate/Rank All Of Your Packs

      10/10 SaGa pack
      9.5/10 Kenichiro Fukui Megapack
      -9999/1000 All other packs

      Comment

      • ~Zero~
        FFR Veteran
        FFR Simfile Author
        • Nov 2006
        • 1556

        #4
        Re: Rate/Rank All Of Your Packs

        Originally posted by moches
        ps hi ~Zero~

        I seeeeeeeee you
        I got caught, oh noes. Hi Moches


        Originally posted by Xiaounlimited
        More like Tier ~0~

        Comment

        • kommisar[os]
          Banned
          • Apr 2006
          • 4097

          #5
          Re: Rate/Rank All Of Your Packs

          based on personal preference and how many times i've actually played the packs...


          vgmp1: 8/10

          vgmp2: 7/10

          vgmp3: 6/10

          smg1: 8/10

          smg2: 6/10

          smg3: 10/10 fuc ye

          ODI: 9/10

          ODI2: 8/10

          rf: 7/10

          dcp: 6.5/10

          mystery: 7/10

          xoon1: 5/10

          xoon2: 6/10

          xoon mini: 9/10

          ffrcp1: 5/10

          ffrcp2: 9/10


          those are the only packs i havent deleted

          Comment

          • moches
            FFR Player
            • Aug 2005
            • 3996

            #6
            Re: Rate/Rank All Of Your Packs

            Xoon Mini 1- 6/10 Decent pack. About what I would expect.

            Comment

            • gnr61
              FFR Simfile Author
              FFR Simfile Author
              • Oct 2005
              • 7251

              #7
              Re: Rate/Rank All Of Your Packs

              DCP Mystery Pack
              ODI II
              DCP
              FFRCP II
              ODI I
              VGMP III
              those other packs
              squirrel--it's whats for dinner.

              Comment

              • jimerax
                FFR Simfile Author
                FFR Music Producer
                • Nov 2003
                • 8185

                #8
                Re: Rate/Rank All Of Your Packs

                RF - 7/10 - has couple of good files, some are bad
                DCP - 7/10 - pack should have been shrinked
                ODI2 - 8/10 - good overall quality, released files aren't needed
                SMG2 - 5/10 - decent, some files feel old/gay in current standard
                FFR - 6/10 - remarkable files, but overall ok
                KBU - 4/10 - uh idk
                KBMP1.5 - 3/10 - pretty disappointed in my old memory
                VGMP3 - 6/10 - most files are enjoyable, don't have strong impression though

                don't remember/haven't played others.

                Comment

                • omgitznpv
                  cohoooooon
                  FFR Simfile Author
                  • Aug 2005
                  • 6980

                  #9
                  Re: Rate/Rank All Of Your Packs

                  odi 2 - 9/10
                  dcp - 7/10
                  smg2 - 6/10
                  rf - 6/10
                  ppp1 & 2 if they count - 5/10

                  i don't really care about any of the others
                  Originally posted by DossarLX ODI
                  What's the point of using drugs anyways? I heard they help you relax but that's pretty much it. (Not talking about medicines)

                  Comment

                  • trumaestro
                    I don't get no respect
                    FFR Simfile Author
                    • Jun 2006
                    • 1332

                    #10
                    Re: Rate/Rank All Of Your Packs

                    CKBMPs, F4, F5, KBCs, KBMPs - lol i have these packs
                    DCP - amazing **** mixed in with not so amazing ****. should've been smaller/taken less time to make
                    FFRCP - the first pack i had a file in, i'm kinda indifferent about it now
                    Kirby 2 - cool **** son. has 2 of my own favourites.
                    ODI2 - i hate =======planet KARMA========== sry f is best file tehe
                    ODI - pretty good i suppose.
                    PPPs - blah
                    RF - pretty good pack, most files i played more than twice compared to most other packs.
                    SMGs - blah
                    VGMP3 - too technical for its own good imo. plus i was about to step meta knight's revenge but then this pack came out, and, being a stickler for original song choice (usually), i dropped the idea until kirby 2 was announced and i decided to step an original version instead
                    Xoons - kinda dumpy, some ok files hidden among the dumps though.

                    haven't played anything new yet, so yeah.

                    Comment

                    • SulferDragon
                      this is a waste of space
                      FFR Simfile Author
                      • Jan 2007
                      • 2668

                      #11
                      Re: Rate/Rank All Of Your Packs

                      Uh, gee, I deleted all my packs a while back, but I think I can remember pretty well all the packs I had.

