TWG CXXXVI - An Extended Sonic Universe Fanfic by Ronnie Darkshadow GAME THREAD

[TWG Scourge Hedgehog]

Re: TWG CXXXVI - An Extended Sonic Universe Fanfic by Ronnie Darkshadow GAME THREAD

I'm here now. Reads time.

[TWG Scourge Hedgehog]

Re: TWG CXXXVI - An Extended Sonic Universe Fanfic by Ronnie Darkshadow GAME THREAD

also I'm glad replacements for dan and rachel are doing some work holy shit I feel bad now

[TWG Michele Hedgehog]

Re: TWG CXXXVI - An Extended Sonic Universe Fanfic by Ronnie Darkshadow GAME THREAD

Errr...vote pattern should be GST for mine, not Alicia plop xD

[TWG Michele Hedgehog]

Re: TWG CXXXVI - An Extended Sonic Universe Fanfic by Ronnie Darkshadow GAME THREAD

also I'm glad replacements for dan and rachel are doing some work holy shit I feel bad now

Gotta go balls to the walls at this point since the game has been pathetically bland. Especially some of the player's excuse is "Oh. cop died. Time to not give a shit anymore." Though I'm interested in seeing your reads Scourge~

[TWG Scourge Hedgehog]

Re: TWG CXXXVI - An Extended Sonic Universe Fanfic by Ronnie Darkshadow GAME THREAD

I'm slow at making detailed reads so I'm just gonna post them in chunks of 2 players as I finish them

[TWG Scourge Hedgehog]

Re: TWG CXXXVI - An Extended Sonic Universe Fanfic by Ronnie Darkshadow GAME THREAD

1. Mike the Hedgehog

Promised a reads list, but said "y'know, fuck it" because they didn't like the current game's progress even though there was PLENTY of evidence to go after from the previous Ends of Day. It's not completely alignment indicative, but the "ASK ME QUESTIONS BECAUSE I'M LAZY" doesn't really line up with his idea that he hates the thread. How do you answer questions if you don't read, y'know? The other replacements are putting him to shame, though. Not sure if it's worth keeping a stubborn player alive atm, but I think it's better we lynch from the non-replacement pool.
However, looking at his interaction with Dan was interesting. He flat out calls Dan's reads and observations "irrelevant", and even boasts he has reads that he's not posting "simply because the embodiment of this game lacks severely". Withholding the bulk of his reads for a fire drill, maybe? Being openly defiant? I really don't like Mike's vibes. He's made some contributions, but at the same time a few of his posts have been commentary on other reads.

Also whoever said it was going to be mylo or lylo if a town gets lynched this phase, whereas you may be correct; it is particular to wolves who pay attention to lylo/mylo before town reaches said phase, from my understanding.

It's perfectly logical for a panicked town to also say the above because they don't want to send town into that situation.

Also, this generalization makes me laugh. I know you included that last line about "a town might have done it too", but you might have as well called him a wolf at this juncture.
Openly admitting he has been withholding information is the biggest reason why I'm labeling him as scummy for now.

2. Dan the Hedgehog Mk.II

I like Mk.II significantly more than Mk.I. As I mentioned above, I don't want to lynch from the replacement pool, and I especially don't want to lynch Dan. Probably ever after his Paul/GST effort post. He points out something I didn't notice (GST putting the vote into a KitB first) and it's good to see. The only thing I can ask of him is why he picked GST and Paul as his read targets. Other than that, this guy is hard town.

3. GST the Hedgehog

I have absolutely no fucking idea why you put the vote into a KitB last phase. I mean, your play at the first EoD was towny in my eyes as I admitted before, but doing a similar charade AGAIN is setting off warning bells. Even the way he entered last vote is a fucking train wreck:

Don't think Alicia is a werehog guys

Destiny

Also apologies for being inactive and yadda yadda yadda.

Saw the cop die and lost interest hard since no one else seemed to be paying much interest either.

