Why religion isn't under the same amount of scrutiny?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #16
    Very Grave Indeed
    Community Manager
    Event Staff
    FFR Simfile Author
    devonin
    • Apr 2004
    • 10142

    Re: Why religion isn't under the same amount of scrutiny?

    the answer god did it has no meaning in itself
    Only to a non-religious person, and that is the distinction you keep insisting on ignoring.

    Comment

    • #17
      FFR Player
      chopperdudes
      • Apr 2007
      • 220

      Re: Why religion isn't under the same amount of scrutiny?

      Originally posted by devonin
      Only to a non-religious person, and that is the distinction you keep insisting on ignoring.
      i'm not making a distinction between religious and non-religious, i'm just saying it has no factual meaning or useful for any kind of prediction or answering any question.

      differentiate "god did it" with "it's magic"?

      and i'm not talking bout moral values here, as that is a totally differnet debate.

      Comment

      • #18
        Very Grave Indeed
        Community Manager
        Event Staff
        FFR Simfile Author
        devonin
        • Apr 2004
        • 10142

        Re: Why religion isn't under the same amount of scrutiny?

        differentiate "god did it" with "it's magic"?
        They believe God exists, they don't believe in magic. God to them is a specific construct with specific qualities in which they have invested a great deal of personal faith and belief. Magic is a random term that covers absoluetly everything that an individual person happens to not understand.

        i'm just saying it has no factual meaning or useful for any kind of prediction or answering any question.
        You're defining 'factual' as meaning 'provable by experimentation and observation' Given that definition, no right-thinking religious person would ever say their belief was factual, so I'm not seeing why this causes such a problem for you.

        Let me reiterate: You are holding something to a standard it has never claimed to meet, and then denigrating that something for its failure to meet a standard that, again, it has never claimed to meet.

        Taking the opinion statement of fanatics or fundamentalists as being indicative of the whole group is an incredible generalization. If you asked most religious people to prove their belief they would say "I (Note the use of I in that statement) don't need proof."

        You clearly do need proof, and that is clearly why you are not a religious person. If you were religious and true to your beliefs, you would simply believe them. That's all there is to it.

        "For people who like that sort of thing, this is the sort of thing those people will like"

        Comment

        • #19
          FFR Veteran
          iceefudgesickle
          • Aug 2008
          • 481

          Re: Why religion isn't under the same amount of scrutiny?

          When one openly attacks a religion, they're thought of as rude? You joking? People BLATANTLY DESPISE religion, specifically Christianity, in this country, and religion is under copius amounts of scrutiny.

          Comment

          • #20
            Admiral in the Red Army
            Afrobean
            • Dec 2003
            • 13262

            Re: Why religion isn't under the same amount of scrutiny?

            quick question about faith in regards to debate:

            If I were trying to tell people that guns should be allowed in schools, could I tell them that I had faith that nothing bad would happen? Because I do. I have faith that if teachers were allowed to have guns in school, that them having them would not cause any trouble. I am an atheist, but I have faith in that ideal. With my faith, that means I'm "right" and since it's "faith", it can't be questioned, right?

            ...

            In OTHER WORDS, faith cannot possibly be admissible in intelligent discussion because it's fundamentally broken. You can believe whatever you like, but you can't use your unfounded beliefs to support (or even to denounce) arguments in a discussion. If unfounded beliefs were admissible in debates, it'd be a volley with people throwing ridiculous **** back and fourth with no regard to logic, deduction, or, to be frank, intelligence.

            This is why we have the rule of no religion discussion here. What happened? Why are these things allowed now?

            Comment

            • #21
              FFR Player
              Magewout
              • Apr 2007
              • 306

              Re: Why religion isn't under the same amount of scrutiny?

              I see the faith argument as a weak excuse to escape all criticism and nothing more.
              Best AAA: Diamond Heart (FFR edit)
              Best sightread AAA: Ninjitsu (I know, I suck )


              Originally posted by MrRubix
              EDIT: Wow Magewout just slayed my riddles

              Comment

              • #22
                FFR Player
                Tired_Old_Man
                • Jan 2008
                • 259

                Re: Why religion isn't under the same amount of scrutiny?

                Originally posted by iceefudgesickle
                People BLATANTLY DESPISE religion, specifically Christianity, in this country, and religion is under copius amounts of scrutiny.
                There's an awful lot of Christians just on ffr for you to say that. In this new age of reason Christianity is still going strong, weak people need hope, who doesn't need some hope? Christianity is what's wrong with America, it's the reason Mcain and his female Bush will be elected and we'll go into recession.

                Originally posted by Afrobean
                If I were trying to tell people that guns should be allowed in schools, could I tell them that I had faith that nothing bad would happen?
                I have faith that dinosaurs never existed. Faith is how you get around blatant flaws.
                Last edited by Tired_Old_Man; 09-30-2008, 09:14 AM. Reason: boobs
                "man is a pupil, pain is his teacher" - Alfred de Musset

                Comment

                • #23
                  Very Grave Indeed
                  Community Manager
                  Event Staff
                  FFR Simfile Author
                  devonin
                  • Apr 2004
                  • 10142

                  Re: Why religion isn't under the same amount of scrutiny?

