Idea for the next jTWG

[rzr]

Re: Idea for the next jTWG

BDN, I really hope you're including the special roles among the total human count. Otherwise, wolves might as well not play. Also, if you're still going for the original idea of not playing follow the leader, you're still off. I'm not sure why people aren't getting it, but you can't have special roles in the game without someone going to follow them. As long as they're human. It's either everyone's special, or nobody's special.

P.S. Shadow, are you really trying to tell me that a game where one wolf against x humans is the easiest wolf victory ever? Because... Yeah.

[Ruritsu]

Re: Idea for the next jTWG

^Rzr, I don't think his complaint was about bandwagoning players, but was about the whole Seer + Gaurd combo, which would be less possible to do if, there was a chance that there wasn't a gaurd (Or seer for that matte >.>) >_>

Correct me if I'm wrong Neon...

Or better yet, just ignore me...

[rzr]

Re: Idea for the next jTWG

Well, the balance of BDN's game feels shaky to me. Something about 5 blues on 4 wolves makes me wonder. The Red Miller helps, but... Some sort of cursed human would probably be good. Dunno, it'd be a lot of fun. The thing is, if the humans knock a wolf off in the beginning the wolves are at bad odds. The game could either be great or go quick and suck. Hopefully, it'll be good.

@ Ruritsu: If he's going for the original goal he's failed miserably. If he's just looking to make a cool game he's succeeded.

[Brilliant Dynamite Neon]

Re: Idea for the next jTWG

BDN, I really hope you're including the special roles among the total human count. Otherwise, wolves might as well not play.

Why on earth would I not include them?

Also, if you're still going for the original idea of not playing follow the leader, you're still off. I'm not sure why people aren't getting it, but you can't have special roles in the game without someone going to follow them. As long as they're human. It's either everyone's special, or nobody's special.

Well of course people are going to rely on the blues' powers. That's what they're there for: to help humans. However, the point of this game is to not totally eliminate dependence on blues but diminish it to the point that greens can actually play. There may not be a seer, and even if there is, they might not provide results (especially if there's no guard.) Thus, the rest of the humans are more encouraged to go out and talk to people get info, and check for liars, which is what they're supposed to do.

Well, the balance of BDN's game feels shaky to me. Something about 5 blues on 4 wolves makes me wonder. The Red Miller helps, but... Some sort of cursed human would probably be good. Dunno, it'd be a lot of fun. The thing is, if the humans knock a wolf off in the beginning the wolves are at bad odds. The game could either be great or go quick and suck. Hopefully, it'll be good.

Cursed Human would only add another potential confirmed human, which with the format of the game can already climb to 5 - nearly a third of the game's players.

@ Ruritsu: If he's going for the original goal he's failed miserably. If he's just looking to make a cool game he's succeeded.

LOL

white text