                      [WARNING] Too many packs ahead.

                      SMG - 7/10 - Some of the files in here are honestly complete crap, but it also has some of my favorite files ever.

                      SMG2 - 10/10 - Pretty much the best pack ever, in my opinion.

                      CRP - 7/10 - Mainly for Shadowgod's files. I really love them. Brave Warrior, Hell yeah!

                      ODI - 8.5/10 - Pretty great. What else is there to say?

                      ODI2 - 10/10 - Pretty much the other best pack ever, in my opinion.

                      RFP - 8.5/10 - There's actually only a few files in here that I don't ever play.

                      DCP - 6.5/10 - Kind of a mixed bag for me. There are some files I love, but some files I really hate.

                      CKMP - 8/10 - A truly timeless pack. I will always enjoy playing files from this.

                      CKMP2 - 3/10 - I think there are a few files in here I like, but overall it's pretty meh.

                      AMC - 9/10 - I never play many of the files in here except my own, but it's full of metal!

                      KP2 - 8/10 - KIIIRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRBBYYYYYYY!!!1!!1

                      PPP - 7/10 - A solid pack. That's about it for me.

                      PPP2 - 4.5/10 - There are too many files in this pack that were in other packs.

                      SKSP - 2/10 - I like the Gaussian Blur files... nothing else.

                      FFRCP - 7/10 - Okay, there were some fun files in here. Actually, several.

                      KBMP1.5 - 6.5/10 - There are some things in here I love to play, but some of the files in here simply blow because of how terrible the songs are. I'll forgive it a little because the songs were basically pre-selected.

                      KBC - 2/10 - I like Big Blue. Otherwise, there isn't much in here... at all.

                      KBC2 - 5.5/10 - I can't say that any of the files in this stand out as great to me, but there are a lot of files I enjoy to play occasionally.

                      KBC3 - 5.5/10 - See above.

                      VGMP - 8/10 - Like the CKMP, I consider this a classic. Lots of stuff I enjoy in here, no matter how old the files are.

                      VGMP2 - 6.5/10 - The bad files way it down for me, and it doesn't have that classic appeal the first pack does.

                      VGMP3 - 9/10 - The large amount of Falcom music is what really makes this pack for me.

                      KBU - 4/10 - Yeah, honestly, there's not much in here worth playing, but I play the files anyway.

                      CMDKDFP - 1/10 - Honestly, this pack does suck. There were a few files I remember kind of liking, but nothing I would ever consistently play. I just deleted the pack and kept those.


                      Comment

                      • moches
                        FFR Player
                        • Aug 2005
                        • 3996

                        #12
                        Re: Rate/Rank All Of Your Packs

                        Oh, hey, Sulfer's back! Where you been?

                        ps I'm adding Xoon Mini 1 right now, just under Xoon2.

                        Comment

                        • N.T.M.
                          FFR Player
                          • Dec 2007
                          • 890

                          #13
                          Re: Rate/Rank All Of Your Packs

                          O hai thar Sulfer!!
                          “Beware the irrational, however seductive. Shun the 'transcendent' and all who invite you to subordinate or annihilate yourself. Distrust compassion; prefer dignity for yourself and others. Don't be afraid to be thought arrogant or selfish... Suspect your own motives, and all excuses. Do not live for others any more than you would expect others to live for you.”

                          Christopher Hitchens

                          Comment

                          • SulferDragon
                            this is a waste of space
                            FFR Simfile Author
                            • Jan 2007
                            • 2668

                            #14
                            Re: Rate/Rank All Of Your Packs

                            I haven't been gone. I just haven't been posting or making simfiles.
                            Actually, I've been on a quest for StepMania enlightenment.


                            Comment

                            • i love gabba
                              FFR Player
                              • Apr 2008
                              • 531

                              #15
                              Re: Rate/Rank All Of Your Packs

                              I'm not good at ranking files and stuff but whatever:

                              FFRCP2 : 8/10 - fun files
                              Mystery Pack : 8/10 - feels... random
                              Xoon2 : 7/10 - average
                              Dark chancellors : 8/10 - some really fun files, some too technical
                              FFRCP1 : 5.5/10 - bleh
                              Xoon Mini pack 1 : 5.5/10 - I only enjoyed like 2 files
                              Kirby pack 2 : 6/10 - fun files, but thats it
                              KBU : 4/10 - no
                              I'm an Arbre Triste

                              Originally posted by Amputee/bluexoon.com
                              "who won?"
                              "Zaghurim, he won a popn music machine"

                              Comment

                              Working...