                  This is why we have the rule of no religion discussion here. What happened? Why are these things allowed now?
                  This is a debate about the concept of religious debate, not a religious debate. That's why it's been allowed.

                  Comment

                  • #24
                    Admiral in the Red Army
                    Afrobean
                    • Dec 2003
                    • 13262

                    Re: Why religion isn't under the same amount of scrutiny?

                    Originally posted by devonin
                    This is a debate about the concept of religious debate, not a religious debate. That's why it's been allowed.


                    You deleted my post, didn't you

                    But really, there is no debate to the concept of it. It's simple. You can't debate it because it's beliefs rather than fact. You can't debate with religion on the grounds that it is unprovable by its own nature.

                    Not only that, but due to the nature of serious debate, unfounded beliefs aren't admissible on the grounds that they are not empirical. You could mention beliefs and such, but they cannot be used as support or as a means to denounce the opposition. If I have a belief that the death penalty is wrong, I can't walk into a debate and say "my beliefs say this is wrong" and walk out the winner of the argument.

                    Comment

                    • #25
                      FFR Player
                      lord_carbo
                      • Dec 2004
                      • 6222

                      Re: Why religion isn't under the same amount of scrutiny?

                      Afro, the thread is not about whether religion is true or not, but whether religion is scrutinized as much as it should be, and how it should be scrutinized. I'm not sure what you don't understand about that.
                      last.fm

                      Comment

                      • #26
                        Admiral in the Red Army
                        Afrobean
                        • Dec 2003
                        • 13262

                        Re: Why religion isn't under the same amount of scrutiny?

                        Originally posted by lord_carbo
                        Afro, the thread is not about whether religion is true or not, but whether religion is scrutinized as much as it should be, and how it should be scrutinized. I'm not sure what you don't understand about that.
                        It's not a debatable topic. You cannot say "prove it" to someone talking about religion.

                        That's the problem. You can't scientifically test religion, because if you try, your returned result is that it's not scientifically true. But a person's faith can be contrary to empirically proven truth, and as far as this topic is concerned, that's where it lies.

                        Thus, this scrutiny that some would suggest is tandamount to frankly stating "gods don't exist and all religions are wrong and/or lies." I personally am in favor of people taking that stance on the subject, but as far as this forum is concerned, I know it can't work. Too many people have their beliefs and they are at odds with the function of this forum. Thus, the best solution is to simply avoid such discussion, not to put a big sticker on it saying "god isn't real".

                        Comment

                        • #27
                          Sectional Moderator
                          Sectional Moderator
                          Vendetta21
                          • Aug 2006
                          • 2745

                          Re: Why religion isn't under the same amount of scrutiny?

                          Originally posted by iceefudgesickle
                          When one openly attacks a religion, they're thought of as rude? You joking? People BLATANTLY DESPISE religion, specifically Christianity, in this country, and religion is under copius amounts of scrutiny.
                          This is pretty much all that needed to be said to answer the OP's question. QFE.

                          Comment

                          • #28
                            FFR Player
                            runnerxc
                            • Feb 2007
                            • 18

                            Re: Why religion isn't under the same amount of scrutiny?

                            The idea that religion and science are two non-overlapping realms is not true. Religion makes various claims about the world, as does science. A universe with a god will look very different from a universe without one. Science is concerned with explaining what exists, so the truth claims of religion are directly in conflict with empirical science.

                            Comment

                            • #29
                              FFR Player
                              Necros140606
                              • Jun 2006
                              • 1088

                              Re: Why religion isn't under the same amount of scrutiny?

                              what about this? science usually doesn't tell religion to stop doing something because it's wrong. religion has been telling science to shut up for centuries, now they go all out for contraceptives, genetics, and such. latest thing they've done is saying you can't check the genes of your embryons to see if there will be malformations/genetic diseases. THEY WANT BROKEN HUMANS TO BE BORN BECAUSE,THEY SAY, THE DIFFERENT SHOULDNT BE AVOIDED. yet they burned dissentors and "witches" in the past, and even nowadays people are exorcized. people who most likely need a psichiatric help, not a purification ritual. the amount of contradictions in the religious matters is huge and just cannot be ignored. this alone should keep people far from any religion, but it seems most people still need a sweet lie to feel reassured.
                              Last edited by Necros140606; 12-17-2008, 02:13 AM.

                              Comment

                              • #30
                                caveman pornstar
                                FFR Simfile Author
                                FFR Music Producer
                                dore
                                • Feb 2006
                                • 6317

                                Re: Why religion isn't under the same amount of scrutiny?

                                I'd say religion isn't under as much scrutiny is because religion is unprovable and science can be disprovable, so if you're going to criticize something you're more likely to go for the one you can actually disprove. It's hard to criticize religion because religious people believe in what is set forth in a book, and so any argument relies on whether or not you take that book as valid.
                                http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IREnpHco9mw

                                Comment

                                Working...