TWG CLXXIX: The Third FE Mystery Game Game Thread

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #1411
    Snivy! Dohoho!
    FFR Simfile Author
    Charu
    • Mar 2006
    • 6263

    Re: TWG CLXXIX: The Third FE Mystery Game Game Thread

    Originally posted by Hakulyte
    but at same time this is a bastard game.
    Haku


    Originally posted by JohnRedWolf87
    Charu the red-nosed Snivy
    Had a very shiny nose
    And if you ever saw it
    You could even say it glows

    All of the other Snivies
    Used to laugh and call him names
    They never let poor Charu
    Join in any Snivy games

    (Click the arrow to see the rest)


    Originally posted by Vendetta21
    All in all I would say that Charu not only won this game, his play made me reconsider how I play it.

    Comment

    • #1412
      Accuracy Player
      _Zenith_
      • Mar 2011
      • 4822

      Re: TWG CLXXIX: The Third FE Mystery Game Game Thread

      Originally posted by Hakulyte
      I see your point, but I also think this is also exactly why this was chosen.

      It's so counterintuitive that you don't want to believe it could be true.

      It just feels like the ideal cover for me.

      Anyway, there's better to worry about than spruce D0.
      Understood.





      Comment

      • #1413
        aka Haku
        Hakulyte
        • Jul 2005
        • 4750

        Re: TWG CLXXIX: The Third FE Mystery Game Game Thread

        Originally posted by sprucegrit
        Yes I have. I explained it was from what I got in the shop. I even explained it in my much quoted shop list, "The item I've used to gain special knowledge", And that wasn't just the 6 wolves part, which really I suspected (that there's 6 wolves) from the OP even before given access to the shop. But then yeah, I may have caused a bit of a wet Knuffle Bunny by not combining my shop list with my extra setup info - players have sometimes 'missed' one or the other. but paraphrasing the shop list, checking that it was permissible, and deciding to post it took more time. I agree now I should have waited a bit longer on that, but the name claim stuff was needed right away as players seemed to be posting name claims. I still would have likely posted the shop list sometime today though.
        I still don't understand why you have "extra setup info".

        Comment

        • #1414
          Snivy! Dohoho!
          FFR Simfile Author
          Charu
          • Mar 2006
          • 6263

          Re: TWG CLXXIX: The Third FE Mystery Game Game Thread

          Originally posted by the sun fan
          Pretty much any bastard role. If a role feels like its something star and I wouldn't put in the game, then its probably not in the game.
          ..


          Originally posted by JohnRedWolf87
          Charu the red-nosed Snivy
          Had a very shiny nose
          And if you ever saw it
          You could even say it glows

          All of the other Snivies
          Used to laugh and call him names
          They never let poor Charu
          Join in any Snivy games

          (Click the arrow to see the rest)


          Originally posted by Vendetta21
          All in all I would say that Charu not only won this game, his play made me reconsider how I play it.

          Comment

          • #1415
            Accuracy Player
            _Zenith_
            • Mar 2011
            • 4822

            Re: TWG CLXXIX: The Third FE Mystery Game Game Thread

            Originally posted by Charu
            ..
            Bastard!





            Comment

            • #1416
              aka Haku
              Hakulyte
              • Jul 2005
              • 4750

              Re: TWG CLXXIX: The Third FE Mystery Game Game Thread

              The second part of spruce's claims could be fabricated information. You don't need to roll something specific to say that.

              Comment

              • #1417
                FFR Player
                LightManticorex2
                • May 2006
                • 25

                Re: TWG CLXXIX: The Third FE Mystery Game Game Thread

                Originally posted by Hakulyte
                I still don't understand why you have "extra setup info".
                Why would a mystery game have people who know things????
                Lock clear

                Comment

                • #1418
                  aka Haku
                  Hakulyte
                  • Jul 2005
                  • 4750

                  Re: TWG CLXXIX: The Third FE Mystery Game Game Thread

                  Well, Tokzic conveniently will most likely only appear when I have to leave for work and I'm town reading nearly everyone else who reads this thread.

                  I guess there's no purpose for me here.

                  Comment

                  • #1419
                    FFR Player
                    sprucegrit
                    • Jul 2018
                    • 6

                    Re: TWG CLXXIX: The Third FE Mystery Game Game Thread

                    Originally posted by _Zenith_
                    One question that comes up in my isolation and it is purely speculation but, if anyone else were to have access to the shop and take the item you've used (granted you can even do that), would it give the same information?

                    There's nothing really substantial with this, but it's food for thought to me.
                    It was indicated there would have been variety between the knowledge a villager would receive and the knowledge the other team would receive. I also endeavoured to learn if the item I selected would still be listed or removed, and it was conveyed to me it would still be listed but listed as unavailable.

                    As I've indicated too, there's some good stuff in there - stuff that would have been neat to have and helped me more individually perhaps, though a lot of it was a negative utility for me. I thought about maybe removing items I really wouldn't want wolves to have, but what I chose was a bit of both. It clarified some things for town but also kept wolves from knowing more town set-up info, if indeed wolves have or get access to the shop.

                    I'm still WIFOMing over whether someone on the wolf team got comparable access just after me, but I'm tending to think not, due to the specifics I got. Still, it wouldn't surprise me if the wolf team has more powers than I was told.