Dead cop apathy card, defending someone because they "don't think they're a werehog guys" and then posting 0 justification for this opinion, ding ding ding we have a wolf candidate.

4. Scourge the Hedgehog
Iamme

in retrospect, this post looks tiny as fuck

[TWG Scourge Hedgehog]

Re: TWG CXXXVI - An Extended Sonic Universe Fanfic by Ronnie Darkshadow GAME THREAD

5. Paul the Hedgehog

I'm still not liking Paul one bit. Nothing has changed about my opinion from last EoD phase.

7. Alicia the Hedgehog

The play at last EoD is somewhat confusing to me. There was no guarantee that someone was going to show up to bail them out of the lynch crosshair, so I'm not sure what to think of them not self-preserving by voting Destiny. I wonder if she would have made the choice of GST didn't come to bail her out. I would imagine so. Her justification was that she would die to out a wolf (after the fact, of course). I'm not sure what to think of this.
The things I haven't liked are her vote on Peter yesterday (which was completely weak and reactionary) and then the "oliver is a wolf fuck you guys I'm out" vote today. Kinda funny after this post:

ggwp oliver and peter, i think i may have forced you both into a corner
i am going to build cases on both of you tonight
if im nightkilled i think the cases will be enough to get both of you killed
if im not nightkilled i will control the day and will tear both of you new holes to shove 100 rings into because your gonna need extra lives

I still want to kill Paul over her, but I think this is a good lynch.

10. Michele the Hedgehog
confirmed green and is using their spot well, what more should I say


11. Aaron the Hedgehog

As a wolf, I don't think he would make the kill on Peter and post this:

First, I wonder WHAT KIND OF JOKERS WOULD WOLF PETER. Especially when THEY HAD AT LEAST ONE POTENTIAL MISLYNCH LINED UP FROM THAT. Seriously, this is making me s-s-s-strangely mad. It's... it's as if they're p-p-playing with us, toying with our minds, making us think we're closer on the path to victory when in fact we are no better off than before. As if they KNOW we cannot do anything right in this situation, as if the ARE SO CERTAIN of their imminent victory that they would be willing to take a risk like that.

Or maybe they just didn't like Peter.

This could be WIFOM and I'd be shooting myself in the head postgame, but this is just too blaring and obvious that I'm now feeling better about Aaron. That and his interaction with him over the night would just make this NK look stupid. I think this is a frame job for Aaron. My biggest suspicions of him for the other two phases were of him using his posting style as cover for their identity.

Maybe I'm just b-biased, but I don't see anything wrong w-with it. To me, it's a fair vote, with fair reasoning to m-match.

I reread this post and found it to be strange. He says he agrees with Paul's vote because he has good reasons for it, but my biggest problem with Paul's vote is the fact that he hasn't fucking stated any deep reasoning. Aaron at least put more work in justifying his Destiny vote, but this is a weird defense of Paul.

Less certain about Alicia after this post, but feeling more certain ab-b-bout Paul from his reply.

It would be a g-g-g-good idea to talk as much as possible today.

I would like him to clarify what he means by "less certain and more certain" in this post. Is it in reference to their towniness? Because that's how I'm reading it. I agree with his stance on Alicia's post. Also would like to hear from him before EoD. For being a non-replacement, he sure has very little posts.

Tomorrow, I want to lynch one of Scourge or Peter. I t-think their interactions during the last day phase are really bizarre, almost as if they were getting complacent because of the inactivity and let slip that they could be w-working in conjunction as wolves. If one of them is a wolf, I f-feel like that would 100% confirm the other as wolf. At this point, with all the inactivity, our efforts are essentially shots in the dark, but I feel like one of their lynches w-would really help us sort thing out. Among o-other reasons to lynch them, of course! Note this is j-just one example.

I also wonder if he still feels this way. I'm going to put him at town lean because of the night kill and his response to it. I want to hear what he has to say about Oliver, Mike, and Dan before considering a different opinion on him.

one left!!

