Just looking for opinions.

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #1
    FFR Player
    Angel Shiyue
    • Nov 2006
    • 90

    Just looking for opinions.

    Which actually gives you leeway to be as harsh as you want. I had about 15 minutes to write this in class during an experiment in which you picked a mood (or two) and then used setting, weather, and characters to develop it. I chose sadness and loss. It's nothing amazing, but I just wanted to see if anyone thought I did a remotely good job. Keep in mind that my writing style is a kind of 'snapshot', a glance at someone without knowing who they are which is why I rarely give names to my characters.

    21 Days

    She could hear the rain coming. The birds had stopped singing, the leaves rustled as if trying to tell her to leave the darkening forest. The last time she'd been to this place was with him before the war had begun. Now, his body was being sent home. The soft "shh" of rain filled the air, already becoming heavy with the scent of wet earth. 21 days. They had been married while he was on leave. The day after the wedding, he was shipped back to the front. In less than a month, she had a wedding and a funeral. The woods were silent, frozen in time. For a moment, she closed her eyes and tried to remember it all, when he held her close and whispered in her ear 'I'll come back'. Like a fool, she'd believed him, thinking there was no way that he could ever be killed. 21 days. He'd been so full of life, but just like this forest during the storm, all the life had dissapeared. The rainwater that slid down her face mingled with the bitter tears of a widow. The rain seemed to fall harder in that quiet moment of tears than it ever had before. With her face turned to the sky, she let a sob fall from her trembling lips. For too long, she had held back. 21 days. She'd had no use for tears. 21 days. He would have been delighted. 21 days. If he had survived that many more, he could have come home. Home to learn about his son.
  • #2
    The Worst
    FoJaR
    • Nov 2005
    • 2816

    Re: Just looking for opinions.

    cliggity cliche

    Comment

    • #3
      FFR Player
      Angel Shiyue
      • Nov 2006
      • 90

      Re: Just looking for opinions.

      I'm not concerned about the cliche aspect of it. We were required to write this in 15 minutes only. I'm more concerned over the fact of setting the mood and tone.

      Comment

      • #4
        (づ ̄ � ̄)づ watermelon
        Windscarredfaith
        • Mar 2005
        • 2612

        Re: Just looking for opinions.

        Pretty cool. Sort of easy to come up with... but given the time limit, it was well-written in my opinion. Good job.

        Comment

        • #5
          Cerebellumberjack
          FFR Simfile Author
          mead1
          • Aug 2003
          • 3960

          Re: Just looking for opinions.

          The problem is not that it is merely cliche, it is the fact that is is OVERLY AND RIDICULOUSLY CLICHE AND HAS ZERO ORIGINALITY AT ALL.

          Comment

          • #6
            FFR Player
            Grandiagod
            • Jul 2004
            • 6122

            Re: Just looking for opinions.

            You set the mood and tone, however, I've read this exact same story 1,000 times on 1,000 different fiction forums.

            To make something eyepoppingly original in 15 minutes would have been way awesomer, even if you didn't get the tone down 100%.
            He who angers you conquers you. ~Elizabeth Kenny

            Comment

            • #7
              FFR Player
              Sol_Solis
              • Aug 2005
              • 661

              Re: Just looking for opinions.

              Originally posted by Angel Shiyue
              I'm not concerned about the cliche aspect of it. We were required to write this in 15 minutes only. I'm more concerned over the fact of setting the mood and tone.
              Originally posted by Grandiagod
              You set the mood and tone
              we have a winnar!(or winrar for some ppls, lulz)
              You set the mood just fine, no need to worry. Even though, yes, it is terribly ridden with cliches as mentioned and depending on the person, that may possibly interfere with the "feel" of the story.
              Last edited by Sol_Solis; 12-16-2006, 02:07 AM.

              Comment

              • #8
                The Worst
                FoJaR
                • Nov 2005
                • 2816

                Re: Just looking for opinions.

                it's so cliche i actually started to laugh...

                i'd say that interferes with the tone

                Comment

                Working...