                    Comment

                    • #1420
                      Accuracy Player
                      _Zenith_
                      • Mar 2011
                      • 4822

                      Re: TWG CLXXIX: The Third FE Mystery Game Game Thread

                      Originally posted by sprucegrit
                      It was indicated there would have been variety between the knowledge a villager would receive and the knowledge the other team would receive. I also endeavoured to learn if the item I selected would still be listed or removed, and it was conveyed to me it would still be listed but listed as unavailable.

                      As I've indicated too, there's some good stuff in there - stuff that would have been neat to have and helped me more individually perhaps, though a lot of it was a negative utility for me. I thought about maybe removing items I really wouldn't want wolves to have, but what I chose was a bit of both. It clarified some things for town but also kept wolves from knowing more town set-up info, if indeed wolves have or get access to the shop.

                      I'm still WIFOMing over whether someone on the wolf team got comparable access just after me, but I'm tending to think not, due to the specifics I got. Still, it wouldn't surprise me if the wolf team has more powers than I was told.
                      Interesting. The fact that information can be different depending on the alignment tickles my fancy, but I don't think I can use the majority of this post to really help any of my cause at the moment. Would actually like to see how others respond to this and what thoughts this may bring.





                      Comment

                      • #1421
                        aka Haku
                        Hakulyte
                        • Jul 2005
                        • 4750

                        Re: TWG CLXXIX: The Third FE Mystery Game Game Thread

                        Originally posted by sprucegrit
                        It was indicated there would have been variety between the knowledge a villager would receive and the knowledge the other team would receive. I also endeavoured to learn if the item I selected would still be listed or removed, and it was conveyed to me it would still be listed but listed as unavailable.

                        As I've indicated too, there's some good stuff in there - stuff that would have been neat to have and helped me more individually perhaps, though a lot of it was a negative utility for me. I thought about maybe removing items I really wouldn't want wolves to have, but what I chose was a bit of both. It clarified some things for town but also kept wolves from knowing more town set-up info, if indeed wolves have or get access to the shop.

                        I'm still WIFOMing over whether someone on the wolf team got comparable access just after me, but I'm tending to think not, due to the specifics I got. Still, it wouldn't surprise me if the wolf team has more powers than I was told.
                        Can you talk about what I said ? I just read your post as hypothetical information and it goes over my head.

                        Comment

                        • #1422
                          aka Haku
                          Hakulyte
                          • Jul 2005
                          • 4750

                          Re: TWG CLXXIX: The Third FE Mystery Game Game Thread

                          afk 40min then I come back 10min and no more Haku until D2 unless dead.

                          Enjoy.

                          Comment

                          • #1423
                            FFR Player
                            sprucegrit
                            • Jul 2018
                            • 6

                            Re: TWG CLXXIX: The Third FE Mystery Game Game Thread

                            Originally posted by Hakulyte
                            I still don't understand why you have "extra setup info".
                            Well, I'm not claiming my role. I don't know anything about game flavour or the characters of the Sacred Stones. I just know I was given access in my role and had to use it right away or lose it.

                            Comment

                            • #1424
                              Unacceptable
                              Precarious
                              • Mar 2014
                              • 209

                              Re: TWG CLXXIX: The Third FE Mystery Game Game Thread

                              Unvote

                              ISOing mtamburini was interesting. Mtam had no track record here prior to this game, so I interpreted that early post in a sort of void—but his later posts are very FFRish. (By which I mean a lot of rapid fire, off the cuff, sort of sarcastic single sentence posts that are more a snapshot of the thread at the time than the player.) But tonally, it sort of syncs well with the throwaway “I'd rather hunt scum,” which makes it seem more genuine, even if it's still a useless statement. At the same time, there's not a lot of actual content, and mtam's play falls into that disconcerting space where there's just enough activity to simulate involvement without actually committing to any ideas (which was one of my main criticisms underpinning the initial vote). The tone is also brusque enough that it comes off as vaguely defensive.

                              I also didn't like this post:

                              Originally posted by mtamburini
                              If you don’t know who I think is town and scum from my few posts then I don’t know what to tell you except to read again
                              There hadn't been much in terms of reads from mtam outside of obviously scum-reading mellon, some general annoyance with Celirra, and an early town read. Most of his posts had been either sort of annoyed/sarcastic, or comments on the number of pages in the thread. So again, his falls into the same zone as my initial read: implying something that isn't there.

                              However, given how quickly mtam adopted a conventional TWG playstyle, combined with his willingness to be forceful, suggests someone with an understanding of the game. That he was willing to just explicitly say he was going to play Fortnite instead, and had to ask about how to vote and EOD, suggests a player who isn't interacting with anyone else (i.e. wolves) outside the thread. Those questions, at least, felt genuine.

                              Overall, I lean pretty close to null on mtam right now, which isn't imo sufficient to continue holding a vote. There's a sort of defensiveness to his posts that's concerning, but that's counterbalanced by the sort of generalized aggression that feels more like frustrated town.

                              Comment

                              • #1425
                                aka Haku
                                Hakulyte
                                • Jul 2005
                                • 4750

                                Re: TWG CLXXIX: The Third FE Mystery Game Game Thread

                                Originally posted by sprucegrit
                                Well, I'm not claiming my role. I don't know anything about game flavour or the characters of the Sacred Stones. I just know I was given access in my role and had to use it right away or lose it.
                                You could be a random VT who somehow received something early game from someone else or something.

                                This is just odd to me.

                                I don't care about game flavour/characters. I only cared about why you knew "extra info".

                                Being forced to use something right away or lose it could also fit into a wolf role.

                                Comment

                                Working...