[TWG Paul Hedgehog]

Re: TWG CXXXVI - An Extended Sonic Universe Fanfic by Ronnie Darkshadow GAME THREAD

Regardless of what alignment Dan is, I love him.

[TWG Paul Hedgehog]

Re: TWG CXXXVI - An Extended Sonic Universe Fanfic by Ronnie Darkshadow GAME THREAD

From that pool, I think that we're more likely to land one wolf in here.

^ I like the logic of the whole post leading to this, but this sentence in particular seems like a bit of a freudian slip. I gotta go back and re-read everything she has said. But out of what has been said for the whole day so far, this I find most questionable.

Besides when Dan flipped out and went on a 10 post rampage, which was awesome.

[TWG Scourge Hedgehog]

Re: TWG CXXXVI - An Extended Sonic Universe Fanfic by Ronnie Darkshadow GAME THREAD

12. Oliver Hedgehog

His biggest clash in the thread has been with Alicia. The fact they've both been KitB targets makes this for a really fucking weird relationship. Alicia said I was potentially cleared, and he picked that apart, which was a good call out. He gave me (and a bunch of other people) a blanket towny read later in the thread.
He dropped his case off of Alicia after the KitB because of her lack of votes. His thoughts on other players had something interesting:

Paul and Dan stick out to me the most at the moment. The Peter death is weird so it leads me to believe it is someone who is not participating a great deal in the thread, and Paul seems pretty towny.

...

Paul because he literally sat on an extremely thin destiny read for the entire game and then gave Mike town points for saying the game is mostly white noise, and doing it shortly after he was shocked at the burst of activity (which didn't really seem like white noise.) If you're an inactive wolf calling shit white noise is a pretty convenient way to disengage from the game.

...

What gives with the 180?
His voting and suspicion logic has been consistent (aside from what I said above, but since this was inter-post rather than thread-wide) as his current suspicions are on Mike (Willy slot + observations) and Dan (before Mk.II, would like to see his new opinion and verdict). He has a very critical and aggressive tone. I trusted him yesterday with his Alicia vote because I have liked his observations so far, but I would still like to hear what he thinks about Michele, Dan Mk.II, and Mike now that they've all contributed some posts. Town lean for me.

[TWG Paul Hedgehog]

Re: TWG CXXXVI - An Extended Sonic Universe Fanfic by Ronnie Darkshadow GAME THREAD

Oh wait, was Michele the n0?

[TWG Scourge Hedgehog]

Re: TWG CXXXVI - An Extended Sonic Universe Fanfic by Ronnie Darkshadow GAME THREAD

that took longer than I thought

gonna place a paul vote for now

[TWG Scourge Hedgehog]

Re: TWG CXXXVI - An Extended Sonic Universe Fanfic by Ronnie Darkshadow GAME THREAD

Oh wait, was Michele the n0?

this is the second time you've asked this and it's still the same answer (albeit first time was about rachel, who is the same slot): yes

[TWG Paul Hedgehog]

Re: TWG CXXXVI - An Extended Sonic Universe Fanfic by Ronnie Darkshadow GAME THREAD

Fuck, Rachel = Michele. Why are there so many replacements??

But wait why didn't she die last night if she is technically confirmed?

[TWG Michele Hedgehog]

Re: TWG CXXXVI - An Extended Sonic Universe Fanfic by Ronnie Darkshadow GAME THREAD

^ I like the logic of the whole post leading to this, but this sentence in particular seems like a bit of a freudian slip. I gotta go back and re-read everything she has said. But out of what has been said for the whole day so far, this I find most questionable.

Besides when Dan flipped out and went on a 10 post rampage, which was awesome.

I'm sorry for thinking a bit realistic :T But look at it this way: at this point in this game, you really need to hunt. And you have given NO justification for that vote on Destiny. So don't question me on that until you fucking tell us what the fuck that bullshit vote was about.